NP Rank:
Cry, Freedom. Again.
The right to freely opine on the web is becoming more difficult by the day. Whereas in America people may stir up controversy over some remaks they make, there is no specific law that can silence their sentiments. As long as the writer remains courteous and follows the basic rules of Net Etiquette, he/she may continue opining widely and freely.
Not so in the world's largest Democracy, which now seeks to rule on the issue of what and how much Indian Bloggers may say. There is now a growing fear that a 19-year-old Kerala blogger is in danger of not just losing in the criminal case filed against him, but also losing his life.
[q url="http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/4178823.cms?TOI_mostcommented"]Petitioner Ajith D had started a community on Orkut against Shiv Sena. In this community, there were several posts and discussions by anonymous persons who alleged that Shiv Sena was trying to divide the country on region and caste basis. Reacting to these posts, the Shiv Sena youth wing's state secretary registered a criminal complaint at Thane police station in August 2008 based on which FIR was registered against Ajith under Sections 506 and 295A pertaining to hurting public sentiment. [/q]
The Shiv Sena at its very basic is a controversial Hindu Nationalist Group that claims to be in favor of the common man's rights to a better society....with them at the helm. Although they seem to have the support of the Mumbai slumdwellers and the Dalits (who have nowhere to turn to for the most part) the general consensus is that the Shiv Sena need to be disbanded for their antiquated, overly-moralistic views. Like this
Look at our country. Our laws. Our rules. A whole long list of don'ts meant only for Hindus. And who are the ones who are empowered? The Mussalmans. How long are we to tolerate this? How long are we to stand by and watch these antics in the name of religion? How long will those in power fool us? How long can we pretend not to see what goes on in the name of concession to the so-called minorities?... Let us have a little laugh over our peculiar brand of secularism. The microphones blare at us spreading the word of Allah a good five times a day. But no Hindu can dare to play cymbals or beat the prayer drums while he passes the house of Allah.
~ from http://www.geocities.com/indianfascism/fascism/shivsena.htm
Check out the Solution to the Christian and Muslim Problem
I do not claim to know any more about the Shiv Sena than I did 10 years ago and I do not wish to know any more about them after this case is settled. Just a day after I mentioned Francois Matthys who was robbed of his Freedom and his health and his sanity in a Mumbai jail on trumped-up charges, along comes the explosive Times of India article called 'Bloggers Can Be Nailed For Views'
Read the outraged Indian Bloggers' comments !
Recommendations (19)
-
Barbara McPherson
Nanaimo, Canada -
Fripouille
Lyon, France -
Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan




Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (5)
at 20:36 on February 25th, 2009
This was all intended to be a follow-up to Uwe Paschen's prophetic item called
Are the Days of Free Speech on Countdown ?
and I decided this was the next in a long line of similar ones to surface in the days ahead, so I'm writing the next chapter, that's all.
at 23:16 on February 25th, 2009
This is a great post and reminder as well as warning. The Freedom of Speech and expression is under attack and in grave danger globally. I just read an e-mail last night from a relative in Europe that received a fine of 3000 Euro for his Blog on the internet because he has a song on there that is not his, yet it is an old folk song sang by a group of folk singers... Same in Niger however there more grave an issue two more Journalist where arrested last week and on previously arrested Journalist was send to the labour camp in the desert.
This in a country that calls it self democratic and upholding the freedom of speech and the press. Excusing the arrest as irresponsible Journalism propagating lies about the Government. ....
Thank you for the Post Fred.
at 02:27 on February 26th, 2009
Thanks for posting this Fred. This is a good example of the nightmare scenario. I mean, it's bad enough being harassed by your government, but at least governments change, and (thank god) laws exist to stop excesses of abuse in many countries.
But when you use the state apparatus to attack people on the grounds of their religious views and beliefs, the door to totalitarianism is wide open, because religions are not elected, therefore the most influential religious body can silence its opponents just because the powers-that-be share their beliefs....
Scary, and a threat to secularism and, ultimately, democracy.
at 10:52 on February 26th, 2009
The previous comments just about say it all. But, don't think that in N. America the 'word sifter' apparatus isn't in place already.
at 23:47 on February 25th, 2009
Interesting Opinion. I will have to read through all the links firs before being able to make a opinion my self on this. Good post Fred. I like it though.
I do not agree with tit for tad though. nor with Demonizing a religion or faith or political opinion. Freedom is for all.
"The Freedom of the one does start where the freedom of the other ends and vice versa."