Solar Flare Precursors are Electric! But What About Venus?

by mgmirkin | May 16, 2009 at 02:27 am
198 views | 42 Recommendations | 5 comments

Photos

Solar Sigmoids vs. Venusian Double-Eyed Polar Vortices (Comparison)

Solar Sigmoids vs. Venusian Double-Eyed Polar Vortices (Comparison)

see larger image

uploaded by mgmirkin

Well, it seems they're finally figuring out that solar flares originate from powerful electric currents.

'Sigmoids' are S-shaped structures found in the outer atmosphere of the Sun (the corona), seen with X-ray telescopes and thought to be a crucial part of explosive events like solar flares. Now a group of astronomers have developed the first model to reproduce and explain the nature of the different stages of a sigmoid’s life.
Recently, the X-Ray Telescope (XRT) on board the Hinode space mission was used to obtain the first images of the formation and eruption phase of a sigmoid at high resolution. These observations revealed that the structure of the sigmoid is complex: it consists of many, differently oriented, loops that all together form two opposite J-like bundles or an overall S-shape. They also showed that at the end of its life the sigmoid produces a 'flare' eruption.
The new model describes how sigmoids consist of many thin and twisted layers (or ribbons) of strong electric current. When these layers interact it leads to the formation of the observed powerful flares and the eruption of strong magnetic fields which carry highly energetic particles into interplanetary space. The team also found that as the sigmoids die out, they produce a ‘flare’ eruption.
“Sigmoids work as ‘mangers’ or ‘cocoons’ for solar eruptions. There is a high probability that they will result in powerful eruptions and other explosive events. Our model helps scientists understand how this happens.”

So, basically, the sigmoids are large electrical currents. Sheets of current, with many filaments.

One wonders whether the researchers modeling solar sigmoids have considered the implications of their findings for other bodies in the solar system?

Specifically, here, I suggest they look closely at Venus's poles, at the "double-eyed vortices". More specifically, they should take a close look at the detailed VIRTIS images beamed back from Venus express. Do the features match as well as a casual morphological comparison appears to imply? If so, have they accidentally solved the mystery of Venus' poles via electrodynamics?

...we are still not able to explain why the global atmospheric circulation of the planet results in a double and not single vortex formation at the poles.

If so, they should really get a hold of Wallace Thornhill and let him know that his 2006 electrodynamic interpretation, though controversial, may be correct.

Venus Express science team members say they want to know how these vortices remain stable and where they get their energy. This goes to the heart of what drives the super-rotating upper atmosphere of Venus. So I repeat and expand here some of the closing comments from my Feb 5, 2005 article.

Venus, as shown by its cometary magnetosphere (plasmasphere), is still discharging strongly to the solar plasma. The enhanced infrared emission seen from the polar dipole is due to the dissipation of electrical energy in the upper atmosphere of Venus. The polar dipole has a variable rotation rate and it varies the position of its axis of rotation with respect to that of the planet. It was observed to move 500 km from the Venusian pole in less than a day and return just as quickly. The variable nature of the electrical input to Venus via the Sun and the snaking about of the Birkeland currents explain both these characteristics.

Of particular interest are the linear filaments sometimes seen connecting the opposite sides of the hot spots. Taylor writes: "It is virtually impossible, even with complete license, to begin to speculate in any detail as to what mechanism could give rise to such a curious effect." The answer, in the Electric Universe model is simple. They are a feature seen in simulations of the behavior between two converging Birkeland current filaments where plasma becomes trapped in the elliptical core between them.

In fact, Thornhill has also speculated (with preliminary evidence from the Cassini probe's CIRS [Composite Infrared Spectrometer] instrument) that a similar feature will be found central to the polar vortices at Saturn as well. Though data is as yet insufficient to make a positive determination one way or the other.

It should be noted that Thornhill also predicted experimentum crucis that, upon observation, Saturn's northern antisunward (winter) pole would be found to have a hot spot to rival that of its southern sunward (summer) pole, in contradiction to the "seasonal" hypothesis. Such was found to be the case, much to the surprise of mission scientists.

Is it possible that electrodynamics (the study of currents, circuits and magnetic fields) will inevitably be the field to yield answers to many of the current unanswered questions in space science?

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Paschen

Interesting and most fascinating.

Did you look into whether the researchers have considered their findings to be compared to other Solar systems?

1
mgmirkin

I don't know about sigmoids, per se. As we don't generally have fine enough resolution on measurements of other solar systems to see that level of detail. Most "solar systems" are inferred from one or two pixels of a large image that fluctuate over time... The theory being that a planet or other body is moving between the star and us. *Shrug*

But, regarding solar flares in general, yes, I think there has been talk (maybe not by these specific researchers) about whether solar flare data can be in any way used as some kind of a standard theory that could be applied to other stars. IE, are solar flares limite to our star, or do all stars go through them? Don't know if they've riddled that one out yet, as they have a hard enough time figuring out how and why solar flares and general magnetic fields exist in / on / around our own star. Let alone the corona problem, among others. I would assume, however, that our star would not be unlike any / all others.

There is an alternate paradigm (much maligned at present) wherein stars are not assumed to be nuclear furnaces, but anodes in large discharges with color / temperature / activity regulated by the level of current impinging on the star's surface. If that's the case then solar activity and cycles may be derived from that and one would expect similar processes to lead to similar results. But anyway, won't get too far into that here. I have my own views, moderately aligned with some of the non-standard line of thinking. But am trying to moderate any agenda-pushing and stick to mostly reporting (but with a little nudge here & there where I think a correction or specific connection needs to be made).

1
amyjudd

An interesting step for sure, now it seems that they just have to connect the dots on this... good piece!

1
Smile

Get Wal on Facebook and see if his he's heard anything more about this. I'm still convinced the EU/ electrodynamics are not properly understood by astrophysics...so I'm not so sure they can so easily connect the dots as Amy suggests. Gosh test  in on Physics Forum - it wouldn't last 2 minutes. My infraction was for mentioning  EU/z-pinch...only to be told - Electric Universe is NONSENCE and not to mention it again. I kept a copy - saving it for the day EU is acknowledged officially....

Anyway the connection you make between double vortex on Venus poles and solar vortices certainly suggests some correlation....

0
Tomitheos

interesting science theories and summary, the photo-visuals compliment the information, well constructed article, good work Michael

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Paschen
First Flagged at 3:41 AM, May 16, 2009 by Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (42)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from