UK bookstore yanks racist Tintin comic

by Kaitlin | July 13, 2007 at 08:34 am
1076 views | 0 Recommendations | 3 comments

Videos

Abertura do desenho "As Aventuras de TinTin"

see larger video

sourced by Kaitlin

Abertura do desenho "As Aventuras de TinTin"

Photos

Tintin muren

Tintin muren

see larger image

uploaded by Ane Cecilie

I grew up reading both Tintin and the Asterix comics. My stepmother's family is European, and the Tintin graphic novels have long been a part of the growing up process in many European households. I was handed many a second- or third-hand Tintin book in my youth.

Now, it has been somewhat accepted that a spirit of post-colonial, pre-WWII European worldview pervades Tintin's pages. That is to say: The Adventures of Tintin are full of racism. I can't lie; I read them, and I understood that then as I do now. That's why I find this story interesting: a man shopping with his family in a UK Borders bookstore picked up a copy of Tintin in the Congo and, shocked by the book's racism, filed a complaint. The store subsequently pulled the book from its shelves.

The book is the second in a series of 23 tracing the adventures of Tintin, an intrepid reporter, and his dog Snowy. The series has sold 220 million copies worldwide and been translated into 77 languages.

But Tintin in the Congo has been widely criticized as racist by fans and critics alike.

Now, understand that Tintin in the Congo was first published in 1931. That is not an excuse, merely an explanation. White Belgians (like Tintin creator Herge) were generally disdainful of the colonies then, including the Congo. I understand where David Enright--the man who asked for the book to be pulled--is coming from (it's worth noting that Enright's wife is African) and his shock at encountering this racism in the kid's section of the store. On the other hand--it's a 76 year old graphic novel that is a snapshot of the mind of a nation at that time. Surely there's historical value in that, lessons about the past that you may wish to impart on your children?

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
insaniac

Even as a child I remember finding the Tintin books to be rather racist (and old-fashioned). They are, taken as a whole, more of a museum piece now- I am not sure how many of today's yoof read them anymore. Rather than getting banned, I believe the books should be discussed as a by-product of colonialism, of which most of Europe has engaged in.

0
cmbellman

I agree that Tintin in the Congo portraits black africans as low intelligent people and funny looking. It's a delicate matter now, even as you point out that this was the spirit at the time making Georges Remi (Herge) no worse than the average man. But how shall we look at it today? For me it's easy though. The books has a special place in my heart ever since I was a child, and I know that I still consider all people equally worth even if I read my old tintin books every now and then.

0
REBECCA ONLY

I think the accusation is a peccadillo, really. There are probably alot worse stuff in the bookshelf, that isn't considered. I don't belive Hergé wrote from his own point of view and that his intentions were to bring out a racist message. But that he was picturing the former society, which was back in the 1930's and probably was a bit more racist. Also listening to black people's opinions about this, most of them don't seem to be bothered.
Either way you turn it, in the end tintin is always a hero!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from