UPDATE - Low Risk of TB Exposure from Infected Traveller

by shmoomie | May 29, 2007 at 04:31 pm
1622 views | 22 Recommendations | 5 comments

Photos

Loading photos...

RE: Highly Infectious TB: Air Travellers Exposed

[q
url="http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20070529/tb_traveller_070530/20070530?hub=TopStories"]Updated
Wed. May. 30 2007 9:49 AM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

A public health official won't rule out the possibility that a man
with tuberculosis who travelled aboard two trans-Atlantic flights this
month infected Canadians -- but he said the chances are low.

The man is believed to be infected with a strain of the disease
known as XDR TB, so labelled because it is considered extremely drug
resistant.

He departed Atlanta, Ga. for Paris on May 12 aboard Air France
Flight 385, then flew back to North America aboard Czech Air Flight
0104 from Prague, Czech Republic last Thursday, landing in Montreal,
then driving to the U.S.

"In general for Canadians and for their fellow passengers on this
flight, there's no need to worry," Dr. Howard Njoo of the Public Health
Agency of Canada told CTV's Canada AM.

He said modern jet planes are equipped with air filters that are designed to screen out the tuberculosis bacilli.

"The risk of transmission is considered to be very low; however, we
cannot say definitively that the risk is zero and therefore we are
undertaking certain public health measures."

Njoo said officials are tracking down passengers who sat near the
man -- an American citizen whose name has not been released -- and
alerting their local health officials to the need for TB screening.

Health authorities in the U.S. and a number of other countries are doing the same thing, but are also playing down the risk.

"We have no suspicion that this patient was highly infectious (when
he was travelling)," CDC Director Dr. Julie Gerberding said during a
teleconference from Atlanta on Tuesday.

"In fact, the medical evidence would suggest that his potential for
transmission would be on the low side," she added, "but we know it
isn't zero."

The strain of TB can be fatal, especially in people infected with
HIV, and as with other forms of TB, can be spread through the air.

The Public Health Agency of Canada is asking any passengers who were on the flight to call 1 866 225 0709.

Infectious disease specialist Dr. Neil Rau told Canada AM that TB is
still a common problem in developing nations, among the homeless and in
prisons, and said there has been a resurgence of the disease in North
America in recent years, due in part to immigration from developing
nations.

He said treatment of the drug-resistant form of the disease involves
placement in a sanatorium, quarantine and an extensive drug regime.

"And then the other big implication of course is if someone is
exposed, you don't know what you can really give them and that's going
to be the case on this airplane flight," Rau said Wednesday.

"If someone really is believed to be infected ... you simply have to
wait and see whether those people develop the disease and that period
could be months years or decades," he said.

Senior CNN medical correspondent Sanjay Gupta, reporting from Grady
Memorial Hospital in Atlanta, told Canada AM on that tuberculosis is
spread through the air, often by coughing or sneezing.

The man in question didn't appear to have those sumptoms and "it
appears he has a pretty low likelihood of actually being contagious,"
Gupta said on Wednesday. However, he agreed there is still a risk to
other passengers.

"The flip side is that he was in an enclosed space for several hours
with several other people around him -- that's a very unusal situation.
We know tuberculosis rates in prison are higher, for example, because
of that close contact, and that's a concern as well."

"I'd be concerned, if I was sitting next to the gentleman, and I'd want to be tested."[/q]

 

Posted Previously:

 

Sure you think of a plane crash, a crying baby ruining your sleep, even the
common cold disseminating through the recycled air system, but this
announcement makes air travel seem even more dangerous.

Air travellers possibly exposed to man with TB

Updated Tue. May. 29 2007 7:27 PM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

Public health authorities in the U.S., Canada and a number of other countries are searching for people who travelled with a man infected with drug-resistant tuberculosis.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control said the man -- an American citizen -- travelled to Paris on May 12. He then took Czech Airlines flight 0104 on May 24 from Prague to Montreal. From there, he drove into the United States.

"We have no suspicion that this patient was highly infectious (when he was travelling)," CDC Director Dr. Julie Gerberding said during a teleconference from Atlanta on Tuesday.

"In fact, the medical evidence would suggest that his potential for transmission would be on the low side," she added, "but we know it isn't zero."

The type of tuberculosis the man is believed to be infected with is called extensively drug resistant TB (XDR-TB), which is a multiple-drug resistant form of tuberculosis.

This disease can be fatal, especially in people infected with HIV, and as with other forms of TB, can be spread through the air.

The Public Health Agency of Canada is asking any passengers who were on the flight to call 1 866 225 0709.

"On airplanes they re-circulate air, and there have actually been outbreaks that have been unusually severe in terms of the number of people secondarily infected," said Dr. Neil Rau, an infectious diseases specialist in Toronto.

"So it's not just the person sitting next to the original case that's of concern. It's also the person sitting many aisles down ... Hopefully, there wasn't much bacteria that (the infected individual) was coughing up."

The CDC said the man has been hospitalized in respiratory isolation since May 25 -- and he is undergoing additional medical evaluation in Atlanta.

Gerberding said the CDC is concerned not only about the man's ability to transmit the disease, but the "seriousness of this organism and the chance that some passenger on this plane could be at serious risk for tuberculosis."

"In this case, the infected patient travelled on two trans-Atlantic air flights and, in doing so, may have exposed passengers and crew to XDR-TB," the agency said.

"A federal quarantine order has been issued and CDC is currently collaborating with U.S., state and local health departments, international ministries of health, the airline industry, and WHO (World Health Organization)."

The quarantine order is believed to be the first since 1963.

The CDC's Gerberding said the air passengers don't pose a risk to other people immediately because tuberculosis takes a long time to incubate.

Her agency isn't recommending mandatory testing of all passengers on the two aircraft.

"This would be part of a personal decision of their own health risk assessment," she said.

"But we would strongly recommend that those people seated next to the passenger and two rows behind him and two rows in front of him to be followed for a baseline skin test to make sure they weren't infected in the past and to be retested in several weeks to make sure they don't have an incubating TB infection," Gerberding said.

The man travelled to Europe on Air France Flight 385, leaving Atlanta, Ga. (where he is a resident) on May 12 and arriving in Paris on May 13.

After arriving in Montreal on May 24, it's believed he then drove to New York City, first crossing the border between Lacolle, Que., and Champlain, N.Y.

Officials with the Montreal Public Health Department said the city's residents should not be concerned about infection.

"You're only infectious with tuberculosis when you have the disease in your lungs. So having just been exposed -- or even being infected -- doesn't put you at any risk for anybody else," the department's Dr. Terry-Ann Tannenbaum told CTV Montreal.

"So in this case the only concern that we might have is for passengers in Montreal who were on the flight. The person then left Montreal and the period of time that the patient spent in Montreal was just not enough to make us concerned at all."

The CDC said the man had been advised by public health authorities in Georgia that he should not travel. But it's not clear whether he knew at the time of his departure that he was carrying the XDR-TB strain.

XDR-TB is very rare in North America:

* In the U.S., there were only two cases last year and a total of 49 between 2003 and 2006.

* Canada had one case in 2003 and another in 2006.

* Tuberculosis rates in general have been falling in the U.S. The all-time low of 13,767 cases was reached last year, about 4.6 cases per 100,000 Americans.

* In Canada, there were 1,616 cases in 2005, or about five cases for every 100,000 Canadians.

* Foreign-born Canadians account for 63 per cent of the cases. Worldwide, tuberculosis kills about two million people per year.

With files from Associated Press

recommend This comment thread is now closed
Brian A Kennedy
Brian A Kennedy
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 02:08 on May 30th, 2007

Yikes -- I think I saw a horror movie that started out this way...

Jordan Yerman
Jordan Yerman
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 06:24 on May 30th, 2007

Both 28 Days Later and 12 Monkeys featured apocalyptic superviruses. On airlines, though, the air is unusually dry, and therefore not especially conducive to the spread of airborne pathogens. Surfaces, though, remain a vector, so bring hand sanitizer... in tiny, tiny bottles, of course.

Kaitlin
Kaitlin
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:31 on May 30th, 2007

Thanks, shmoomie. It's such a weird thing...like we're going to enter 28 Days Later territory or something. Great work.

0
Kaitlin

Haha...I didn't read the other comments first. Can you tell?

rahul
rahul
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 10:50 on May 30th, 2007

shmoomie, you've convinced me with this scientific clarification. Good stuff.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from