When Good Monks Go Bad

by kerren | August 17, 2007 at 12:49 pm
600 views | 30 Recommendations | 8 comments

Photos

Copy of DSCN0340

Copy of DSCN0340

see larger image

uploaded by niel kusumsiri

A mystery plaguing the New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife may
be solved. For years they have been investigating the cause of foreign
creatures appearing in New Jersey rivers. It hadn't occurred to them to
be on the lookout for Buddhist monks.

One of the basic tenets of Buddhism is the divinity of human and non-human life.
This may be the reason that a Buddhist sect located in Queens, New York
decided to liberate several hundred eels, bullfrogs and turtles.
Supposedly the animals were purchased in the Chinatown section of
Manhattan and then taken to New Jersey to be returned to nature.

On first glance, although illegal, this may seem a rather harmless
or even noble action. These animals were probably facing a death
sentence until the monks stepped in. But not so fast; introducing a
species into a "foreign" environment can have disastrous effects on the
native inhabitants and ecology. They may have inadvertently rendered a
"death sentence" for the existing species in the waterways.

Now I am not attacking Buddhism. I have no idea what kind of karmic
repercussions I may inflict upon myself with this post. Going against
monks can't be good. But, my point is that even generally good habits
or beliefs need to be examined. I applaud the proactive stance the
monks decided to take. I question if it was fully thought out.

~Kerren Lynch-Gallagher

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
ryan

kerren, reminds of Simpsons episode with frogs in Australia...I guess nature isn't ready for globalization...what is your source for this?

0
kerren

The source is Channel 12 News New Jersey.

0
ryan

Ok, should be in the story...

0
killersocks

Sounds like something I might have done as a kid. Doh!
I saw a blurb on this on the Washington Post site:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/08/14/AR2007081400530.html?hpid=sec-religion

I appreciate the monk's good intentions , but good-natured activities like this are is how we ended up with the European Starling here in the US. 

AlanEvans
AlanEvans
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 13:57 on August 17th, 2007

Thoughtful piece ...

Here's a thought: What kind of karma would I cause by marking this Good Stuff?

Ah, what the heck, lets see - Good Stuff.

0
denseatoms

As in the story -- the road to hell is paved with good karma.

Barry Artiste
Barry Artiste
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:29 on August 18th, 2007

kerren, Good stuff, Unfortunately this seems to be the demise of a lot of species in North America.

North American salmon and other native fish breeding grounds past, present and future are being decimated, because European settlers in the 19th century introduced Carp into our waters (As a food source). Carps prolific breeding soon took over all North American waters, with the exception of some lakes and streams in Pacific West.  This lack of knowledge on the European settlers part resulted in native fish spawning grounds being decimated by Carp.

Carp who can grow to a meter in length and hit 60 pounds are bottom feeders and can lay up to half a million eggs. This resulted in Native species depositing their eggs in deeper colder waters where the male fish could not reach the eggs. 

Another note, not publicly known, is 17th European settlers on the East Coast introduced Earthworms and Bees to assist in soil and crop development, and livestock, vital to their survival.  Earthworms and Bees as well as todays livestock were not native to North America.  Though some earthworms existed on the West coast.  Not to get into Environment changes with species, but to make a long story short it wreaked havoc with the eco system resulting in the American Indian warring and fighting with the European settlers who upset North American Indians own long established native food supply, in the end the North American Indians were moved away, mostly by force or necessity for survival.

Let's just say, the North American Indians knew the environmental consequences 400 years ago, and only in the last 3 decades is Modern Environmental Science catching up in this knowledge in what people nowadays  in modern society deem First Nations Indians as uneducated and backwards. In ending sometimes Book Smarts, just can't compete with historical knowledge and traditions brought to us by First Nations elders wisdom, past, present and future.   "Food for Thought" and Lost by many.

0
findbluesky

By buying these animals and releasing them, due to the increased demands won't more animals be captured from their original habitat and imported to the usa. Won't this in fact be worse for the lives of these species in the long run? I wonder.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

AlanEvans
First Flagged at 1:57 PM, Aug 17, 2007 by AlanEvans
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in Environment

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from