A 21-year quest for freedom

by CJaye | December 27, 2008 at 10:06 am
583 views | 2 Recommendations | 5 comments

Photos

Sterling Spann-Photo-02

Sterling Spann-Photo-02

see larger image

uploaded by CJaye

A man was sent to death row, accused of the rape and murder of an elderly woman. But Sterling Spann always maintained his innocence. Clover, S.C. was the last place you'd expect a murder. It was the kind of small Southern town where most people didn't even bother to lock their doors. But a lock probably wouldn't have stopped the murderer he seemed to be driven to kill. Police soon made an arrest, convinced they had their man. But the killings didn't stop, and, for more than 20 years, neither did the questions - about whether the right man was in prison. A man named Johnny Hullet stated to police he knew for a fact that Spann had nothing to do with Melva Niell's murder. Johnny Hullet in 1969 had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. He had had dreams and nightmares, seeing his grandmothers head roll toward him while he was at work. But that was nothing compared to what Hullet’s own wife said. She said and later testified that her husband had often beaten and sexually assaulted her and their daughter. And that he had worked a produce route that took him right by the houses of the other two elderly murder victims.

CLOVER, S.C. - There is an old town, a quintessential Southern place with manners, called Clover, South Carolina. in this town lived a sweet lady named Melva Niell.  Everybody called her Miss Mel. She was quiet, respectable, and devoted to her church, her friends and her town.

Melva Niell was 82 and healthy. Which made the worst, last day of her life all the more difficult to bear.

It was September 16th, 1981, Melva Niell had uncharacteristically failed to keep a morning appointment. A neighbor, worried, went to investigate. The screen door was unlocked. The inside door was wide open. There was a rush of dread; the neighbor withdrew, and ran home and called the Clover police.

At first glance the home appeared tidy as usual, but stunned officers soon found Miss Niell’s bed splattered with blood... a church newsletter and her own zucchini bread recipe scattered nearby. And there, in the bathtub, was Miss Niell. It was ugly. Apparently, she had been tortured on her own bed, sexually assaulted with some foreign object. Then the killer had strangled her and left her body lying in bloody water in her own bathtub.

The small Clover police department had no experience with such horror. State police were called. Investigators looked at that gruesome scene and soon developed their own picture of the case was "open and shut," as they say.

What happened in the next few hours and days would echo over decades; would ruin lives and reputations. Behind almost every twist in this strange tale lurked allegations of ineptitude, misconduct, injustice, racism. And more murder. But not yet. Not at the beginning


Sterling Spann lost his mother and then his sister during the investigation of an innocent man. Sterling took a plea bargin so he could get off death row. I really can't blame him, the catch to that was the state tricked him he was to plea guilty and get parole. He didn't get parole the prosecutor said they had the right man in prison. Case # 62 rejected for his parole hearing, the next hearing rejected as well. On the next try Sterling was parolled. Sterling wants to start a Ministry. He saids be patient, never give up and fight to the end as he stands with with tears in his eyes.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
duo

Sterling went through so much.  How awful for the victims and their families when police hastily arrest and courts convict the most convenient person rather than continue the search for the guilty party.  The object of a detective's work should not be to simply hurry and close the books on serious crimes, capturing the nearest poor or minority male to hold responsible.  I don't know, of course, if that is what happened in Sterling's case, but it happens.

Thank you for sharing his story of strong faith and perseverence.

Mary

0
CJaye

It's called tunnel vision plan and simple!!! Oh I have other names too but I'm going to be nice about it.  Sterling was and is a innocent man and through hell. Thank you Mary for your comment.

0
Earline

This was an amazing story , wonder if there is a book out about his case?

Its a shame that so much of his life was wasted in jail.

God Bless you Sterling , may you live in peace and happiness now.

0
Sandy Aslanian

I have never forgotten the name Sterling Spann since I saw the story when it was first broadcasted. Sterling, you continue to be in my heart and prayers. Sandy

0
walter bachner

How many innocent people in this country have been legally murdered by capitolpunsihment? The entire concept of capitol punishment is so tainted that it is sickening and offensive that Americans are still executed. When will this country finally mature enough to learn that only god, if there is a god, has final judgement over human life. It is a sad comment that the USA joins totalitarian regimes like China and the Muslim fascist states in executing people.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

duo
First Flagged at 9:03 PM, Jan 28, 2009 by duo
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (2)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from