Abu Ghraib Guards Say Memos Prove Them To Be Scapegoats

by Karen Hatter | April 30, 2009 at 08:08 pm
294 views | 36 Recommendations | 1 comment

Videos

Karpinski on Abu Ghraib: We were following orders

see larger video

sourced by Karen Hatter

Karpinski on Abu Ghraib: We were following orders

Photos

More photographs have been leaked

More photographs have been leaked

see larger image

uploaded by gonzo

Initially, in 2004, when photos of prisoners held at Abu Ghraib in Iraq surfaced, the Bush administration declared the actions shown in the photos to be the work of a few "bad apples" .


Since the release of the torture memos, which detail the Bush administration's Department of Justice (DOJ) correspondence with the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), describing many of the actions shown in the photos from Abu Ghraib, those soldiers previously convicted on charges arising from the incidents at Abu Ghraib are seeking to use the information contained in the torture memos to aid in their appeals process.


U.S. military court had blocked those charged from calling senior U.S. officials to testify nor would the government acknowledge procedures or policies related to the commission of the acts in the photos during the prosecution of the soldiers who had worked at Abu Ghraib.


An excerpt from the article :


When the photos of detainee abuse at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq surfaced in 2004, U.S. officials portrayed Army Private Charles A. Graner Jr. as the ringleader of a few low-ranking "bad apples" who illegally put naked Iraqi detainees in painful positions, shackled them to cell doors with women's underwear on their heads and menaced them with military dogs.


Now, the recent release of Justice Department memos authorizing the use of harsh interrogation techniques has given Graner and other soldiers new reason to argue that they were made scapegoats for policies approved at high levels. They also contend that the government's refusal to acknowledge those polices when Graner and others were tried undermined their legal defenses.


Graner remains locked up at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., about halfway through a 10-year prison sentence for detainee abuse, assault and dereliction of duty. His lawyer said this week that he is drafting appeals arguments centered largely on the revelations in the memos and a newly released congressional investigation into the interrogation practices.


Click here to read the complete.

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

You have to wonder where Janis Karpinski is on this story.  After all she commanded the prison.  I would like to see her take on this.

1
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

She has shown her displeasure after the fact.  She commanded the prison at the time  of the incidents.  What did she do to stop the practice in her capacity of Commanding Officer.  I agree that the pawns on the board got convicted for this, but it seems that those that are in positions of responsibility got away with it.  At the very least Karpinski did not provide the supervision necessary to stop these practices.

In fact, I think the whole Chain of Command collapsed.  When I was in the military I always had the option not to carry out an unlawful order.  That, sometimes, takes courage. 

That was my point about where Karpinski is on this.  Thanks for your comment.

1
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

The excuse for any crime committed that someone was just following orders, went out with the Nuremberg Trials.  Soldiers at all levels have the duty to disobey unlawful commands.

2
Barbara McPherson

This is an important story and should be kept in the public eye.  Those in the Bush administration from the top down need to answer for their actions.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

I agree Barbara, but let's appoint an independent commission and put all the facts on the table. Leave political parties out of it.  Let's get to the bottom of this and then let the cards fall where they may.  Little tidbits and inuendos achieve nothing.  The end result will be, that those that are responsible for this will laugh all the way to the bank. 

I'm amazed that when you listen to various commentators how the spin is rampant on both sides of the political spectrum.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Anonymous
First Flagged at 8:46 PM, Apr 30, 2009 by Anonymous (not verified)
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (36)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from