NP Rank:
Alan Grayson’s Four-Page Medicare Buy-In Bill Introduced
In an impassioned speech on the House floor on Tuesday, Representative AlanGrayson, recounted how when his first child was born, his insurance company refused to pay the $10,000 dollar cost. a four-page bill can be seen here in all it's simplicity and transparency. Here's part of Grayson's speech:Grayson: Isn't it time that we finally did something good for America? Isn't it time that we gave all Americans the right to buy into a public plan like this? Isn't it in fact past time that we did something like that and what's the harm? I say to those people on the other side of the aisle, if you don't want to buy into the public option, that's fine. But don't prevent me and my family and the ones who I love from doing the same. Let us have our alternative. And remember, remember what you said so many times before. You say the government can't do anything right. Well let's see. Let's see right now. Let's let people buy into the public option, this bill.
q url="http://news.firedoglake.com/2010/03/10/alan-graysons-four-page-medicare-buy-in-bill-introduced/"]As quixotic efforts go, I’ll take Alan Grayson’s HR 4789, a four page bill which “allows any American to buy into Medicare at cost.” You cannot possibly get more simple than that, it would not add one cent to the federal deficit, and it would offer people the option of purchasing Medicare (and its provider network) or purchasing an insurance product from a private company.[/q]
NowPublic on Facebook
Most Recommended Comment
Crowd Power
-
nanute
New York, United States
Recommendations (4)
-
Hugh Askew
Omaha, Nebraska, United States -
Rory Cripps
New Port Richey, Florida, United States




Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (17)
at 12:14 on March 10th, 2010
i really wish peole would sop asking me for good hard sweaty pony tails im down to my last pair! why do the wolves in my head hat eamericans is it cos they are fat??ANSWER ME!
at 13:54 on March 10th, 2010
MR Henry Thompson (not verified): Did you perhaps swallow too much water from the East River when you used to swim around there when you were a kid?
at 12:28 on March 10th, 2010
Well you can't blame the insurance company for not paying for Grayson's child. Health insurance premiums specifically exclude payouts for livestock.
at 13:02 on March 10th, 2010
Very classy on your part. Your parents would be proud of you.
at 15:49 on March 10th, 2010
They are, but then, they don't get out much. The wolves, you know.........
at 05:31 on March 11th, 2010
your an ass
at 13:29 on March 10th, 2010
Here's my response to Grayson. And this is coming from someone that no longer has health insurance for his family and has to pay $600 just for his autistic daughter's medication every month:
"Isn't it time that we finally did something good for America? "
Yes! The best thing that you can do for Americans is to shut up and stop trying to ram health care reform down their throats!
"I say to those people on the other side of the aisle, if you don't want to buy into the public option, that's fine. But don't prevent me and my family and the ones who I love from doing the same."
Grayson: I don't know which is bigger--your hypocrisy or your mouth! You and your family have the best health insurance coverage in the world and it's all bought and paid for by the U.S. taxpayer. And you and those of your ilk would never give up that coverage in place of the massive health care fraud that you're perpetrating on the American people. "But don't prevent me and my family and the ones who I love from doing the same.", the most disingenuous statement coming from a politician in a long time . . . .
I will say this however: It may not be a bad bill! LOL!
at 13:30 on March 10th, 2010
So, you wouldn't want the opportunity to by in to Medicare? Call him a hypocrite, he's a Democrat in a conservative, mostly Republican district and his constituents favor him over all Republicans in the upcoming Republican primary. He beat out conservative Rick Keller for the seat he now holds.
at 13:41 on March 10th, 2010
nanute: I said that it may not be a bad bill! Come on! I gotta get out my frustrations somehow!
at 13:42 on March 10th, 2010
You had to edit the original. It wasn't there when I posted my comment. Either that, or Joe D. is involved somehow. lol
at 13:50 on March 10th, 2010
nanute: Yeah! I edited but for some reason, it took longer than usual for it to come up. No . . . Grayson may really be onto something here. At least his legislation would be part of an existing program. It makes more sense to me . . . .
at 14:00 on March 10th, 2010
It took longer than usual to come up because I was in the midst of responding to your original, unedited version. You are right: Grayson's proposal is a hybrid of the public option that never got a hearing. It deserves consideration, and a vote.
at 15:30 on March 10th, 2010
nanute: I'm just having fun. For some reason the kool aid hasn't affected me yet.
at 16:07 on March 10th, 2010
Stay away from the electric variety.
at 18:46 on March 11th, 2010
Representative Grayson, You're the best! I have lived and used Universal Healthcare and the scare tactics the republicans My sister,now 54, was diagnosed with terminal cancer last year. She had broken her coxic bone about 5 yrs.ago.After further examination they discovered the cancer and amputated the bone then she did one year of treatment. For months since last year she had complained if severe back pain.......lose weigh the Dr. said. She lost alot of weight but still the pain was worsening......keep up the weight loss and get more exercise. She began swimming because she still had the severe back pain.Not once did they check to see if the cancer had returned! That would have cost the insurance company too much I guess. She soon discovered a grape size lump under her arm that seemed to appear overnight. She mentioned this to her daughter and she insisted she see a Dr. Unfortunately she had been dropped from her insurance after the first cancer and had to go on Medicare & Medicaid to get the treatment for the terminal cancer she now has. From the grape size lump and within about 7 months it has spread to the breast, liver,kidney,spine,pelvis,spine,ribs,and lung. She is a non smoker,worked up until it was impossible and her insurance company let her down to where she had to get assisstance,too late,to ever get a clean bill of health. She may live 3 yrs.but she has already had a secondary infection which has delayed her chemo and radiation treatment. On her most resent visit the Dr. suggested she take a trip with her chldren before she is too weak to go. She will be doing that in July. I flew from Fl. to Az.to spend two weeks before Christmas and our oldest sister will be going soon. I hope to go again next year if things are okay with her. She stays in bed or a wheelchair because the Dr. doesn't want the pressure on her spine. She is the baby of six children and it's unbelieveable what these insurance companies have been allowed to do. The prescriptions she has to take for the nausea is expensive and believe me, her medicare and medicaid doesn't go far after rent and utilities. I hope to God that get a Democrat in AZ. because the healthcare etc.in AZ is HORSESHIT!!!! Please get this healthcare passed ASAP! There are so many stories like my sister's and I can guarantee you THE REPUBLICANS ONLY CARE ABOUT LINING THEIR POCKETS AT THE EXPENSE OF OTHERS LIVES. THANK YOU AND GO GET THEM!!!!!!
at 12:11 on March 19th, 2010
I think Grayson's idea is great! Letting whoever chooses at whatever age to buy into Medicare at cost would be a great addition to the current health reform. At 66, I'm now on Medicare and would be delighted if my sons (age 27 and 30) could also be. Health care should not be tied to jobs! Also, while I am happy to have some of my tax money go to help pay for health care of low income people, I do not want my tax dollars to pay for the marketing for insurance companies or for large corporate salaries.
at 12:24 on March 19th, 2010
Very well said Joy. I think there is a larger benefit to allowing anyone to buy in to Medicare. If more younger aged people buy in, it will help offset the rising cost the government expects to pay out over time. Less need for medical care by younger healthy members of the population will spread the cost risk.