NP Rank:
Back behind the veil, Our Dreams are Gone! : Afghani Women Speak
Barry Artiste Op/Ed
When Canada says we are trying to win the Hearts and Minds of Afghanis and improve their life, it is pretty much a Moot point when Men of Afghanistan rate Afghani Women below their own Cattle and treat women as Breeding stock, at the whim of men.
Again the rules are not to apply when cultures from other countries flee to come to Canada or for the West for that matter. But how does one tell a culture, what you are doing is against Western Culture, without being brought up on charges by the Human Rights Tribunals of slandering parts of their culture? You can't!
Many aspects of Canada's Multiculturalism and Diversity rarely take these instances into consideration. They turn a blind eye to it,stating this is a rare occurrence and would never take place in Canada! Really?
“My dreams are gone.”
“It is already too late for me.”
“My life has been destroyed.”
At first, the words pouring from the mouth of the girl with jewel eyes hemmed in kohl sound like a typical teenage lament.
Her tone is plain and without melodrama – she believes what she says. And there are plenty of reasons she should.
In the span of about one year, the 15-year-old, named Sitara, has been yanked out of school, off a path that hinted at promise, and sold by her father for 700,000 Afghanis (about $15,000) into a marriage that, already, she has “nothing left for.”
NowPublic on Facebook
Crowd Power
-
Barry ORegan
Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada
Recommendations (36)
-
LCoastMom
On a beach, in Sunny, California, -
israeli.agent
India -
Mary Richard
Toronto, Canada -
a211423
Clearlake, California, United States -
The_Cynic
Freddy Beach, Where the deer r, Canada
-
anarkissed
Saskatoon, Saskatoon, Canada -
Amy Judd
Vancouver, Canada





Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (13)
at 08:36 on September 19th, 2009
I do despair at what is reality in Afghanistan and what is promoted in western media. While I do agree with Obama on many things, though he is far more right wing in my politics, he is seen as left in the US, ho-hum.
But he is wrong about Afghanistan.
No matter who spouts some drivel about 'winning' there - it just won't happen. There is no military solution as we see it now. If, on the other hand - and with the technological advantage the west has, the military were to go in and do what military do - there would be a victory in a few months, but the civilian cost would be astronomical! Far too great for us to stomach.
So, what is the answer?
That good old political get-out clause. Seek the upper-hand with those who can engage in the land you wish to occupy - and then arm them and leave. Let them have the victory while calling it your own.
Afghanistan is based, solely, on a tribal system and for each tribe you encounter with force you will make a new enemy to fight until you leave what is theirs. It is almost like fighting a rearguard action perpetually.
What will it mean for the women of Afghanistan? Nothing. Even after all the fighting is done they will still be subjugated until a time can come when Afghanistan is rich enough to educate its people out of such tradition.
Is this right? No - and we should never agree it so - yet, I don't see the western nations having a ding-dong with the Saudis - do you?
If we can give one defining gift to the Afghans it is the very thing they need to take ownership of their own destiny - somewhere where girls and women can be educated, and in bloody secret if that has to be the case.
at 08:46 on September 19th, 2009
Thanks cynic so true, I too truly believe if a country really sincerely wants to better themselves and make a difference, it is they who must do it and not on the lives of our troops. Cause as you say a tribal culture. which it seems the middle east is based on, Woman alas will always be the losers. We are fooling ourselves if we can change thousands of years of history.
at 09:44 on September 19th, 2009
"If we can give one defining gift to the Afghans it is the very thing they need to take ownership of their own destiny - somewhere where girls and women can be educated...."
According to UNESCO two thirds of the world's illiterate, 900 million, are women; and in seventeen countries over 90% of women are illiterate.
300 million women in developing countries have no access to family planning services. 90% of world population growth is occurring in the poorest countries. If women were empowered to make a choice population growth would be reduced by 30% in developing countries. In a Wall Street Journal piece I linked to Milan's latest article, it was stated that an Afghan woman has an average of three to four sons.
A study of 74 developing countries found that one in five households is headed by a woman: they are either widowed, divorced, separated or abandoned. "These women are trapped in a downward spiral of poverty. Forces beyond their control are pressing them further into poverty every year. Yet the poorer they become the harder they have to work to support their children.
In countries where women have leadership roles and the education of women is not denied, the realities and acceptance of women has pronounced effects on the population that over time can alter views and allow women the mobility they deserve and are a vital resource for growing nations.
When the United Kingdom's former Foreign Secretary, Sir Geoffrey Howe, was visiting Pakistan during Benazir Bhutto's term as Prime Minister, his wife asked a little boy what he would like to be when he grew up. "A truck driver maybe," mused the child. Surprised at his modest ambitions, Lady Howe persisted: "But surely you would like to go into politics, even become Prime Minister?" Back came the answer, "No, that's women's work."
Studies show consistently that in countries where women are educated, the society moves forward socially and economically rising out of stifling poverty and suppression.
IF YOU EDUCATE A MAN, YOU EDUCATE ONE PERSON;
IF YOU EDUCATE A WOMAN, YOU EDUCATE AN ENTIRE FAMILY.
at 17:43 on September 19th, 2009
Excellent analogy a2. Why some do not see women as leaders is beyond me, though this little boy seem to hit the nail on the head.
at 07:19 on September 20th, 2009
Thanks Barry : )
at 09:59 on September 19th, 2009
"IF YOU EDUCATE A WOMAN, YOU EDUCATE AN ENTIRE FAMILY."
That is why Taliban bombs girl's school in the first time and every time.
here
here
here
and here
The animal fear in them does not allow them to stand an educated and rational women.
.Agent.
at 12:59 on September 19th, 2009
Sitara needs to know as long as she is still breathing there is hope. I understand she feels all hope is gone. At 15 a day can seem like an eternity. It is part of the monster called teenage angst. Even without the drama that spills from American teenagers without a second thought. Sitara needs to hold on, hold tight to what she believes and what she dreams.
There are more stories of intimidation and fear tactics used on Afghani women everyday. It is only a matter of time before Afghani women realize there is safety and there is power in numbers. They are going to have to be brave enough to stand up to the machine called man.
20 years ago their stories would have never been told, there would have been no one to tell it too and if by chance someone did listen, that would be as far as it would go. There were no women who had made it out of the oppression of their fathers and husbands. Now they have, now they know better. Now they need to stand hand in hand and shout, because there are people listening. There are people, both women and men who want to give a hand up. But Sitara and her 'sisters' need to be brave enough to grasp that hand.
at 15:00 on September 19th, 2009
Barry: Yes! Everything in your story underscores why many have become complete and total libertarians when it comes to free speech. PC (political correctness) is, in no way, conducive to a free society. How did Canada and the U.S. get to the point where their governments are censoring citizens for saying what they mean and meaning what they say? What's next . . . book burning . . . salutes to the PC Goddess? We (those of us in the west) make a sincere and earnest effort to see the good in all cultures and show those cultures respect in spite of our disdain for their customs. I think that we've been had and that we should revert back to the old ways and start calling things as we see them. There's no doubt that you are calling things as you see them. Thank you sir!
at 17:49 on September 19th, 2009
Thanks Rory, I have never been one to pull punches and always call things as I see them in my Op/Ed and back em up with facts. PC in the media and Gollywood is a leftys first defence in swaying public opinion their way.
Much to the dismay of some, who feel I should remain Chapeauless, lest I rock the NP boat.
One thing I love about Now Public is that allows both left and right wing who are lets face it, are on the same Bird of Prey to speak their mind!
at 15:03 on September 20th, 2009
So, when all is said and done, this article should include some kind of suggestions or resources helping us who care to find a way to help. Simply reading it in my kitchen and clucking over it does nothing for these women.
at 15:33 on September 20th, 2009
Thanks Anarkissed for the excellent comment, certainly the UNs Development Programs and other auspices of the United Nations job is to help these women, through their laws and conventions. Will they? Doubtful, as they have seemed pretty ineffective for decades! But the UN seem to have lots and lots of rhetoric to back up their moral stances to these countries, it just seems not to do any good, when other countries fail to listen, as they feel we should not interfere with their countries affairs. "But Oh Man " do those countries love the billions in aid we send em.
But then the above is just one man's opinion.
at 09:28 on September 21st, 2009
Well while we in the west want to support these women, real change can only happen from within. This is as true for a country as for an individual. Too many of Afghani women support the status quo and that is the problem. They allow their sons to develop with these ideas, force their daughters to accept them, and obey their husbands as expected. Till more afghani women stand up and say no, and risk suffering and death, there's naught we in our cultures can truly do. At best we can send money to the shelters to help those who've begun the fight. Moslem women must make their own definition of emancipation. one that fits with their faith and culture while giving women the opportunities to be joyous and powerful people in harmony with their men.
But I do wish we could snatch away every female in islam for a few months. Just so the men can find out what it would really be like to not be 'distracted by females."
at 18:54 on September 21st, 2009
THanks Anarkissed, good points all around