Beautiful brides from Vietnam up for sale in China.

by gerrypopplestone | March 24, 2009 at 06:24 am
2642 views | 79 Recommendations | 13 comments

In the stunning landscapes of the terraced paddy fields that snake up the mountains around Sapa in northern Vietnam, there are many delicious beauties to be had. One of these attractions is young marriagable Hmong women. There is a plentiful supply too. Only they don't go willingly with the men who want them. 

They get kidnapped and dragged over the border to China. Vietnam's neighbour badly needs more women.  And it looks to Vietnam to supply these cheap imports.  Ever since the one child programme when many Chinese couples opted for male babies, there has become an acute shortage of young Chinese women for brides. And Edward Tu of Hong Kong University of Science and Technology thinks this could cause a surfeit of a million men a year for four decades.


So what better than to import them?


According to The Economist (March 14, 2009), gangs of kidnappers roam the mountains around Sapa in north Vietnam, hoping to snatch a potential bride or two for selling on in China. Typically, a Hmong girl is wooed by someone (Vietnamese or Chinese) who speaks her language.  She gets lured to a rendezvous to be drugged and smuggled into China, probably near Lao Cai, an hour5's drive from Sapa.  The magazine tells of one 18-year-old who escaped back home after four days, through jumping out of a window and going to the Chinese police.  They took her back across the border.  But most don't escape.


These kidnappings have been going on for some years.  But local people say the numbers are rising among Hmong women.  Bride-buying, a Chinese tradition that the Communists largely stamped out, is on the increase with the country's surging economy.  Ever since the 1980s, "women were taken from poor areas, and sold to some areas that had recently gotten richer," says Ding Lu of the All-China Women's Federation, a Chinese NGO. In the 1990s,  more women than men abandoned their villages for big-city jobs, leaving the countryside loaded with single men.



There is nothing new about bride kidnapping rings in China. "What's new is cross-border traffic," Ms. Ding says. The women come from mostly from Vietnam, according to the All-China Women's Federation, caused by Vietnamese relative poverty and the long, porous border. More than 10,000 women from Vietnam are in China illegally, according to International Organization for Migration estimates.   "The pretty ones are sold as brides", says Nguyen Thi Phuong Thi of the Vietnam Women's <?xml:namespace prefix = st1 />Union, a Communist Party arm that monitors the problem. "The ugly ones go to brothels."


The kidnappers call their victims "straying cows." Dang Canh Khanh (Youth Research Institute in Hanoi) says the promise of a job is a common trick. In fact, he reckons women cross the border willingly on promises that they will be well cared for.  Their young victims may trust the bride-brokers all the more because the traffickers often are Vietnamese women themselves. Former brides or prostitutes in China, they have the advantage of being able to move between the two cultures, says Pham Kim Ngoc, a researcher at the Center for Gender, Family and Environment Development, in Hanoi.


Selling new brides is lucrative, according to Samantha Marshall of the Wall Street Journal (August 5th 1999). At the border, where supplies are highest, a young woman is worth $250 to $800, with $50 to $100 of that, still a small fortune, going to the initial kidnappers, and the rest kept by brokers or traders who provide brides directly to buyers. The brides command a higher price in more remote regions, but the longer a trader holds on to a woman, the greater the chance of running into the authorities. So it isn't uncommon for a trader to make a quick deal near the border, then return to repurchase the bride for a richer transaction inland.



Pei Xingfu lives in the border village of Ban'ai. He was arrested for kidnapping a Vietnamese woman in broad daylight. According to him, about 30 to 40 per cent of his fellow villagers marry Vietnamese women. "Thanks to the opening up (of the country) and reform, villagers here are better off and therefore can afford to marry Chinese brides. I don't understand why they still want to wed Vietnamese women, even young men between 26 and 30," he says.

In the past few years, about seven men in the village have been sentenced for trafficking in Vietnamese women. Dongxing City shares 35.77 kilometres of the country's land boundary line and 42 kilometres of the coastal boundary with Vietnam. Ever since the Viertnam War there has been a  tradition of marrying on either side of the border.  This has given rise to trafficking of Vietnamese women in China. According to www.boloji.com , eight border towns in Guangxi are affected by this influx of Vietnamese women.


Will such a cruel trade ever be wiped out.  The Chinese police have opened up closer links with their Vietnamese counterparts, in the hope of stemming the tide of illicit goods crossing the border.  Whether they can prevent brides being smuggled over this 800 mile border is doubtful.



 


recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Paschen

With the Excess in Males due to the one child policy wish cause this because of cultural values giving male children a preference, we will see more of this in the coming decade unfortunately though. Why we better start getting China on site with Human rights legislation. 

1
Iffy

I have long thought the 'Pussydax' is a market force that is very hard to stop. Governments will impose policies only for the 'Pussydax' to rise somewhere else. You give women in the west more rights and make them work in the labour force, and the 'Pussydax' then replaces their former sex role with women from poor countries (look at the size of the sex trade). I think all governments should track the Pussydax and take into consideration when they make policy.

0
jehzlau

this is scary... it's just sad when people are still doing this kind of business

0
gerrypopplestone

It's possibly more widespread than we appreciate!  Although real hard figures are impossible to come by.  I think it also says something about the status of women in some societies that some women regard it as normal.

After all, people in search of a marriagable partner often go abroad (with lots of dosh) in search of someone poor. White women from the UK go to the Gambia.  White men go further afield.  Both think that their money gives them a status!

I rememberf a delcious film the BBC did of a woman from London going to the Gambia, falling 'in love' with a sexy young Gambian.  She arranged to bring him back to the UK.  She was delighted with her sexy trophy! The only problem was that, as soon as the wedding was over and he had British cityzenship, he disappeared to live his reasl life - the one came to Britain for:  away from her!  I'm sure many such stories exist!

But in Vietnam, women don;t have that freedom.

0
Amy Judd

What a sad story - thanks for bringing this to us.

0
gerrypopplestone

Thanks, guys.  It is difficult to know how widespread the kipnappings are.  There are very few documented accounts of it.  But kipnapping seems embedded in the texture of the area. Part of the difficulty (to Western eyes) is that it seems widely accepted.  In Vietnam, if parents disapprove of a suitor, he is expected to agree with his lover for him to 'kidnap' her.  Then everyone seems to accept the match!

2
Fred Miller

Good story, Gerry, and thanks for the link, Cypresso.

This probably sheds light on the whole situation, similar to Indian dowry and other marriage customs. Customs that are not fully comprehensible to those with their traditional Western notions:

Says Deng, "People would look down upon you if you don't have money or a wife. Having a Vietnamese bride is cheaper but will nevertheless earn you respect. At least you have a family." Tradition in the area demands that a bridegroom pay 8,000 to 10,000 yuan to the bride's parents as a betrothal gift.


And the bride in question isn't too upset about the whole thing either, proudly displaying photos of the relationship to relatives.

0
gerrypopplestone

Thanks for the additional point, Fred.

0
Swan

Hello Gerry,

Thank you for this story.  It's one of those terribly tragic practices that everyone knows is happening, yet no-one does anything about.  I wonder who would do what if it were to become a practice here amongst our Chinese population?

Perhaps it is already - who knows.
         ~ Swan

0
gerrypopplestone

Thanks, Swan.  People are clearly ambivalent about the practice (except the girls involved), and that makes it difficult to outlaw.

1
azzayindia

great pick gerrry

0
jazzyzazzy

Yes Swan perhaps it already is ! same old same old story exploitation at its worst.

0
Stanley_from_BJ

I felt very sorry to see this report. What a sad story it is talking about. In fact, I am from Beijing and it is my first time to visit this page. I do find some Travel for Bride ads here with a complete fee of only RMB 20,000. Now I know this is completely a different story with sad backgrounds. And I wish God will help these girls any time these girls need in actual life in the heart. I also wish that some organization or authority will come to handle this problem.

Do wish such bad behaviours will stop and never happen any more.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Cypresso
First Flagged at 6:33 AM, Mar 24, 2009 by Cypresso
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (79)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from