NP Rank:
Can Mormonism save America?
by generaldecay | August 7, 2009 at 09:19 am
130 views | 10 Recommendations | 3 comments
As the world's leading military, economic, and cultural power since World War II, the United States will linger in the global gene pool and influence whatever comes next. But how exactly will Americanness get transmitted to the civilizations that replace us?
This is an interesting piece from Slate. It seems to be somewhat predicated on the notion that America will shortly reach its demise but if one forgets about time scales and thinks instead hypothetically, it asks what will save America? Specifically, will it be Mormonism? Crikey!
... For America's intangible qualities to get preserved—our shared history, our ideals, our passions—someone needs to do the preserving. [There's a case to be made] that the Christians kept Rome from being erased from our collective memory—that the Catholic Church was the one entity that maintained Roman hierarchies, Roman thought, and the Latin language as the rest of the continent descended into illiteracy. A religion is also a good candidate to keep America alive. The history of Catholicism shows that religious movements can outlast the political systems in which they arose. Our idealized conception of what America stands for has its origins in religious belief as well: the Puritans' values of industry and self-reliance, and their desire for the nation to be a "city upon a hill." What religion might serve as America's preservationist?
And why...
Why does Card think the Mormons will live through a disaster? He explains via e-mail that Mormon culture "has strengths and weaknesses, but it has almost all the attributes of a civilizational winner. … We have organizational practices and ideological elements that make it highly likely that wherever we are, we will outlast the collapse of governments and civilizations."
I don't buy it, though the piece gives plenty of other reasons why Mormonism may do for America what Catholicism did for the Roman Empire. Um. Well, then... I'm not really sure what to make of that!



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (3)
at 10:01 on August 7th, 2009
Ah organized religion... the brainwashing of vulnerable people. Sure, churches do a lot of good things but is not without wanting something in return like loyalty.
at 10:05 on August 7th, 2009
sara, thank you for the recommendation and comment. Yes, churches do demand that indeed. And normally a couple of quid also!
at 08:08 on August 8th, 2009
Re: The comment "I don't buy it..."
I can just imagine a Roman Citizen having the same sentiments living in the context of his day. I can see the similarities, and I can see it happening, over time.