The Catholic Hypocrisy

by trock71 | February 4, 2009 at 09:28 am
4043 views | 47 Recommendations | 14 comments

Photos

Canopy of Splendor

Canopy of Splendor

see larger image

uploaded by Raphael Borja

Videos

The Vaticans Treasures

see larger video

sourced by trock71

The Vaticans Treasures

Sitting at a traffic stop on my way home from work, I happened to glance at the church on the southwest corner of the intersection. While admiring the ornate traditional French architecture, landscaping and living quarters I noticed a billboard on the property.  It was a petition for funds to renovate the steeple.  It reads something to the effect of "help us meet our goal".

The local newspaper reported "A major renovation of the tower to deal with the rotting wood was previously planned to start in mid-2008 and was expected to cost $1.5 million to $2 million. With repairs to exterior brickwork recently added to the project, the renovation cost is now estimated at $3 million." 

The parish has about $400,000 raised, which will cover the removal of the spire and belfry. About 70 per cent of the $3 million has to be raised before the diocese will permit the restoration to start.

What puzzles me about this undertaking is the lack of involvement on the part of the Church itself. Why is the church petitioning the public for support to repair a facility that is owned by the Catholic Church?  Every Sunday worldwide,donations from parishioners are collected for God's work.  Don't get me wrong,  I am a God fearing Christian man, but, should not the church be responsible for maintaining itself, namely the Vatican, the head of all things Catholic? Then I thought, if I write this piece I'm really going to get skewered, oh well, here goes.

United Nations World Magazine reported the Vatican's treasure of solid gold has been estimated to amount to several billion dollars. A large bulk of this is stored in gold ingots with the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank, while banks in England and Switzerland hold the rest. But this is just a small portion of the wealth of the Vatican, which in the U.S. alone, is greater than that of the five wealthiest giant corporations of the country. When to that is added all the real estate, property, stocks and shares abroad, then the staggering accumulation of the wealth of the Catholic church becomes so formidable as to defy any rational assessment. The Catholic church is the biggest financial power, wealth accumulator and property owner in existence. One of the greatest possessors of material riches than any other single institution, corporation, bank, giant trust, government or state of the whole globe. The pope, as the visible ruler of this immense amassing of wealth, is consequently the richest individual of the twentieth century. No one can realistically assess how much the church is worth in terms of billions of dollars.  Is becoming a financial superpower God's work, is that what he envisioned for the world?

Some idea of the real estate and other forms of wealth controlled by the Catholic church may be gathered by this remark made by a nationally syndicated Catholic priest,

"The Catholic Church,' he said, 'must be the biggest corporation in the United States. We have a branch office in every neighborhood. Our assets and real estate holdings must exceed those of Standard Oil, A.T.&T., and U.S. Steel combined. And our roster of dues-paying members must be second only to the tax rolls of the United States Government."

The Vatican Billions
Avro Manhattan 1983

I had occasion to visit the Detroit Institute of Arts in 2000 to see an exhibit entitled, Angels of the Vatican.  When I entered I was overcome by the beauty of the masterpieces adorning the walls of the museum, the pungent smell of the incense entombed in the tapestries filled the room.  At that time I had no idea what I was looking at other than the works of the masters, Rembrandt, Michaelangelo and Divinci.  Today I am stunned that the Roman Catholic Church hordes such wealth and flaunts it while millions of people around the world are poor, suffering and dying,filling the pews of Parishes worldwide, praying fervently and donating billions annually while worshipping a man who is supposed to be God's representative on earth. Jesus, the founder of Christianity, was the poorest of the poor. Roman Catholicism, which claims to be His church, is the richest of the rich, the wealthiest institution on earth.  Their actions are diametrically opposed to the very teachings they espouse.  The early Christians, following upon the example of the Apostles and the first and second generations of Christ’s disciples, upon conversion obeyed Christ’s commandment to the letter and disposed of their possessions. These they either sold or gave to the Christian community, the latter using them for communal benefit, so that all members would partake of them in equal portion.

Last Easter Pope Benedict XVI says fasting is important for modern Catholics because it helps make them aware of the deprived state in which many people live.

Benedict says that through fasting "we make a statement that our brother or sister in need is not a stranger."

The comment released by the Vatican was part of the pope's traditional message for Lent, the time the Church sets aside for fasting and prayer in preparation for Easter.  The pope urged parishes and other communities to encourage private or communal fasts during Lent.

While the Church continues to amass incredible wealth on the backs of its followers, how does one follow the doctrine of an institution that can't obey its own teachings? Let them fix their own steeple.

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
tikun

There is nothing wrong with being a God fearing Christian man. What has the church to do with ones personal belief in a higher sense of being. Also, you can read "God fearing" as the Awe of God, and replace the English word God with infinite. Then you have the Awe of the infinite. The sense of something greater than oneself. It is a sense and a common thread that allows all of us to feel a shared experience of being alive.

1
trock71

Thank you, I did mean reverence or in awe of God. I could not have said it better myself.  The intent of the piece was not to denounce the faith of Christianity but rather to expose the hypocrisy that exists within the church.  It is my opinion that this would be unacceptable to God.

0
Yellow Guitar

Good opinion piece.

"No one can realistically assess how much the church is worth in terms of billions of dollars"

How much is the church worth? If the church is buidlings and property you get one answer. If the church is people it's a completely different question.  :)

It is frustrating and heartbreaking at times to see how little we've learned from church history. We're still building mega-churches in an age when our brothers and sisters are starving. Some things never change. Where there's sheep, there will be those who are more than happy to fleece them...

Just the same, I'm glad the church isn't perfect. That would rule me out completely. Cheers.

0
trock71

I am aware of the Vatican Bank scandals and P2, and all the other nefarious connections to the Vatican. Now it may be different, but the church and the Vatican have been in business for centuries not just the 20th century.  People have openly given to the church and the Vatican for centuries and at times were forced to.  Remember the separation of church and state? Henry VIII?  They may now not give as much,but people have been shelling money over to them for a very long time.  The local diocese' are not separated from the Vatican.

2
Mary Richard

I remember reading about the Vatican sending aid to Gaza last month, and most local parishes help the homeless and families in need, with funds, food and/or clothing, I've seen it. 

Maybe they just don't a lot of advertising/boasting of this, but they do have organizations around the world following Mother Theresa's work, and such.  

0
trock71

I am sure that there are a vast majority of parishes doing the Lord's work.  But that is not what this article is about.  It is about the hording of wealth and abundance by the VATICAN not the local diocese.  The local diocese funnel money to the Vatican.  It has nothing to do with Mother Theresa, God bless her gentle soul, it is about pure greed.    It amazes me that the Vatican puts out a budget every year when they do not file tax returns in any country they occupy nor is there any over site by any governing body into their activities.  We are supposed to take them at their word?  I urge you to look at the video and pictures at the top of the article and tell me that the Roman Catholic Church's main focus is piety, charity and humility.

0
OverlordCelarent

Neat article, I'm honored you consired my photo.

0
Luke Slomka

its something i have always taken for granted that the church would ask for money, the points you make seem very valid though, anyway thanks for the food for thought

0
Uwe Paschen

Benedict says that through fasting "we make a statement that our brother or sister in need is not a stranger."  Well nothing is wrong with that statement and I do even endorse it. However why did we have the reformation by Martin Luther, the persecution of the Hugenots followed by the 30 year war that Prussia won against  Europe's Catholic Nations and so one. Because Christ has long left the established churches and so did his philosophy. Today and ever since the Crusades it has been about power, dominance, control and blind devotion of a political system on wish is based the USA mind you, since they copied the Vatican in many ways such as the electoral college. Gandhi say wile addressing the house of Lords in Briton, " You claim to Christian and there for believe in the sermon of the Mountain that Jesus held, would you follow his teaching and live by his rules, then all Hindu would convert to Christianity."

0
trock71

Absolutely! Paschen

0
superpavel.com



superpavel.com has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Babel-Fish

You have captured the true picture, let me add that still much of the Catholics wealth is earned in the third world where poverty exists. 

The priest do not follow the steps of Christ and are never to be seen talking to parishioners that live in poverty other than Holy week when they make money out of house blessings. This is very apparent here in the Philippines and then we see the bands of Mormons and Jehovah witnesses and other bands of missionaries here to convert Christians into guess what Christians and the money is directed elsewhere. 

Religion is big business in the Philippines, the Catholics of course led the way.  

My advice is pray direct cut out the middle man as the middle man is after your money. That is also a good business practice.  

Meanwhile the bells chime daily and the sheep pile in and place a peso or two into the collection bag. Or with other religions donate 10% of their earnings or money to support the documentation and advertisement to convert other Christians to be Christians.  Its sad how gullible mankind can be but that's how it is in this mad world we live in.

 

0
trock71

GMA-7 NEWS / PHILIPPINE DAILY INQUIRER :  Stated that  :  The Roman Catholic Church is the BIGGEST LAND OWNERS in the Republic Of The Philippines.  Additionally, the Roman Catholic Church owns the prestigious educational institutions in the Philippines, like :  Ateneo de Manila, Collegio San Juan de Letran, San Beda College, De La Salle University, San Sebastian College, Don Bosco College and others.

The Catholic Church also owns huge hectars of land where ther monastery or seminary convents are within these huge hectares of land. The Catholic Church also owns big hospitals like, San Juan De Dios, Cardinal Santos Medical Center, Perpetual Hospital and others. Some intellectuals believed that the Philippines top hospital St. Lukes is owned by the Catholic Church too. Monte de Piedad Bank is also owned by the Catholic Church.

 

GMA-7 NEWS / PHILIPPINE DAILY INQUIRER  :  Stated that  :  The Roman Catholic Church (CBCP -Catholic Bishop Conference Of The Philippines) is receiving millions of pesos donated by Philippine Amusement & Gaming Corporations (PAGCOR) earned  money from gamblings.

1
paulm

The church is always attacked and it's always seems to be the same tired arguments by different people who have not yet come to the realization that this is the one true church founded by Jesus (don't take my word, do you own research as I did).

Re: the article in UN magazine, which I couldn't find by the way, please post the url for those of us who'd like to read it. Let's think about this argument for a moment; supposing this is true, that the church is worth Billions of dollars, (The figures I have heard by the way are more in the neighborhood of 300 million, which would make the vatican's net worth the same as a small college in the US) realize that unlike other institutions, the church opens it's books to the public, Their Net Worth is open for all to see. And many institutions do check up on the figures and come to the above net worth of around $300 million. But supposing the Vatican is  indeed worth billions of dollars,Let's think about this for a minute... The large chunk of this value would have to be from the works of art in the various buildings. Would you rather the church sell off all the wonderful works of art so they end private collections, never to be appreciated or viewed by the public again? I would think this will be a bigger diservice to the world versus allowing the art to be view and admired by the masses (realize that anyone can go see these items, not just catholics) Also these works of art became famous and priceless after they were painted because of who painted them not because they are owned by the vatican. Finally the reason the church commisioned these paintings has to do with what was happening at the time and the way that relgion and faith (and they both go hand in hand)

Also, I read some of you write of the all these lands that the vatican  "owns". are you speaking about the property that is owned by individual dioceses that don't belong to the Vatican? The Vatican has no power or say over what is done to these lands. If a particular diocese should decide to brake from the church guess what they take these lands taht are being said belong to the Vatican? the diocese would take them with them (because they are the true owners not the Vatican). The Vatican has absolutely no power to say what should be done or not with these lands. The only property the Vatican can control is that in Vatican city and even these lands is subject to the city governing board, not the actual church organization. The arguments that all these lands in far away countries belong to the Vatican would be like saying that the US government is the true owner all property that Americans own in other countries (which is not true).

As I said at the begining, the Vatican is an easy target for all these unfounded attactks. Attacks that get regurgetated from titme to time. It's easy to attack the Vatican because it is an easy target. If you really would do your research you would see that other religious organization have far more money than the Vatican (one is building a 2 Billion dollar mall in their home state, yes 2 Billion with a "B"). There's others that have more control over their members' donations (One requires all donations go directly to their headquaters and there they decide what and how much is send back out) unlike the Vatican who only receives one day's tithing per year in June, and has no control over all other 364 day's donations. I read this posts and didn't see any of the above facts. All I could encourage all of you is to do research don'tlisten to what others 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Terri Potratz
First Flagged at 10:19 AM, Feb 4, 2009 by Terri Potratz
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (47)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from