China Denies IOC Criticism

by Heiky | June 26, 2008 at 10:50 am | 406 views | 7 comments | 29 recommendations

Thursday, June 26, 2008

China denied politicizing the Beijing Olympics although the International Olympic Committe accused that it had injected politics into the Games. The IOC had sent a letter this week to the Beijing organizers in regards to Zhang Qinglin's speech at a ceremony marking the Olympic torch's passage through Lhasa on Saturday. They expressed regret over this incident in their public statement.

The International Olympic Committee’s public statement on the matter read: “The I.O.C. regrets that political statements were made during the closing ceremony of the Torch Relay in Tibet. We have written to Bocog to remind them of the need to separate sport and politics and to ask for their support in making sure that such situations do not arise again.”

Nonetheless, it is a controversial issue. For months, China had charged that others were injecting politics into the Olympics, and now it is faced with a similiar charge itself. Although China said that their position is against the politicizing of the Olympics, the issues surrounding the games are definitely hard to ignore, especially the confrontations between protesters and Chinese supporters during the torch relay. These incidents certainly highlights the connection between politics and the games.

However, the incident that triggered the rebuke from the IOC was not at a petty riot, but during the torch relay's closing ceremony, where it was reunited with a seperate flame that had been carried to the top of Mount Everest.

The incident in question occurred Saturday during the controversial Lhasa leg of the Olympic torch relay, when Zhang Qinglin, the Communist Party leader of Tibet, said: “Tibet’s sky will never change and the red flag with five stars will forever flutter high above it. We will certainly be able to totally smash the splittist schemes of the Dalai Lama clique.”

That remark prompted the I.O.C. to send a rare letter of reprimand to the Beijing Games organizing committee, known as Bocog. In response, a spokesman for the Chinese foreign ministry told The Associated Press on Thursday that Zhang’s remarks did not represent politicization but instead were meant to encourage a “stable and harmonious environment for the Olympics.”


Some activist groups do not think that the rebuke is strong enough.

The activist group Reporters Without Borders does not think the I.O.C. rebuke is strong enough — it wants the committee to demand an outright apology from Beijing. “It is not enough for the I.O.C. to express its regret about the extreme gravity of what happened in Tibet,” the press freedom organization said in a statement. “The I.O.C.’s president, Jacques Rogge, must request a public apology from those who made these comments and from the Bocog.”

A blogger thinks that the IOC's actions were too little too late.

The IOC has ignored Tibetans and supporters calls to cancel the torch relay through Tibet and to hold China accountable to its promises of human rights improvements for years. Now when China makes another blatant statement linking politics and sports, (condemning the “Dalai-clique” at the opening and closing ceremonies of the Lhasa torch relay) the IOC comes out with the bold action of writing a letter to the organizers to “remind them of the need to separate sport and politics and to ask for their support in making sure that such situations do not arise again.” While the IOC falters, Tibetans continue to live under a brutal occupation in their homeland.

A Chinese internet user blogged about the increased sercurity during the ceremony.

由於先前聖火在外國傳遞,遭到支援西藏人士強烈抗議,加上拉薩「三一四」騷亂陰影仍在,昨天聖火傳遞前,拉薩全市封城;想進入聖火傳遞路線,必須持事先核發的特別許可證,通過重重武警關卡,關卡有拒馬、蛇籠、刺釘等障礙物,沿途一字排開站滿公安和武警,警戒森嚴。

Translation of the above excerpt: "Due to the pro-Tibet protests around the torch relay and the shadows of the 314 incident still remaining, the whole city was sealed off yesterday for the torch relay. If you want to go into the relay path, you must have a special pass, and then you have to go through security gate after security gate, laying out all your potentially harmful items before the security and the police."



recommend Add a comment
Rob Walker
  • super editor
Rob Walker
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:04 on June 26th, 2008

While the International Olympic Committee might send letters of rebuke to China, saying they 'shouldn't politicize the Olympics', it can't possibly change the fact that hosting the Olympics in China *is* very much a political issue.

Whether they intended it or not, whether they had no other choice in putting the Olympics in China, there are enough controversial issues there (smog and freedom of speech, etc.) that will directly affect the games that to pretend otherwise would be foolish.

The IOC can send all the letters it wants, but that's not going to change the runners struggling through pollution levels higher than that of Los Angeles on a bad day, or the respected sports journalist struggling to get accredidation.

Good story, Heiky!

0
Heiky

I agree. Letters will have minimal affect, if any at all. Warnings will not work either. Being Chinese, I know how the system works. Raising concerns or voicing out criticism will just alarm the already paranoid government, further increasing content or media controls. Holding the Olympics there is very much a political issue indeed. In fact, the Olympics seems to have put China's ongoing political issues in the spotlight. It's definitely a problem that cannot be fixed by a single letter.

Jarrett Martineau
  • super editor
Jarrett Martineau
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:46 on June 26th, 2008

Heiky, thanks for this. Great post! I have to agree with Rob Walker's comment -- politics and the Beijing Olympics are inextricably linked and I'm sure the controversy will only intensify as we get closer to the games in August.

julianw
julianw
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:53 on June 26th, 2008

Great story, Heiky -- thanks for translating that blog post.

stvalentine
stvalentine
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 13:02 on June 26th, 2008

Heiky, I like this story. It's good stuff.

lcherry
lcherry
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 18:33 on June 26th, 2008

Great article Heiky.

0
Eric Z.

Great China! Great Olympic!

Eric Z. has contributed a photo to this story.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

June 26, 2008 at 10:50 am by Heiky, 406 views, 7 comments

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from