China: Tibet independence 'doomed'
China has dismissed suggestions that a meeting of Tibetan exiles may step up efforts to seek independence for their homeland, saying any such moves were "doomed to fail". The comments from China's foreign ministry on Tuesday came as some 500 Tibetan exiles continued a week-long meeting in India aimed at mapping out a future strategy for dealing with Beijing. "Our position on Tibet is clear and resolute. Any attempt to separate Tibet from China is doomed to fail," Qin Gang, a spokesman for the Chinese foreign ministry told reporters in Beijing. Qin went on to label the meeting, held in the Indian town of Dharamsala, as lacking legitimacy, saying "the so-called Tibetan government-in-exile is not recognised by any government in the world." More than 500 delegates are meeting, the first major strategy re-evaluation since 1988 when the Dalai Lama outlined his "middle way" approach, seeking autonomy but not outright independence for Tibet. The exiled spiritual leader called the meeting after expressing frustration at years of fruitless talks with China. Karma Chophel, speaker of the Tibetan parliament in exile told delegates on Monday that "the middle way approach has failed, it has not produced any results". "In that light, the Tibetan public should come out with an opinion about what to do." Samdhong Rinpoche, Tibet's prime minister in exile, described Monday's first session as "emotionally charged", but said it was important to have an "open and frank discussion". Any new approach, he said, needed to have "the clear mandate of the people" and would have to be brought before the parliament in exile for approval. Growing frustrations: The Dalai Lama himself is not expected to attend the talks, saying he does not want to sway the debate with his opinions. The meeting follows growing frustration in Tibet over Chinese rule, with an uprising in March in western China that was subsequently quelled in a violent crackdown by the Chinese authorities. Following the incident, Chinese forces were said to have set up camps near major monasteries and towns while many monks were expelled from the clergy. The younger generation of Tibetan exiles are calling for full independence, saying they cannot live with China. Chophel, the parliament speaker, said a secret survey done recently in Tibet indicated more than 8,000 of 17,000 Tibetans were willing to follow the Dalai Lama's "middle way". But the results also indicated more than twice as many wanted independence for their homeland. Caution advised: Some analysts cautioned against any deviation from current policy, saying that a strong anti-Beijing sentiment could actually play into China's hands. "The people inside Tibet may say as quick as possible a solution is better, anything that will get the Chinese off our backs," Robbie Barnett, an expert on Tibet at Columbia University, told the Associated Press. But he warned that "it seems to be a possible Chinese strategy to make the radical section much stronger" . Barnett said it could mean no contact with the Chinese government and tougher ties with the international community. Any move by Tibetan exiles to push for independence is very likely to draw a backlash from China, bring an end to dialogue and scuttle the tenuous ties with Beijing. A more confrontational approach would also put Tibetans living under Chinese rule at risk as they would bear the brunt of Beijing's response. Some delegates, however, were willing to accept such an outcome. "We can't live with China," said Lobsang Phelgye, 55, who was representing the Tibetan exile community in Nepal.
Many Tibetans say they were an independent nation before communist troops invaded in 1950, while Beijing says the Himalayan region has been part of its territory for centuries.