Day Camp Director Overwhelmed by Offers of Support for Her Kids

by Karen Hatter | July 10, 2009 at 12:48 pm
748 views | 54 Recommendations | 37 comments

Videos

Member Contradicts Swim Club Statement

see larger video

sourced by Karen Hatter

Member Contradicts Swim Club Statement


This all began on June 29, 2009 when the children of the Creative Steps Day Camp, after a $1,950.00 membership fee had been paid for the campers, arrived at the Valley Swim Club to swim in the facility's pool.


The children from the day camp were informed by pool attendants that minorites were not allowed in the pool and asked to leave.


A couple of days later, the day camp's membership was suspended, the fee returned, without explanation.


Please read Day Camp Kids Told Minorities Not Allowed in Phila., PA Pool for more background on this story.


On Thursday, July 9, 2009, Philadelphia Daily News reporter Ronnie Polaneczky informed Alethea Wright, director of the Creative Steps Day Camp, of the numerous offers of support that had been pouring into the Daily News, seeking ways to aid Ms. Wright's summer camp.


One web designer, Winston Jordan, learning the day camp did not have a website, offered to build the day camp a site, stressing his services were offered 'pro bono'.


Click here to read the entire article.



 


recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Amy Judd

I wonder about this quote by Horace Gibson about the pool attendants telling the kids that minorities were not allowed in the pool:

"When the minority children got in the pool all of the Caucasian children immediately exited the pool," Horace Gibson, parent of a day camp child, wrote in an email. "The pool attendants came and told the black children that they did not allow minorities in the club and needed the children to leave immediately."

I was looking for other statements on that as I just cannot get it in to my head that staff would be so blatantly racist to children, but I can't find that statment anywhere else except from this one man and so I wonder if that was actually said - has anyone else had any luck?

1
Reality

That statement was never made.  No one ever said minorities were not allowed in the pool.  Members of the private club complained because of the number of children there that day, and did not appreciate the unexpected increase in activity that they, being members of this club, were not informed of in advance.

2
Tina Kells

This story is very upsetting but I am not sure where you got that the kids were "asked to leave" as that is not the account relayed by Creative Steps Camp director Alethea Wright or any of the mainstream media reports.  While there is no doubt that MEMBERS acted horribly in this case I can not seem to find anything to back up the statement that pool staff stated minorities were not allowed at the pool and that the kids needed to leave as you write here:

"The children from the day camp were informed by pool attendants that minorites were not allowed in the pool and asked to leave."

Can you post a reference link? Or are you referring to the third party account given by Horace Gibson, one of the parents who was not present at the pool that day?

Parents of minority children who were asked not to return to a suburban private pool are considering legal action, according to a Philadelphia day camp director.

The Creative Steps camp in northeast Philadelphia had paid $1,950 for 65 children to go each Monday afternoon this summer to The Valley Club in Huntingdon Valley. But after the first outing on June 29, the money was refunded with no explanation.

Camp director Alethea Wright said Thursday that while at the club, some black and Hispanic children reported hearing racial comments.

“A couple of the children ran down saying, ‘Miss Wright, Miss Wright, they’re up there saying, ‘What are those black kids doing here?’ ”

Wright said she went to talk to a group of members and heard a woman say she would make sure the group — made of up of children in kindergarten through seventh grade — did not return.


6
Karen Hatter

The original NBC Philadelphia article, linked here at NowPublic in the article, Day Camp Kids Told Minorities Not Allowed in Phila, PA Pool , states:

"When the minority children got in the pool all of the Caucasian children immediately exited the pool," Horace Gibson, parent of a day camp child, wrote in an email. "The pool attendants came and told the black children that they did not allow minorities in the club and needed the children to leave immediately."

I am unaware, nor can it be determined from the article, whether Mr. Gibson was poolside at the Valley Swim Club or whether he was relaying what was told to him by his child or children, other children or parents that were there that day.   
 


 

0
SALLY SUTTON

HELLO....I AM OUTRAGED AT WHAT HAPPENED TO THE CHILDREN FROM "CREATIVE STEPS" JOHN DUESLER SHOULD BE FIRED. I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT THIS KIND OF RACISM IS STILL GOING ON. ( I AM WHITE) I HOPE THE CHILDREN CAN GET ANOTHER PLACE TO SWIM. HOW EXITED THEY MUST HAVE BEEN TO GO TO A BEAUTIFUL COUNTRY CLUB AND THEN TO HAVE THEIR FUN SQUASHED BY INTOLERANT AND HATEFUL PEOPLE.IF THERE IS ANYTHING I CAN DO PLEASE LET ME KNOW.(I DID E-MAIL THE CLUB)...................THANK-YOU....SALLY SUTTON




0
Karen Hatter

Hello, Sally.

Many share your outrage over this incident.

Actions of concerned citizens have always made a difference in causing positive change.

17
Laughing-Samurai

when we re-post a media article from the main stream, whether it's here on NP, our blog, or some other site we have to accept the article for what it is. We are not full time paid journalists with the resources to verify every single fact of every single post. 

The poster on NP is not responsible for the contents of any story posted. Only the original author can be held to account for the story. If a story is on someone's blog well may be we should check to see if the main media is reporting on it, but if it's not, it does not mean its not true or incorrect.

Last year, when there was the terrorist attack in Mumbai, there were so many posts on NP which contained quotes from so called eye witnesses but it would have been impossible for a poster to NP to track down all those witnesses to verify that they said what was reported.

I do believe a serious incident/event took place at this private swimming club which needs a full investigation and the findings made public. No NP member has the resources to do that, so we will wait and see if some one will do just that!

If it's a private club I wonder why then, they even opened it to non members. I suppose if it's a private club they are entitled to decide on the membership but once they offer it to the general public without vetting, then it's no longer a private club.

Karen I think you did very well to get this story out and we will have to wait to see what becomes of it. Hope I'm not rambling on here but I actually think the staff editors are asking for a bit too much on this story.

7
Karen Hatter

Thank you very much for the praise, Z, and comments on reposting.

Traditionally speaking, ever since I have been posting here, for more than two years, there has never been a requirement for contributors to verify posts originating from an outside source, with the possible exception of some unknown blog site, which, in this case, NBC is not. 

I do appreciate you stopping by to provide your thoughts to the thread!

3
Tina Kells

With all due respect, the full information here is easily found online and is included in the links referenced in both this story and the original NP post.  The statement that the kids were asked to leave because they were black is not presented as a fact in the original article, it is mentioned along with other accounts of events.  For whatever reason, the only person quoted from that original article is this parent who was not there and the eyewitness testimony of both children and counselors at the event have not been included.  Not one other account, including those which came first hand from the children, state they were asked to leave because of the color of their skin.  In fact, the kids were not asked to leave at all, the camp was told they could not come back again a few days after the incident.

5
Laughing-Samurai

Tina, I followed your advise and watched media video's about this story, including Fox News. They are all reporting along the same lines that this incident reeks of racist overtones. The children of the camping group are part of the video's expressing what they had experienced at the club.

This club handled the matter very badly for whatever reason the club decided to rescind all the contracts of the camping groups it had entered into.

I have a question. I read in the forum recently, that NP wants posters to only add about 60% of the original story along with about 40% of personal comment. Does that mean that all posts like that are "opinion?" and therefore should have the opinion tag?

3
Tina Kells

I am not disputing that racism is a factor here, I believe that it was. I am only suggesting that reporting a third party account as the one-and-only truth of the matter, especially when that account is inaccurate, is unfair and unnecessarily adds fuel to the rage many of us feel over this disgusting show of modern day racism.  

On your other point:

Not all original commentary has to be an opinion and facts are not subject to copyright.  We are asking that people not copy complete posts from other sources and that when they post they somehow introduce the story with original text.

4
Laughing-Samurai

Tina, thank you. I do think that when posting to NP it would be better to add more than one source of a story, which I have done in the past. When I read Karen's post I did look for other sources too, but I think at the time, this was very much a local story by a local news media.

8
Karen Hatter

Tina, the statement attributed to Horace Gibson is included in the original article I linked in my first post that dealt with the incident at the Swim Club Valley. It is the only source I used for my post of the story.

I did not quote Mr. Gibson. I paraphrased the remarks the NBC article attributed to him. His statement is not presented in the original article in any way to infer that there is some dispute regarding the account he included in the e mail, as in prefacing his statement in the article with 'Mr. Gibson alleges that ....'.

In the linked NBC Philadelphia article titled Pool Boots Kids Who Might "Change the Complexion" Campers sent Packing After Visit to Swim Club, Mr. Gibson's remarks are the most lengthy remarks provided in the article, aside from the remarks provided by one of the young camper, stating what he heard the adults say at the pool, re: what are all the black kids doing here and worrying about injury coming to the other kids. That is why I alluded to Mr. Gibson's comments.

As I stated previously, it is unclear, in the article I used, whether Mr. Gibson was poolside or not.

None of the information you mention is in the NBC article I referenced and linked in my first post. I have referenced my first post in this post.

 

 

3
Tina Kells

You mention the NBC article but the link in your story does not go to NBC it goes to a printthis.clickability.com version which I suppose does not make any updates easy to find.  When you follow the link to the NBC post at the bottom of your printthis.clickability.com referenced story you are taken to an update that states this:

Creative Steps Day Camp paid The Valley Swim Club more than $1900 for one day of swimming a week, but after the first day, the money was quickly refunded and the campers were told not to return.

At first there was no explanation, but some of the campers recalled overhearing comments about the color of their skin while at the club.

Then the swim club president John Duesler issued this statement: "There was concern that a lot of kids would change the complexion … and the atmosphere of the club."

So the staff at Girard College, a private Philadelphia boarding school for children who live in low-income and single parent homes, stepped in and offered their pool.

If, as you state, the children were told by staff that minorities were not allowed at the pool why would the updated NBC report say "At first there was no explanation, but some of the campers recalled overhearing comments about the color of their skin while at the club."

I find what happened completely outrageous but I am concerned that not all the facts have been presented here and am only adding these comments to make them known.

11
Karen Hatter

Tina, this entire exchange began when I was asked to provide some form of additional corroboration for the remarks attributed to Mr. Gibson, which originated in an NBC Philadelphia article.

I have not stated anything independent of what has been quoted in the NBC Philadelphia article.

I cannot be required to account for the actions and reporting appearing in an updated NBC report, as you ask of me when you ask me to explain an updated statement offered by NBC

3
Tina Kells

Fair enough Karen.  I am not going to debate this with you further. You chose to report only one account and that is completely within your right. I am, however, surprised you would not make every effort to be sure of your information when summarizing the situation using such inflammatory words as, "The children from the day camp were informed by pool attendants that minorites were not allowed in the pool and asked to leave." 

8
Karen Hatter

Tina, whatever you are seeking from me I cannot provide to you.

My summarization, which you characterize as inflammatory, was formed using the original NBC article, borrowing from and using many of the exact words included in the original article.

As yet, I have not read any account that has disproven or refuted the statements made by Mr. Gibson nor have I read a retraction, offered by NBC, of the statements attributed to Mr. Gibson.

If or when that occurs and I am made aware of it, I will offer that information.   

The article that precedes this thread provided a glimpse into the kindness offered by many good samaritans to aid the Creative Step Day Camp and its director, Ms. Alethea Wright. 

0
Tina Kells

Karen you are deliberately omitting other facts and accounts of events that day and choosing to present one parent's third party re-telling to a media outlet as the one and ONLY truth.  That is irresponsible and unbalanced "reporting" designed only to inflame racial tensions on this site and about the incident.

Frankly, I expected much more from you specifically and of editors in general.  Your outright refusal to include any facts that do not support your statement is very disappointing.  The only accurate way to present your summary is to add the words "According to one parent's account..."

8
Karen Hatter

Tina, you have misrepresented what I have presented in my article and what is stated in the article itself. I reject your characterization of me and the article that I have posted here.

The statement attributed to Horace Gibson in the NBC article does not identify him as being a third party not in attendance at poolside. It is unknown where Mr. Gibson was when the incident occurred. The article merely states that he wrote e mail, stating the events he stated. 

I will state again, I am not responsible for attempting to verify reporting provided by NBC news affiliates.

I also believe that engaging me in this fashion was improper and might have best been done by private message.

I request if you have any additional comments you wish to make to me, you make them to me in private if you intend to make accusatory and defaming remarks in your discourse with me.

8
Laughing-Samurai

once the swimming club accepted the fee from the camping group, they entered into a legal contract. After the start of the contract the club decided to rescind it without proper justification, such as, the camping group had broken the club rules.

The way the club rescinded the contract was legally wrong and can be sued for damages. It was all handled very badly by the club, whether it was because the camping group happened to be a bunch of black kids trying to enjoy their summer, or because the club members were complaining about over crowding, it really does not matter, because the club should have considered all those points before entering into a legal contract with the camping group.

2
Tina Kells

I agree, that is one thing that I have not seen addressed at all... how did the pool just break its contract?

5
Roy C

It is not clear if the statement attributed to the employee is an interpretation of what the kids thought they understood the employee to mean or whether it was a word-for-word quote.

I have experiments I could post where they take kids who go to the doctor and question them. The kids get led into making statements that would put that doctor away for years very easily.

This is exactly how witnesses' testimony is corrupted and innocents end up in jail, accused of heinous crimes, released years later when the kid grows up or the DNA test is finally in.

Kids and adults were make their memories conform to authority's expectations without much prompting.

One social psychologist I met told me she can get any group of children to produce a statement that makes it seem as if the kids were hurt without suggesting, just by phrasing the questions the "right" way and all in less than ten minutes.

And, after a while, the kids spontaneously "remember" the events as adults wanted them to.

2
Paschen

Great Comment Roy, I fully agree and that may play a big factor here as well.


11
Karen Hatter

And sometimes events occur and are reported as they occurred.

There is often a need for some individuals to avoid the unpleasantness of possible racist behavior by grasping for the slightest glimmer of plausible deniability to dismiss the reality that, at this time in America's history, the country is experiencing an increase in intolerance that has been documented and cannot be ignored.   

Not all who may hold bigoted beliefs belong to hate groups.

It is more than probable that Valley Swim Club club members, being confronted with the prospect that 'their' pool would have to be shared with individuals not to their liking, voiced their opposition in no uncertain terms.

Creative Steps Day Camp director, Alethea Wright, while being interviewed on CNN yesterday, July 11, 2009, stated she was told by one of the members that she, the member, would make sure the day camp didn't come back.

It is interesting that there has been no statement, written or otherwise, from John Duesler, the president of Valley Swim Club or anyone identified as speaking for the club, that has vehemently denied the claim regarding the pool attendants' statements to the children.    

The alleged pool attendants' remarks originated from a local source, making it likely those in the area, including the club officials, could have read or heard of them.

The e mail written by Mr. Horace Gibson, which referenced the pool attendants' remarks, was sent to MSNBC.

 

4
Roy C

Thanks.

The kids may indeed be right, both literally and in terms of interpretation, but I doubt we will ever know.

I will say that my experience on the more ethnically-oriented East Coast is that all groups have more prejudice there than on the West Coast.

I remember the reaction in the '80s when my wife, African-American, and I were at the Philadephia Zoo. There black people just stared at us.

Then, days later, we could feel the somewhat negative vibes in suburbia from some white women when we were going to a restaurant.

7
Laughing-Samurai

There are in America today, private country clubs, like for tennis or golf, which do not accept membership from non-whites. I think this was high lighted when Tiger Woods became the No1 golfer.

Does this swimming club have non-white members or workers? I did read somewhere that's it's in an area which is 99.99% white, so on that grounds alone there could be no non-white members.

On a lighter note, the other day I read something about, "It's the business of newspapers to sort the wheat from the chaff, and ensure the chaff is published!"

4
Roy C

There are also clubs that only take Jews and only take blacks. One white congressman wanted to be part of the congressional black caucus because he was the congressman for a district which was a black district.

Hey, guess what! The black caucus wouldn't let him in.

Actually, the snobbiest "cricket clubs" and such now take all races and creeds. Frankly, when I learned that that had all changed in suburban Philadelphia, I was pleasantly surprised.

3
Paschen

The question of racism is the main one here. Clubs that are only for Man, Woman, Christian, Muslim, Jews, Black, White , Homo Sexual or others exist every where and in every country except for a few European Countries where this is outlawed. Wish causes a new set of problems and another sort of discrimination.

Mismanagement seems to be secondary. Many businesses make falls assumptions and over extend them self to the point that they have to go back and cancel a loot of contracts.

Every Air line over book and hopes it will all work out and usually does. 

This time it did not and action where taken that may have been badly handled.

I was on an over booked flight in Chicago two month ago and truest me people where not happy no matter how the Air line staff tried to handle it. First they asked for volunteers to take the next or even next day flight, after they did not get enough responses to that request, they had to make the decisions and make some people wait.

Children and Families as well as Business people had priority and what remained was taken off the plane list and put on stand by, many said some very ugly things in the heat of the moment and in one couples case security had to be called in.

Of course they where right to be upset, however, today this is common business practice in order to keep prises down and make certain that you are always booked to max.-capacity to cover the cost.

Imagine all the Gym members showing up at the gym at the same time? They would have to close the gym and kick every one out. 

It could very well be that this has been mishandled and blown out of proportion by both sides.

Last year we had an open house for our Farm and B&B and as usual I expected about 50 people since I have done it a couple of times. Only this time in order to increase our exposure we decided to sign up with a tour guide organization and their add campaign . They organized annually an add campaign for tourist to find out new spots to discover.

So we expected maybe 500 people at the most and so the tour guide organization believedas well. 

We ended up with over 3000 visitors for that day and it was crazy, had we not managed to pull the entire community together to come and help with out notice on a last minute call, I would have no choice but to kick every one out and close doors.

Trust me it was stress and I own our community a great deal of gratitude for all their shipped in that day. Because even though we had extra staff on hand no one expected this sort of turn out. 

Some thing similar could have happen here as well. 


3
Tina Kells

I think you have made a very important series of points.  I have no doubt that racism played a role here, but what role? Was it the real reason for the cancellation of the contract or a catalyst? I find it hard to believe that the people who agreed to have the day camps there in the first place did not know the numbers of children and even the fact that the day camps had minority children in attendance. 

I have no doubt that racist members at the pool made a fuss and that the management gave in and I find that sickening.  Personally, I would have taken the stance that if the members did not like it they could join a new pool, but that is just me...

6
Laughing-Samurai

you posted the same comment twice so I will add my reply here too!

Paschen, in part of your comment you stated that last year you held an "open day" on your farm, first planning on 50 people attending, and then 500, but in the end over 3,000 visited.

You did not enter into any legal contract with any of the visitors. You advertised the event and people showed up. After 500 people, you could have closed your gates and refused further admittance.

When the swimming club accepted the fee from the camping group, it entered into a legal contract to provide temporary membership of the club and its facilities for a fixed time period. Part of that membership entitled the group to use the pool. I think I'm also correct in saying that the camping group was given a fixed time period on Mondays to use the pool.

So all the regular members of the club would know about the arrangement and since there are laws of Health and Safety which cover all pools used by the public. A pool can only have a certain number of bathers, and life guards must be provided per "x" number.

Say for the sake of this comment, the club pool was allowed to have 100 bathers, and the camping group consisted of 60 kids, then during their pool time only a further 40 regular members could also use the pool. Anyone else would have to wait their turn.

My mother lives in a large housing village in Florida. They have a pool and club room for about every 500 homes. But the pool can only hold 50 people. Once that is reached others have to wait.

This swimming club knew all this before entering into temporary membership with these external groups. They were given fixed time periods and the general membership would have been aware of that.

Once a contract has been entered into then both parties need to agree before it can be rescinded.

May be the club cancelled the membership of the camping group, then realised it was a "black kids group" so to cover itself, cancelled the membership of the other groups too.

As for over booking by airlines, I think in many countries you are entitled to some compensation, and even with flight delays, I think there is also compensation?

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

albertacowpoke
First Flagged at 1:07 PM, Jul 10, 2009 by albertacowpoke
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (54)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from