NP Rank:
Defending Israeli citizens from terrorist fire
- I think because of the serious nature of this conflict(war) with Terror organizations I felt the need to present this news information/Opinion piece.
-
A quarter of a million Israeli citizens have been living under incessant terror attacks from the Gaza Strip with thousands of missiles fired over the past eight years.
-
These missiles have been described as "home made" by the media. They are, in fact, deadly. Hamas has in its possession longer range Katyushas and Grad-type missiles which can cause devastation such as that on Monday 29 December as one Israeli was killed and 14 injured in a Grad attack on Ashkelon.
-
Israel left Gaza in 2005, giving Palestinians the chance to run their own lives. Despite this, more than 6300 rockets and mortars have been fired into Israel since then.
-
During the past year alone, more than 3000 rockets and mortars have been launched into Israel.
-
Since the end of a formal ceasefire (during which terror attacks continued) with Hamas came to an end on Dec. 19, more than 170 rockets and mortars have been fired at Israeli civilians including a barrage of some 80 missiles on Dec. 24 alone.
-
As US President-elect Obama stated during a visit to Sderot five months ago, "If somebody was sending rockets into my house where my two daughters sleep at night, I would do everything to stop that, and would expect Israel to do the same thing."
-
No other country in the world would have exercised the amount of restraint that Israel has shown for the past several years without responding.
Hamas bears responsibility
-
The deterioration in the situation is the direct result of Hamas policy. It violated the calm, is firing against and attacking Israeli citizens, and is investing all its resources in arming itself and gathering power.
-
If Hamas would renounce the path of terror, there would be no need for the Israeli action. Quiet will be answered with quiet, but terror will elicit a response.
-
"We strongly condemn the repeated rocket and mortar attacks against Israel and hold Hamas responsible for breaking the ceasefire and for the renewal of violence there." - US Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice
-
"We talked to them [Hamas] and we told them 'please, we ask you, do not end the truce. Let the truce continue and not stop' so that we could have avoided what happened." - Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas
-
"For quite some time, Egypt has been warning. Whoever tried to confuse the understand of [ignore] this warning, must bear the responsibility. The Prime Minister of Israel warned the Hamas and said: "You must stop, otherwise we will take measures in response." In response to what? To not renewing the calm, to the rocket fire. Just before the arrival of [Israeli Foreign Minister] Livni to Egypt, 60 rockets were fired from Gaza!" - Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit
Israel targets Hamas and the terrorist infrastructure
-
The goal of the Israeli military action is to strike the growing infrastructure of terror and ability of Hamas and its allied organizations to launch missiles and mortars at Israeli citizens and carry out terror attacks.
-
Hamas has used the ceasefire to massively arm itself with increasingly sophisticated weapons to expand the range of the threat against Israeli civilians.
-
Hamas has demonstrated its increased threat as the Ashdod area was hit by rockets, marking the northernmost point where Hamas rockets have reached, more than 40km north of Gaza.
Israel does not target Palestinian civilians
-
The terrorist organizations work out of the Palestinian population centers and cynically exploit them, so the responsibility for Palestinian civilians getting hurt rests on their shoulders. Israel, for its part directs its activity at terrorist elements and does its utmost to refrain from harming the innocent.
-
Those homes and buildings which are used for storing weapons caches and manufacturing weaponry are legitimate military targets.
-
The high casualty figures being fed to the media from (unreliable) Palestinian medical sources do not differentiate between terrorists and civilians. The vast majority of those killed in IDF actions have been terrorists. Hamas terrorists do not always wear uniforms to distinguish themselves from the general population.
-
As The Times of London reports: "Radio stations ordered all members of the security forces, who have borne the brunt of the attack, to slip into civilian clothes, stay away from their bases and avoid congregating in groups to escape death from above."
-
At the time of writing, even the United Nations is citing some 50 civilian deaths out of more than 300 Palestinian casualties.
-
Hamas TV has acknowledged this morning that the vast majority of those killed are from the Hamas military. A news ticker running repeatedly from 10:00 AM announced:
"More than 180 Palestinian policemen were killed including the [Police] Commander, General Tawfik Jaber."
In the background Hamas TV is repeatedly broadcasting the same scenes of dozens of bodies of the uniformed Hamas soldiers who were killed in Israel's first attack Saturday when Israel hit a Hamas officer's course graduation ceremony. (Source: Palestinian Media Watch)
-
In stark contrast to Israel, Hamas actively celebrates targeting Israeli civilians. A video on Hamas TV Sunday morning blended pictures of Hamas fighters shooting at Israel with pictures of injured Israelis and medical evacuation scenes. In addition, the visuals include pictures of skulls dripping with blood, captioned: "Let them taste violent death". Other narrations and texts include:
"Send them to Hell! Tear them to pieces!"
"Send them to Hell, Qassam missile!" (Source: Palestinian Media Watch)
-
Israel has collected intelligence on specific targets for the past year and has not indiscriminately attacked the Gaza Strip. For example, during the Hamas takeover of the Gaza Strip in 2007, Hamas took control over many facilities in Gaza, including this building and the "Palestinian Prisoner Tower" located in southern Gaza City. The facility was being used as a central operational facility for Hamas security operations and as a weapons arsenal. Hamas offices were also located inside this building and and additionally, large amounts of weapons are also stored inside. The building was used only by Hamas and was not a residential building by any means.
Preventing a humanitarian crisis
-
Israel has continued to allow humanitarian aid to pass through Gaza's border crossings despite Hamas's rocket and mortar attacks, including upon the crossings themselves.
-
23 trucks bearing medical supplies, basic food commodities and other humanitarian goods passed through the Kerem Shalom crossing into Gaza beginning at 10.30am on Sunday morning (28 Dec).
-
"As the prime minister said yesterday, we are not at war with the Palestinian people, but with the Hamas terrorists, and therefore we are bringing in the goods for the Palestinian people," said IDF Major Peter Lerner, Defense Ministry Coordinator for Government Activities in the Territories.
-
Three humanitarian aid agencies are sending goods into the Gaza Strip: UNWRA (United Nations Relief and Works Agency), WFA (World Food Agency) and the ICRC (International Committee of the Red Cross). All three agencies were notified Saturday evening that they would be allowed to send as many truckloads of supplies into the region as they could muster. "We didn't place any limit on the number of trucks," Lerner said. "There are only 30 truckloads because that was what they were able to get ready for today."
-
Israel also plans to allow some Palestinians wounded in Saturday's offensive on Hamas to enter Israel to receive medical treatment. Meanwhile, Hamas is preventing wounded Palestinians from crossing into Egypt to receive treatment.
Further sources
-
International Law & the Fighting in Gaza, Justus Reid Wiener & Avi Bell, JCPA, Justus Reid Wiener & Avi Bell, JCPA (PDF format)
Crowd Power
-
tikun
Tel Aviv-Yafo, Israel
Recommendations (16)
-
158
St. Louis, Missouri, United States -
gerrypopplestone
London and elsewhere, United Kingdom -
René
New Orleans, Louisiana, United States -
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan


-1.jpg)

Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (31)
at 09:35 on December 29th, 2008
Yes, well the Palestinians have been living in filth, no different than the Warsaw Ghettos for a long time.
Maybe they wouldn't try to send puny rockets into Israeli's homes if they were treated with dignity and respect and lived as neighbors as they did when Israel was created.
I have no sympathy for Israel. They have brought all this onto themselves.
at 09:37 on December 29th, 2008
Nothing like keeping a boot on their necks and then complaining they don't get up.
at 09:40 on December 29th, 2008
????????????????????????????????????????????????? Am I missing something. Did you read the piece?
at 09:38 on December 29th, 2008
Thank you for your understanding and artist sensitivity.
at 09:54 on December 29th, 2008
Art has nothing to do with apartheid and racism.
at 11:31 on December 29th, 2008
Art_By_Alida,
apartheid is racism. But not here. Your emotions seem to be getting the best of you instead of sticking to the issues. Name calling just isn't effective for dialogue.
at 13:00 on December 29th, 2008
This seems to be the pot calling kettle black ...
Source: my.nowpublic.com
at 13:11 on December 29th, 2008
Emilio what in heavens name are you talking about?
at 13:16 on December 29th, 2008
Dialogue, my friend ...
at 08:30 on December 31st, 2008
cherry-pickin', emilio.
at 10:10 on December 29th, 2008
I received some photos of the dead in Gaza today in an angry email. How many children has Hamas killed in the past year and how many children are dead from the Israelis?
And how many children are going hungry in Israel and how many are going hungry in Gaza? How is healthcare in comparison? Education? Access to clean water? Heat?
at 10:58 on December 29th, 2008
Great questions. Now do some honest research and the answers will stare you in the face. BTW, the numbers game is not worth commenting on.
at 11:06 on December 29th, 2008
You defend some thing that is be on being able to be defended. Have the courage to look at what Israel has become and face it and change Israel as once German and Italian as well as Spaniel had to face them self and their own atrocities committed onto others. Gaza is the modern Warsaw Ghetto and they act in the same way as did the Jews that where once trapped in the Warsaw Ghetto by the German NAZI regime.
at 11:29 on December 29th, 2008
No I live here and have the courage to admit that I do not share your view point. It is interesting that most people that disagree with Israeli policies always want to find a Nazi comparison. Is it that Europeans have this need to absolve their guilt by trying to make Israel into the present day barbarian? Therefore freeing themselves from the past and using Israel as their scapegoat?
Israel hasn't trapped anybody in Gaza. Look at the reality. It is a strip of land formerly owned by Egypt and taken by Israel during the 67 war. Then we leave and PA takes control and wrecks the hell out of every house left standing and agricultural enterprise left for them to use. Fatah is ousted by Hamas and barely supported on the street. But the corruption of PA caused Hamas to get control and take completely over once they ousted Abbas and his government. Or to put it mildly Hamas had a coup.
There is a border with Egypt and yet they find it necessary not to open it. Why? Why are they , a muslim country not willing to open their borders freely? As a sovereign State they have that right. But Why?
at 11:36 on December 29th, 2008
Maybe it is because you live there that you fail to be able see with distance and neutrality and can not call it what it is as many South African had no Idea what really went on at the start and had to have their noses put right in front of it before they could see. Same happened in Europe in the 30s and 40s and most did not want to believe it either back then and rather believe in a fairy tale.
I am sorry however Israel's Politics are unacceptable in the 21s century.
at 11:48 on December 29th, 2008
One thing about living in Israel, the Israelis are not afraid to discuss uncomfortable issues be it political, social, etc. They are their worst critics. So no I am not deluding myself. I just disagree with your analysis.
I do not agree with your premise that Europeans did not know what was happening. They were either too scared or unwilling to do something about it. Or really didn't care that it was happening to the Jews.
I also disagree with you concerning Israel's actions regarding the 21st century. Just maybe our actions will help toward the destruction of a terror infrastructure that supports nuclear holocaust by the likes of Iran-Hezullah-Syria-Hams axsis.
I believe that it is naive to think that muslim extermism will just go away once the Palestinians take over all of Israel and the world will be a better place. It is just not true. We know it to be so and we live with it every day. Maybe in fact the horror of destroying with force the cancer of terror is what is needed at this pioint in time. That in fact, it is the fear of many that precipitates the "head in the sand" mentality that all will be well with a kumbaya cheer. After all we are all one people. Maybe this is just what is needed for all of our children to survive the 21st century.
at 11:53 on December 29th, 2008
That is good to hear, as long as the same discussion can be just as open and honest with Outsiders as there are among insiders that would be commendable in deed. Yet I do not see it so far.
at 12:02 on December 29th, 2008
Paschen,
Part of the difficulty having a discussion of this nature is the highly charged words and accusations that create a hostile atmosphere lending itself to name calling and worse. Even at Now Public how many of us are actually involved in this discussion. There is a regular cadre of anti-Israel, which I really do not include you, people. No matter what Israel does it will never be good. Only if it was to disappear then the world would be made right once again.
I only continue to discuss issues with you because I sense a willingness to stay on topic no matter how difficult and the desire for both of us to understand where each of us are coming from.
at 12:08 on December 29th, 2008
I do not think that this is the case though, I remember News articles about Israel praising Yitzhak Rabin and many other such personalities as well as events and policies.However not for the past couple of month for sure and maybe not for the last couple of Years as well, especially since the death of Arafat and the rise of the wall as well as other sad news that came since then.
at 12:23 on December 29th, 2008
Not quite sure what you mean?
The wall is only about 10-15% of entire fence. Mostly it is see thru fence. This has truly helped in not making it easy for suicide bombers to freely enter Israel. It has worked for the most part. I will also tell you something that may surprise you the fence travels most of the way on the old 67 border. Yup it actually does. It gets changed as it gets closer to Jerusalem. So in fact for the most part it is on the old pre-67 border. Also, where the fence/wall is not finished is where terrorists have taken advantage and have created havoc.
Nothing is so simple as it appears.
at 01:36 on December 30th, 2008
Many people will praise Israel when they finally wake up and negotiate a real peace. Everyone knows what the parameters are (including sharing Jerusalem) but the only trouble is that Israel uses every excuse to avoid doing it.
at 08:34 on December 31st, 2008
So?
Source: daledamos.blogspot.com
- Sign In or Join to post comments
poor oligarch (not verified)at 13:05 on December 29th, 2008
Tikun,
Alida earlier put the question, "And how many children are going hungry in Israel and how many are going hungry in Gaza? How is healthcare in comparison? Education? Access to clean water? Heat?" Your reply thus far was, "Great questions. Now do some honest research and the answers will stare you in the face. BTW, the numbers game is not worth commenting on." Are you going to help us out a little more?
With regard to the wall, its been widely reported that all of the aquifers (water sources) are on the Israeli side of the wall. Would you care to comment?
As you say nothing is so simple as it appears. To many of us the wall seems to have little to do with keeping terrorists out, and everything to do with economic oppression (or collective punishment if you prefer that terminology)?
at 13:25 on December 29th, 2008
According to sources from a google search. children in Israel that go hungry. Not clear exactly what that means. If not enough calories or by what standard not clear. 1 in 3 go hungry.
Gaza according to sources on the net. 2-out of 3 hungry.
Healthcare: Israel has one of the best systems in the world. It is based on a socialist system of care. Everyone is covered.
Gaza: it just so happens that a very close friend of mine helped develop the health care system in Gaza when Israel took it over after the 67 war. up until then it had little or no serious facilities while part of Egypt. In fact I met a number of the Gaza doctors at the time. Currently since Hamas has taken over much of the facilities are understaffed and over worked. Even before the recent events. This has more to do with Hamas control and interest then Israel. Although quietly a number of children from Gaza are being treated in Israeli facilities now.
The fence in fact has to do with terror attacks and it has worked well. Many of the water aquifers you mention are actually in the mountains and not any where near the fence.
hope this helps.
at 01:33 on December 30th, 2008
The water that Israelis are permitted to take out of wells is something like ten times the amount the Palestinians get and they wont budge from the legal agreement, negotiated in something like 1948 by the Brits!
at 04:06 on December 30th, 2008
WRONG. I truly think you should really do your research before making public pronouncements just for the hell of it.
at 01:29 on December 30th, 2008
I recommend this, not for what it says but for the elegant way it denies the real issues, as usual, from an Israeli perspective. Why is it that Israelis find it so hard to face the truth of the way they oppress their Palestinian brothers and sisters? Of course they know this ruthless aggression causes the anger that makes the rockets! They remember the Warsaw Ghetto as Paschen points out. But, if you keep repeating the mantra of "it's Hamas", you get to believe it. The Financial Times (no less) advises Hamas not to recognise Israel but to use it as a negotiating tactic.
Sadly, such oppression can get in the way of thinking clearly how to cope. I wish them clear thinking and wise decisions in this hell.
gerrypopplestone
- Sign In or Join to post comments
wbsfr8 (not verified)at 08:45 on December 31st, 2008
~can't see how giving real estate to these thugs, autonomy and self-rule can be viewed as "oppression".
- Sign In or Join to post comments
poor oligarch (not verified)at 09:08 on December 31st, 2008
"giving"
More the matter of the continued failure to return the stolen land, prevarication since '67, now enhanced by 18 months of economic blockades. You may not be able to see, but I think you'll find the world does see it as oppression.
at 19:46 on January 18th, 2009
My hope is Hamas learned their lesson.
If they resume rocket firing the next war will be much worse.
Very informative article.