Democrat Bill Owens Wins New York 23 Race

by Rory Cripps | November 4, 2009 at 05:38 am
215 views | 42 Recommendations | 10 comments

Democrat Bill Owens beat out Conservative Doug Hoffman for New York's 23rd Congressional seat on Tuesday.

The race drew national attention when Sarah Palin,  Fred Thompson, and other prominent conservative Republicans threw their support behind third-party candidate Doug Hoffman as opposed to Dede Scozzafava, the liberal Republican candidate that dropped out of the race on Saturday. Ms. Scozzafava, on Sunday, then threw her support to Bill Owens and urged her supporters to do the same.

Democrats see the win as an indication that the Republican Party is being fractured from within by the party's  "far right" element and expect to see more of it in the 2010 elections.

In a major defeat for conservatives, Democrat Bill Owens bested insurgent Conservative Party candidate Doug Hoffman in the once sleepy special election in upstate New York's rural 23rd District that turned into a quest by anti-tax "tea party" activists to send a message to both national parties.

Mr. Hoffman conceded early Wednesday. He was trailing 49 percent to 45 percent with 87 percent of vote counted. His defeat came despite the backing of conservative luminaries such as former Sen. Fred Thompson, former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin and former House Majority Leader Dick Armey.

Mr. Owens said he won thanks to Republicans and independents who supported him in this conservative-leaning district.

"They put aside partisanship and declared they're ready to move forward, not back," he told supporters in Plattsburgh.

Democratic leaders see third-party upstarts entering 2010 midterm congressional races as a potential, albeit unintentional, ally. Moderate Republican candidates, Democrats believe, are being pushed to the right in states that require them to stay centrist in order to win. In other words, the enemy of their enemy is their friend.

"What we are seeing here is a fractured GOP in Senate races all over the country," said Sen. Robert Menendez, New Jersey Democrat and chairman of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.

"The tea partiers and the birthers and the far right of their party is moving these candidates in that direction and that's a lot harder when you have to win in the general election," Mr. Menendez said.

recommend Add a comment
3
albertacowpoke

6% of the votes were cast for the former Republican candidate that endorsed the Democrat.  Doug Hoffman actually did quite well under the circumstances.

This should awaken Democrats to the fact that those that are  angry are no longer a fringe.


0
nanute

apc, If I didn't know you better I'd accuse you of spinning here. The 6% of votes cast for the former Republican candidate could be seen as a repudiation of Hoffman by party line Republicans that just couldn't bring themselves to vote Democrat. As I alluded to earlier, this is a district that last sent a Democrat to Washington before electricity was commonplace. I don't care how many people voted for Hoffman. It reminds me of the Black Knight sense of victory.

2
a211423

Usually we hear of "third party upstarts" in the GOP as being more conservative, so hearing a trend for liberal leanings to the GOP is good news.  Perhaps they will decide in three years to come to the party that represents them vigoriously.  : )

2
Amy Judd

Good round-up

2
nanute

I'm glad I called this one wrong. I spoke with a true conservative Republican voice in the 23rd district yesterday and we both were convinced that Hoffman would win. I haven't seen the breakdown by prescient to see where Hoffman's strongest support was.I'll hazard a guess that it was rural in nature. The larger cities, Watertown, Potsdam and Plattsburgh probably went in favor of Owens The fact that a district that hasn't sent a Democrat to Washington since reconstruction shouldn't go unnoticed. The voters in the 23rd narrowly rejected the purity test and rejected outside influence in what should have been a local election.



0
Rory Cripps

nanute: You actually spoke to a true conservative Republican voice? Jeez! What is a true conservative Republican voice anyway? I'm curious.

1
nanute

It's subjective in my opinion, and you'd find something wrong with it.  Next question.

0
Rory Cripps

nanute: whether it's subjective or not, could you clue me in? I have a pretty good understanding of what a conservative believes and what a progressive believes. But I'm curious to hear a progressive's point of view as to what a true conservative Republican voice is . . . .

0
nanute

Tell me what one is and I'll agree with you 100%.

0
Rory Cripps

nanute: Today's Conservatives essentially agree that the least  government is the best government. That's one of the reasons why so many conservative Republicans were disgusted with Bush. And of course conservatives are against abortion, gun control, taxes, amnesty for illegal immigrants, and they're for the death penalty, and so on. These are just some of the issues that conservatives feel strongly about. On the other hand, progressives are for abortion, gun control, taxes, amnesty for illegal immigrants, and they're against the death penalty, and so on. Some people make the mistake of confusing Libertarians with conservatives. I don't know how they do this but they do. If you know Conservatives that disagree with my take on what Conservatives are for and against, I'd love to hear from them.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

albertacowpoke
First Flagged at 6:12 AM, Nov 4, 2009 by albertacowpoke

Related Stories

Recommendations (42)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from