NP Rank:
Did 'Birther' coverage spell the end for Dobbs at CNN?
The Mystery of Lou Dobbs' sudden departure from CNN begins to make sense.
When Lou Dobbs suddenly announced he would be leaving CNN, many were puzzled and even suspicious.
Sudden resignations usually indicate some conflict or problem behind the scenes. Now, a story published by The Washington Post and picked up by the saavy Media Matters, reveals that it may have been Dobbs' interest in covering the story of President Barack Obama's birth certificate which ended his career with CNN:
On July 15, Lou Dobbs introduced a story on his CNN news program by saying that "new questions are raised about the president's eligibility to be president." Unbeknownst to the long-time cable news veteran, the moment he uttered those words, he embarked upon a steep downward trajectory that, just a few months later, would result in his departure from CNN, the network he had called home for the better part of three decades. ~ Media Matters, Nov. 13
At least, that's the story told by the New York Post this morning, which reported that Dobbs' coverage of the phony controversy surrounding President Obama's birth certificate ran afoul of CNN president Jon Klein, who sent a memo to Dobbs' staff telling them to knock it off with all the "birther" stories. The Post also reported that Klein's memo enraged Dobbs -- he hadn't let facts, sense, or reason prevent him from covering the "birther" garbage, so it was unlikely that the network president could stop him either. It's a tragicomic tale, when you think about it. Dobbs, after 30 years of success on cable news, decided to make his last stand in defense of a story whose primary agonist is alawyer/dentist who claims to be the victim of a conspiracy engineered by Obama, the Justice Department, and Microsoft.The Post's reporting doesn't name any sources, which isn't surprising, but when you place it next to The New York Times' initial story on Dobbs' departure, which reported that Klein told Dobbs he could keep his opinions confined to the radio or leave CNN, a theme emerges -- CNN finally had had enough of Dobbs' nonsense. But that raises an obvious question -- what took so long? Make no mistake, "birther"-ism is a special kind of disqualifying offense when it comes to legitimate journalism, and Klein's ultimatum to Dobbs, if true, was completely justified and the right thing to do. But Dobbs' dalliance with the "birthers" was only his most recent descent into conspiratorial race-baiting.
By all indications, the wheels started turning on this after Media Matters began highlighting Dobbs' "birther" coverage, building upon years of assiduous documentation of Dobbs' deleterious influence on the national dialogue. Media Matters was also a lead partner in the Drop Dobbs Coalition, educating Dobbs' advertisers about his incendiary rhetoric and false reporting and persuading major corporations to stop advertising on Lou Dobbs Tonight. Long before the 2008 election, long before Dobbs ever had the opportunity to lie about Obama's birth certificate, he was waging a smear campaign against Hispanics and immigrants and using his cable news perch to spin elaborate conspiracy theories with no basis in fact.
Crowd Power
-
Susan Marie Kovalinsky
Ledgewood, New Jersey, United States
Recommendations (52)
-
The_Cynic
Freddy Beach, Where the deer r, Canada -
Babel-Fish
Negros Oriental, Philippines -
Hugh Askew
Omaha, Nebraska, United States -
tikun
Tel Aviv-Yafo, Israel
-
YankeeJim
Arlington, Virginia, United States -
aurealeus
BeanTown, to Florida, United States -
Barry ORegan
Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada




Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (32)
at 21:19 on November 13th, 2009
I think this piece warrants an Opinion tag, smk.
With that said, I am only going to comment on the "coverage of the phony controversy surrounding President Obama's birth certificate" -- it is a fact that President Obama has refused to produce a long-form birth certificate and has spent upwards of $1 million in legal fees on this matter.
Given this alone, it is my opinion that someone was behind Jon Klein's 'memo' to Dobbs.
Conspiracy is very real. Conspiracy theorists are a necessary avenue to truth and this 'conspiracy' could have easily been put to rest had President Obama simply produced his long form birth certificate. Until such time as he does, the so-called 'birthers' will continue its 'discussion' on this matter and silencing a journalist is not the way to go.
at 03:10 on November 14th, 2009
"....President Obama has refused to produce a long-form birth certificate and has spent upwards of $1 million in legal fees on this matter."
Is that true?
I have pretty much blown off the controversy around this issue, assuming it was just a big whine by Obama detractors.
A million bucks for lawyers spells serious problems. A MILLION dollars? What would a photocopy of the certificate cost? $20.00?
Now you got me wanting some proof.
at 21:49 on November 13th, 2009
Accuracy in Media (AIM) reveals some interesting information on Media Matters in this June 2007 article, titled "Hillary's Hit Man Strikes Again".
at 21:57 on November 13th, 2009
And in this most recent article: CNN's War on Lou Dobbs (I probably should have read this first:)
at 01:54 on November 14th, 2009
Doesn't look good for free speech. From the article link by Rhonda "accuracy in media" it squarely places the blame on left-wing dislike of any criticism of the President and their intention to stifle any reasonable debate.
at 02:56 on November 14th, 2009
Journalism and free speech took a hit again. I tend to agree with Rhonda, why spend all this money, when u can just produce the certificate and put matters to rest.
I view articles from media matters with suspicion.
Just to set the record straight, I have never been a fan of Lou Dobbs and I have a remote control to take care of that. I also think that the birth certificate issue detracts from the real issues. Having said that, why is it so hard to produce a long form birth certificate?
at 03:48 on November 14th, 2009
Why should he, when the republicans are hooked on that bait there not looking for the real problem the fact that he is an android that's been programmed to save the world, lol
My real opinion is who damn cares and its too late he is the president and so far he has not pushed that damn red button. lol
at 03:59 on November 14th, 2009
Haha, never thought of the android twist. Good one, we should pursue that.
at 16:14 on November 14th, 2009
I CARE and it's NEVER too late!
If at any time, proof should surface that Obama is not an American Citizen, impeachment would be in order.
at 05:06 on November 14th, 2009
It appears true from everything I have read, Hugh. Here's a comprehensive read: Obama birth certificate lawsuits.
at 05:47 on November 14th, 2009
"...Obama for America' paid $1,066,691.90 to the Perkins Coie law firm between Oct. 16, 2008 and March 30, 2009..."
That's a lot of jing for a simple item...................unless, of course, it doesn't exist.
Very interesting. VERY interesting.
Thank you for the info.
at 10:55 on November 14th, 2009
You are very welcome, Hugh! My pleasure!
at 06:11 on November 14th, 2009
Gee, he and Dan Rather seem to have plotted a similar career course when they say anything against a sitting president?
at 08:26 on November 14th, 2009
Well, it does appear as though there are no documents in either case.
at 06:37 on November 14th, 2009
As usual, Barry sums up in ten words what is the crux of the matter; the Artiste has real talent, and I mean that! :) ;)
Rhonda: I did not put "Opinion" on this as I do not offer my opinion, which I am holding in reserve. I am only showing what the Washington Post and Media Matters have to say. The latter state their opinion, but I do not say I am in any agreement with them; I only show what piece I came upon which prompted me to post this. Very fishy.
at 10:57 on November 14th, 2009
Thanks, smk:)! I've been known to be wrong before:) Albeit, not too often:)
at 11:03 on November 14th, 2009
Ha! ;) Yes, I agree you are not often wrong----and I do think this birther issue cuts both ways. On the one hand, there is some craziness on the part of the birthers, but on the other, some of it is simply a legitimate question, and why does Obama NOT simply produce what he must? They claim he has, but has he? Something not right there. all in good time, I expect. He is either faking them out, and enjoying it, while biding his time, or he has indeed produced enough documentation, or.......or........I cannot say it :( (starting to scream in greater New York metro/New Jersey area)
at 11:05 on November 14th, 2009
And what craziness would that be on the part of the 'birther's, smk?:)
at 11:08 on November 14th, 2009
Well, the ones who say he is the son of some mysterious Kenyan dignitary, etc. Odd rumors. Not all of it, just some......
at 10:37 on November 14th, 2009
"Media Matters" is a biased organization with an agenda supporting ILLEGAL immigration.
Media outlets such as "Media Matters," "America's Voice," "The Southern Poverty Law Center" and others such as the National Council of La Raza, and the Center for New Community, are working hard to subvert our laws and system of immigration that is in place, and it appears to be working. The resignation of Lou Dobbs shows that their efforts are achieving successes in undermining the laws of the United States and freedom of speech supposedly guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution, by working to silence those who dare to speak out against the status-quo.
The Washington Post and most other "Mainstream Media" is in the back-pockets of the financial elite and therefore is also biased.
The TRUTH is... the nations of the world are alligning towards one-world governance and total control by financial globalists, corporations and Central World Bank dominance over the world's resources and financial markets, thereby effectively erasing all national borders and individual sovereignty, enslaving us all. Alternative media reports these truths while mainstream media keeps quiet or supports the lies while distracting from the truth and issues that should be front page headlines.
In my opinion, Lou Dobbs is a true Patriot for reporting on important issues that affect all Americans (and the world) while the corporate elitists, bankers and their supporters should all be labeled as TRAITORS and punished as such.
Additionally, Obama should be required BY LAW to provide proof that he is indeed a natural-born native American and furnish his birth certificate, if he is to remain President of The United States of America. Otherwise, impeachment should be in order.
WAKE UP AMERICA!
at 10:04 on November 14th, 2009
Fabulously incredible, This joker, who used to be taken seriously by some, manages to engender a passion, as a pastime on CNN's dime, attempting to disgrace One of America's largest ethnic citizenry and he Gets credit for only one preposterous remark. This only goes to show that unless a particular body of people feels personal and collective resentment, they nay advocate exclusively for their own. Ever hear "First they came for the Jews, then they came for me" It seems to apply here. Many times Mr. Dobbs was confronted by news folks and questioned on the veracity of his reporting, only to respond that if he said it, it was true. Not so, because the reporters has concrete facts which disproved Dobbs allegations ans weird theories. In fact Dobbs said that CNN also was in line with his reporting. Fox news told Geraldo Rivera that Dobbs would not be working there. One really never knows, though because lately our population is acting very strangely. I feel for our people, (Black, White, Hispanic and others as well). Remarks and not facts, are meant to show extreme prejudice. We will agree on one issue with a sense of patriotism, only to find that our misguided agreement just eliminated our only possible ally. That is what is going on today. Our laws and practices, including the God thing, have been a tool used only to protect certain conditions and keep the carrot visible until one who is not preferred reaches that poit, and then the stick or the whip is there to prevent forward or upward motion. Whatever motivates you today against your people, will tomorrow be motivated against you and yours. Lou Dobbs will have a place to go and the person who is jumping into his position, is only going to circle the wagons on everyone. The "beyond the Beltway on pressing policy issues and the real people they impact. " Certainly it is not rocket science to understand that quote. He will speak in a language that will exlude tha layman and consider that real people are the only ones who will be considered. The viewers should not too happy just yet. WE can vote or help elect someone, once they are there it is for a while. All of us tell the truth, It is up to each one of us to understand, what is it true about.
at 10:35 on November 14th, 2009
Personally I am irked by the sudden required birth certificate syndrome. I have what I believe to be a great idea.
Someone, not myself, because i do not know how to do it, but I know it can be done.
Set up a web page with each and every president and vice president and even runners for the job.
Show all presidents birth certificated on it from the first to the last. Authentic ones and verified only. Also it may be a good idea, to dispel any potential problems, to try and get the people who are alive now to personally have a chance to voluntarily submit theirs.
Many people are heavily full of themselves and claim no immigrant past, so we may want to know if they have native descendants. (Indian)
They can then be linked to any or all pages on the net including youtube, Facebook, Twitter etc. If I don't receive a response on this with someone willing to do it, I will consider collaborating with someone on it.
One remark I have is that no president, before Obama, has been asked this question. Certainly this entertains some sort of bias.
at 11:29 on November 14th, 2009
Lou Dobbs and the Birth certificate is a hand me down story he chose to pick up and would bet that if it were a Hispanic person and not Obama, He would have been the first on it. No one is stopping anyone else from posting what they believe is the truth. Things are not helped any when the leaders of this country, do not provide the real facts to the people. The president of the United States of America, Once elected, does not have to dignify him/her self to anyone by showing personal documents of any sort, which are certainly already examined before his candidacy. It is in our constitution that no one who is not a residing member of this country, for x amount of years, can seek and hold office. If it ever turns out that Obama is not a citizen, We will need to fire everyone responsible for having anything at all to do with having to check that detail. Further more They would have to face felony charges and possible incarceration. Now that, is something to report.
at 17:48 on November 14th, 2009
The birthers are tiresome, and no matter what is presented to them to disprove they will continue the conspiracy theories, perhaps forever!
It reminds me of the controversial information about the influence of the freemasons in America, and was George Washington really a freemason and did the tenents of secrecy and intrigue influence his decisions as president. Also the latest theories about Lincoln and was he really suffering from a wasting disease and would have died anyways, if he had not been assinated. And on, and on, and on.
It's the pedestal effect. Great people attract those who want to knock them down, and they will go to extreme lengths to do so. It's a flaw in human nature. : (
at 17:57 on November 14th, 2009
I think this is a detraction from the real issues. Those are the economy, unemployment above 10% and Afghanistan, almost in that order. Let those that are pursuing it through the courts deal with it and let the cards fall where they may.
Besides I thought this story was about why Lou Dobbs left CNN and not a rehash of Obama's birth certificate. It seems to me we have heard all those arguments before.
at 05:11 on November 15th, 2009
albertacowpoke,
"Besides I thought this story was about why Lou Dobbs left CNN and not a rehash of Obama's birth certificate."
Dobbs' 'interest' here evidently was the 'straw that broke the camel's back':)
Too, I've been thinking about the fact that it is alleged that 'supporters' of Hillary Clinton were first to bring the matter of President Obama's birth certificate up during the campaign. In effect then, Hillary Clinton's supporters started this 'distraction'. I believe they are 'democrats':)
One definitely has to be aware of distractions!:)
at 06:00 on November 15th, 2009
I certainly agree with you Rhonda. Yes and Hillary's campaign dug up the issue and challenge. It wasn't some right wing conspiracy.
at 12:56 on November 15th, 2009
Thanks, albertacowpoke:)! That's right, "It wasn't some right wing conspiracy."
at 04:53 on November 15th, 2009
Nancy Salvato with BasicsProject.org :
"What perturbs the rest of us is that President Obama has failed to produce a legitimate birth certificate. He has a team of lawyers who are opposing the examination of his sealed records in Hawaii. What he produced was a certificate of live birth... not a birth certificate. The rest of us are appalled at the lack of media examination surrounding the fact that there is no law requiring that a candidate for the highest office in our land produce an authentic birth certificate which proves natural citizenship."(from Obama birth certificate lawsuits).
at 04:57 on November 15th, 2009
"During the Democratic primaries, supporters of the Hillary Clinton campaign pointed out that there were issues with the validity of Barack Obama's Hawaiian birth certificate, claiming that it was a fake and that Obama was therefore ineligible to run for the presidency. [1]" (from Obama birth certificates lawsuits)