Ethanol May Not Be the Miracle It's Made Out to Be

Here is an update to a story I did last year, that is relevent today, both on Biofuels and Food Shortages predicted to happen by going Biofuel.  This is a companion piece to Robs story below.

http://www.nowpublic.com/environment/canada-worlds-third-worst-polluter

By JOHN STOSSEL and ANDREW G. SULLIVAN May 2, 2007 ABC NEWS 20/20 Gas prices are skyrocketing as the high-demand summer season rolls in, and Bloomberg News predicts that some pumps may soon hit four dollars per gallon. Along with high gas prices come the calls for Americans to diversify our energy sources and reduce our dependence on foreign oil. But be skeptical of politicians who tout ethanol as the clean-burning solution to our energy crisis. Are gas prices hitting a "record high"? Don't believe what you hear from the media about that. Reporters often forget to adjust for inflation. Gas prices were higher in the 1920s and the 1980s.

The Miracle Solution?

The idea that ethanol is the answer is a myth. Ethanol is one thing that both Republican and Democratic candidates agree on this campaign season. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani voice their support for the corn-based fuel, and Sens. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., Barack Obama, D-Ill., and former Sen. John Edwards want the government to subsidize ethanol production. According to former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, "The economics of ethanol make more and more sense." Ethanol "makes sense" to these politicians because, they say, it's a clean and renewable energy source that will slow global warming, protect the environment and reduce our dependence on foreign oil. Plus, it just sounds good: Ethanol's made from corn, and we grow corn, so it just seems natural. But if ethanol made so much sense, we wouldn't have to subsidize it or mandate its consumption. Jerry Taylor of the Cato Institute said, "If you can make a profit in this economy by putting something on the market, the government doesn't need to put a gun to your head." But ethanol producers do need the help of government subsidies if anyone is going to buy their product, because without subsidies it would cost much more than gasoline. And critics point out that the idea that ethanol is good for America in terms of energy prices, foreign policy or the environment is a myth. The Ethanol Process As Jerry Taylor reminded us in his interview on "20/20," when ethanol is produced "it takes a lot of fossil fuels to make the fertilizer, to run the tractor, to build the silo, to get that corn to a processing plant, to run the processing plant." Then there's the energy it takes to move the ethanol around. Because ethanol degrades, it's not possible to transport it in pipelines like we do oil, so using ethanol means putting many more polluting trucks on the road to deliver it. More on this story "SOURCE" http://abcnews.go.com/2020/story?id=3130684&page=1

This NP Reporters "Artiste7ca@yahoo.ca" Comments: Consumers should also know that Ethanol is a starch and sugar based fuel. We have all heard about the old Sugar in the tank stories. One downside of using Biofuels is that using a food for fuel will raise the price of that food.  Something to think about especially when food is a scarce commodity in third world countries already. So be warned, if you must use ethanol, either do a half ethanol and half premium gas in your tank, or one tank of ethanol for every 3 tanks of regular gas. Would I use it? Well with fuel injection systems in most vehicles, I would be leery. Fuel injection servicing and overhaul for a typical low cost Hyundai costs around $1,200 dollars (Parts not included) to get the sugar and starches out of your clogged fuel injectors. If you own a BMW, Escalade, Porche or other over engineered high cost luxury car, better take out a second mortgage to repair it. Ethanol doesn't leave me with a lot of confidence. God help you if you live and drive in Northern Climes with a tank of ethanol in February at any temperature below freezing. Better have your OnStar, CAA or AAA card handy and your Local Tow Truck company on speed dial.

Will your mechanic warn you, perhaps, but then you will be most likely putting his kid through university, and if you keep using ethanol you'll most likely be paying for your mechanic's addition to his Beach Front home. Something to think about.