Facebook Bullying: First Phoebe Prince, Now Constance McMillen

by Yuliya Talmazan | April 7, 2010 at 11:57 am
7685 views | 6 Recommendations | 14 comments

Cyberbullying: Facebook Against Constance McMillen

The suicide death of 15-year-old Phoebe Prince had nationwide resonance when it was discovered that the teenager was relentlessly bullied on and off school grounds by a group of fellow classmates for months before her death. The bullying of Phoebe Prince, an immigrant from Ireland, has taken on many different forms ranging from verbal abuse to threatening text messages to bottles thrown at her on the way from school. But, one form of abuse used against the teenager involved social networks and took the form of cyberbullying. It is alleged Prince was bullied online via Facebook and Craigslist, making it hard for the 15-year-old to escape bullying any time of the day. 

Now, another "social outcast" is being targeted on Facebook. Eighteen-year-old high school senior Constance McMillen from Fulton, Mississippi, made headlines last month when she asked for a right to go to her high school prom accompanied by her lesbian partner. To avoid controversy, the school officials opted to cancel the prom completely. But, McMillen felt she was discriminated against and filed with federal court, which eventually ruled that her rights have been violated. However, the court also ruled not to make the school re-instate the prom on the grounds that an "impromptu" prom would be organized by other students and their parents.

But yesterday, it was reported that McMillen was decoyed to attend a "fake prom," that only seven other students attended. The rest of the class was partying in a "secret" location that was not made known to McMillen. 

This morning, a Facebook group titled "Constance quit yer cryin" has surfaced, counting close to 1,700 fans. There is no information about who started the group. CBS reports that intial posts made were directed against Constance McMillen, including the very first post that reportedly read, "Seriously, you've pretty much eff'd up your fellow classmate's best memory of High School."

But, unlike Phoebe Prince who was left one-on-one with her Facebook bullies, hundreds of McMillen's sympathizers logged in to voice in their support for Fulton teenager and disgust with group creators. The group has now been completely overtaken by McMillen's supporters who continue to post messages of encouragement, such as "People don't choose to be gay, but people do choose to be bigots" and "Whoever made this [group] should grow up."

Some of McMillen's supporters are calling for colleges around the country to revoke admission offers and scholarships from the students who attended the "secret" prom or started the hate group. Others are posting phone numbers of the school officials that have allegedly discriminated against McMillen, asking people to call in during business hours and express concern.

In addition, one member of the forum started posting photos that allegedly came from the "real" prom that Constance was not invited to. The authenticity of the photos has not been confirmed.

"Constance quit yer cryin." 

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
2
Nancy Benedict

Uh...pardon me, but how does this represent a "hate" group.   This girl did some specific with which a lot of people take issue and which had repurcussions that made a lot of people angry.   If people were cursing her in the cafeteria or throwing bottles at her out of cars like they did with Phoebe, yes, that would be bulling.   Posting on a public site that "hey, you effed up our prom" when that is what they actually believe she did, is called free speech, not harassment.  I don't see that she's being stalked, called names, or terrorized.  People are posting that they're angry about what she did (not who she is.)  Are they not allowed to say this?  Now, of course, the PC police will step in and anybody who criticized this girl or her actions WILL be targeted and terrorized -- phone numbers put on the net, people encouraged to call them and harass them, etc.   To compare this to Phoebe Prince is just sick.

0
NLB

You know what else is just sick? How ignorant you are. Perhaps you are a lesser degree of bully, or perhaps you consider yourself completely open minded but news flash: your commentary is a perfect representation of adverse effect discrimination. Here you are blaming her for ruining a prom. And I'm sorry, how did she ruin the prom? She went to Admin to inform them she was going to prom with her girlfriend and she was to wear a tux, because she felt NO reason to have to disguise the fact that she was gay. Some of America needs to wake the f*** up and follow the rest of the world, for you "Nancy Benedict" are very much lacking in ... class? taste? education? Pick one from column A.Now stop being so homophobic and stop defending all the sick people like yourself.

1
JustMe125

Nancy...you're kidding right?  What else would you call this group of people?! This girl did nothing wrong and because some assinine school officials decided to bury their heads in the sand and stop the prom instead of trying to take an important step forward, Constance takes the heat for it.  They should all be ashamed of themselves.  I am sorry that there are many "Constance" people in this world that continue to go through things like this in our day and age.  How do you know Nancy what this girl is going through?  Words hurt as much as fists...I know.  I almost lost a son at the age of 15 due to a group of boys who had bullied him since kindergarten until one day he swallowed a bunch of pills to try and make it all stop.  Reading stories like Phoebe Prince just re-open those emotions like it was yesterday and fill with a sadness at the thought that it may never change for some until it is too late.  Big hugs to all the Constance and Phoebe's of the world and to their loved ones as well.  One person can make a difference in things like this when we stand up for what we know to be right... a wonderful woman named Rosa and a bus come to mind :)

0
katec

Nancy isn't kidding She is a moron

0
dc1113

you may be right but you saying that is a cyberbullying.

1
Candi Painter

I am from Fulton and see what Constance is going through! Considering that she was standing up for what was right I think she deserves to be respected not hated! And even though she might have ruined prom. It honestly does not concern the rest of the world. it should concern Fulton and the kids who were going to prom! I think everyone needs to grow up I'm 15 and I know all this!

1
erica01

Amen JustMe125. You hit the nail right on the head.

0
ravforu

I'm sorry Candi, but what people do in Fulton DOES concern the rest of us as these fools who claim to "love my Jesus" will continue to ostracize others who are not considered "normal".  You keep forgetting there were disabled students besides Constance who were "directed" to the "fake" prom. So not only does Fulton's fake prom parents & students not want Constance's "drama", they didn't want the "drama" of having disabled students at their "not prom this is a party". Do you see cruelty?  I think you know the answer. Surely you can see how this impacts everyone as these people will go out into the World.  It gives a black eye to Mississippi residents, Christians, high school students and Southerners. So now besides living down the treatment of Blacks I have to live this down too as I will be classed in with the narrow-minded and rednecks once again. The very fact that you continue to insist that Constance ruined prom rather than the school speaks volumes about why everyone everywhere should be outraged. You just don't get it. Did Jesus only walk with the "normal" people or did he have concern for the people on the fringe? I think you know the answer. I know He would be shouting at those Parents and Students who crafted or participated in the deceiptful fake prom "You hippocrits!"

1
JenniferTroyAlabama

@ravforu I am from the south also and I hate what those close-minded people convey to the rest of the world. I grew up in a small hypocritically-religious town in Alabama and people like that make me ashamed of where I am from. I just don't understand how anybody can blame Constance for being who she is and wanting to share that. I truly hope that this incident will make her a stronger person and maybe shine a harsh light on the dark bigotry that still exists in the south and the rest of this country. This country is drowning in serious problems, debt and political unrest, and we are so busy judging each other because of race, religion or sexuality when we should be embracing those differences. We could do so much if we just took our heads out of our asses. The bottom line is it's nobody's business who Constance loves or what her race is or what she choses to believe. As long as she isn't infringing on my rights to love who I want, or celebrating my race or practicing my religion, then leave her alone. The bigots of this country are what's keeping this news story alive. I have a degree in Journalism and I know that if that school had just let her go to prom, they would have avoided all of this mess. How is all of this worth it? All they have done is weaken their religion, weaken people's perceptions of Mississippi and bring the Gay and Lesbian community stronger in that town. Constance made a stand for her beliefs and the taller she stands, the easier it will be for others like her to stand tall. FYI: Not all southerns are ignorant homophobes. We just happen to have a lot of them down here. And i'm pretty sure that there is a circle in hell for them(hypocrites) as well. But, the climate is changing and only because of people like Constance. This coming from a college-educated, straight, libertarian southerner.            

0
MED

Well said, Nancy. This "event" (from the initiation of the request to the school board to "escort her girlfriend"  and wear a tux" to the continuing media fawning) was/is carefully orchestrated by McMillen's activist lesbian mother and her mother's activist community colleagues. By McMillen's own admission, she was never harrassed or bullied at anytime throughout her hs years, and she has been "out" and active since the 8th grade. If the school had said "yes" to the initial request, the activists would have STILL gone to the media, positioning McMillen as a successful brave lone youthful crusader for lgbt rights, showing those backwards Christian  MS heterosexuals what for! The point was to make an lgbt  point, at IAHS' (and the entire student body's) expense and to launch McMillen as an lgbt media cause celeb (she makes the media money).  NO ONE is required to *accept* homosexual behavior, just tolerate it.  And tolerance is a *two way* street. Remember that when championing lgbt rights. .            

1
lizzielou

Nancy your a sick individual.   Karma goes around and you will get yours.      

0
Marti Murphy

Since when did teenagers have to clear their date for prom with administration? If there wasn't a problem throughout the highschool years, although fellow students knew that she was gay, why all of a sudden would Constance feel the need to ask anyone's permission to bring her girlfriend to prom? I believe that the administrators over-reacted, but clearly something else is not right here. I wonder who has an agenda?

0
Jo135

How is all of you ganging up on "Nancy" any different than everyone bullying Pheobe or Constance? People targeted them because they didn't like something about them. Just because you dont share "Nancy's"  opinions or beliefs, that makes it ok to call her a moron, ignorant, or a sick individual? And we wonder where our children learn it from. Learn to express your opinions without having to put others down and maybe the next generation will be able to do the same.

0
Nancy Supporter

Ironic in a bullyish sort of way, isn't it?  of the homo faction to equate anyone who disagrees with them a "bigot", "terrorist", "ignorant" , (insert verbal slander here) and jump on the "equality" bandwagon. Ask any black person in America and see if they think what they suffered "equates" to the anger and intolerance of people exercising their freedom of [sexual] preference- and that's what it is- sexual preference. There is no scientific support that people can't choose their gayness-on the contrary we would have heard a big hubbub in the media had this information come to light sooner.  There is no social support for their behavior. Ahem, no social support besides those who also want to use this deviant social outlet to justify their behavior. To bash the people standing up for this moral normalcy is pretty balsy, considering the last count of gays in america numbered less than .6%  

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Susan Marie Kovalinsky
First Flagged at 12:33 PM, Apr 7, 2010 by Susan Marie Kovalinsky

Related Stories

Recommendations (6)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from