FBI and American Muslims: Balancing trust, suspicion

by Susan Marie Kovalinsky | December 19, 2009 at 09:34 pm
162 views | 16 Recommendations | 1 comment

Quote

"Home-based terrorism is here," Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano said in a recent speech in which she cited the arrests of U.S. citizens suspected of plotting attacks with al-Qaeda and other Muslim groups. The five Virginia men are U.S. citizens.
Homeland Security Secretary

As the FBI  and police have  reached out to Arab and Muslim communities across  the US,   forging ties of trust and and reciprocity,  there has also been the uneasiness of having to probe terror connections,  and investigate the degree of seriousness,  and connecting links to the middle east.  

Photos

Loading photos...

Law enforcement have had many occasions of the need to investigate or suspect activities such as the providing of  material support to terrorist organizations. Prosecutors are often  faced with the complex task of having to decipher  whether reported admissions to Pakistani authorities are admissible in a U.S. court and whether such statements were in any way coerced.

The concern about domestic terrorism as a threat is one that increases with time.  

Finding the balance between building trust with US Muslim communities,  while trying to keep at bay the threat of internal opposition is a tenuous one.  This ardent task is made worse by the fact that President Barack Obama  -  in a decisive break with his predecessor and the entire  W Bush Administration  - has vowed to improve and repair relations with Muslims around the globe.  

In the Washington Post piece on which this article is founded,  it is stated:  When asked about the arrests in Pakistan, Obama praised "the extraordinary contributions of the Muslim-American community."

U.S. law enforcement officials have praised the Muslim community for coming forward with concerns about its own,  in relation to domestic terror threat, which the FBI has lauded as a 'very positive step'.  

Since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FBI agents from the same office have met with Muslim leaders, fielded questions at mosques and participated in Ramadan feasts. The outreach might well have resulted in the families of the five men coming forward to the FBI to report them missing.

But that action now has agents and prosecutors facing a dilemma as the case has morphed from a missing persons investigation into a counter-terrorism probe. As U.S. officials consider whether to file criminal charges against the men and how aggressively to prosecute any potential case, some Muslim leaders are calling for leniency, saying the tough approach often used by the Bush administration would alienate a community whose relationship with law enforcement is uneasy.

"Charging them and throwing them in jail is not the solution," said Nihad Awad, national head of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, which approached the FBI on behalf of the families. "The government has to show some appreciation for the actions of the parents and the community. That will encourage other families to come forward."

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
1
Hugh Askew

"Since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, FBI agents from the same office have met with Muslim leaders, fielded questions at mosques and participated in Ramadan feasts. The outreach might well have resulted in the families of the five men coming forward to the FBI to report them missing.

....some Muslim leaders are calling for leniency, saying the tough approach often used by the Bush administration would alienate a community whose relationship with law enforcement is uneasy."

So, the effort put forth under Bush is no longer valid? Why? Because someone actually got arrested?  In other words, since we helped, we get off free?

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Hugh Askew
First Flagged at 2:52 AM, Dec 20, 2009 by Hugh Askew

Related Stories

Recommendations (16)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from