NP Rank:
Female managers face more sexual harassment
Female managers are 137 percent more likely to experience sexual harassment than their rank-and-file counterparts, according to a recently released study.Even Heather McLaughlin, a sociologist at the University of Minnesota and the primary investigator on the study, was surprised by the findings. “It’s sort of a paradox,” she says. “You would expect that having that status and power over other employees would protect you from that behavior.” Turns out it doesn’t, and McLaughlin’s conclusion is that “because of gender norms, people are still not accepting women in power positions.”
There's probably no surprise that women are still sexually harassed in the workplace. So long as we live in a patriarchy, women will be harassed in all sectors of society. What is slightly more surprising, however, is that female managers are much more likely to be harassed than female subordinates. What does this mean? Well, it seems to be about power. The men who are harassing are not doing so with overt and conscious sexual intent, but rather to undermine their female superiors.
The women in the study reported that men were not sexually harassing them because they wanted a relationship with them, McLaughlin says. “It was more about proving themselves,” she says about the harassers. Among the women in the study, many believed the harassment they encountered was all about undermining their authority.
The following quotes from research participants really speak for themselves.
“I was being harassed. I was being undermined,” she explains. “I think they were intimidated by me, and this was the only way to get power back.”
...
“The higher you were, the more of a power trip it became for men, and sometimes I thought they were not even aware of what they said,” she says.
The finding about power games doesn't come as much of a surprise to sexual harassment experts who argue that sexual harassment is always about power.
“Sexual harassment is, and always has been, about power more than it is about sex,” says Kathleen Neville.
...
“What is so difficult and frightening for women who are in management positions and have worked hard to get there is that they are suddenly feeling extremely vulnerable because they find themselves in a situation which might cost them everything.”
The article ends with some brief (arguably pinch-of-salt) advice for women who are facing these challenges.
--
For information: the study looked at tracking data for 600 individuals from adolescence into their 30s.
Recommendations (28)
-
Tina Kells
Vancouver, Canada
-
Patricia Turo
Switzerland (Confoederatio Helvetica) -
Amy Judd
Vancouver, Canada -
a211423
Clearlake, California, United States -
smkovalinsky
New York, New York, United States



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (4)
at 16:12 on September 15th, 2009
I think people like to push to see how far they can take things, and it's also jealousy for sure, the men are jealous of the position of power a woman holds over them
at 16:30 on September 15th, 2009
Really, except that my last boss has a harassment suit on and I can guarantee from how I was "approached" and made believe it didn't happen (and apparent eyewitnesses as well) that the suit has a real basis in fact.
Amy, what if I said something parallel to your statement and something which, of course, has some degree of truth to it, as your statement does, such as, "Women are jealous of the position of power a man holds over them".
Would that be a sexist statement?
at 07:06 on September 16th, 2009
I am not denying that sexual harassment happens, but is it not also true that women are better at flirting than men ? I am also not disgusted when an ugly woman flirts with me, I try to remain polite. Women are also often physically intimidated by men.
at 09:38 on September 28th, 2009
Thank you for your comments and recommendations, all.