Gaza conflict being fought on Facebook

by mtippett | January 12, 2009 at 10:31 am
463 views | 43 Recommendations | 6 comments

Photos

'Weird' Facebook site shut

'Weird' Facebook site shut

see larger image

uploaded by stvalentine

A frend of mine on Facebook who is a strong defender of Israel pointed me in the direction of a group who is planning on petitioning FB to remove groups that they believe encourages violence agaionst  or threaten Jews, Israelis or the contry.  They hope to get 250,000 people signed up and they are half way there.  Here is their statement:


NOTICE: PLEASE READ THE "RECENT NEWS" SECTION TO LEARN ABOUT OUR CURRENT FUND-RAISER FOR THE FAMILIES OF IDF SOLDIERS KILLED/WOUNDED WHILE FIGHTING IN GAZA DURING OPERATION CAST LEAD (THE ISRAELI-PALESTINIAN WAR IN GAZA)! WE HAVE CURRENTLY RAISED OVER $2,000!

____________________________________________________________


ON FACEBOOK, THERE ARE MANY ANTI-ISRAELI/ANTI-JEWISH GROUPS, AND EVEN MORE PEOPLE WHO SHARE SUCH VIEWS. However, there are few pro-Israeli/pro-Judaism groups, and that is why we are here.

Please join and invite all of your friends to join; if, and ONLY if, you've invited at least 500 friends, message Todd, and if you fit certain restrictions, you will be promoted to officer. Please do not message Todd if you have invited less than 500 friends; our many thanks and great appreciation are implied here, and we simply do not have the time of day to respond to every single one of those questions.

Though a Facebook group may seem like a little thing, it can go a long way.

Please DO NOT message Todd or Yonatan asking them to advertise your group on this group's page; we have a no-advertising policy and, because the group is over 5,000 members, we no longer have the ability to message all of it's members. Therefore, if you do, we will just disregard it.

Separate business and other non-Facebook related causes are accepted, however.

____________________________________________________________

ONCE WE REACH 250,000 MEMBERS, WE WILL PETITION FACEBOOK TO REMOVE ALL GROUPS WHICH SAY THINGS SUCH AS "G-D BLESS HITLER," "F--K THE JEWS," "F--K ISRAEL," ETC., AND GROUPS WHICH ENCOURAGE VIOLENCE AGAINST AND/OR THREATEN JEWS, ISRAELIS, OR THE NATION OF ISRAEL AS A WHOLE.

Though this may appear to be a violation of the First Amendment (Freedom of Speech), we have learned it is not. The Bill of Rights only applies to the Government, and entails that the Government cannot obstruct with the rights of the people. Facebook is a private company, and not owned, funded, or operated by the Government; thus the Freedom of Speech law does not apply for them. The rules for Facebook are made by it's creators, and listed in the Terms of Use page. There, on the fourth bullet point under the User Conduct section, it clearly states that no Facebook user can "upload, post, transmit, share, store or otherwise make available any content that we deem to be harmful, threatening, unlawful, defamatory, infringing, abusive, inflammatory, harassing, vulgar, obscene, fraudulent, invasive of privacy or publicity rights, hateful, or racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable."

Thus, groups such as "Israel Is Not A Country" can be removed by Facebook without violating the United States Constitution Bill Of Rights. To learn more, visit http://www.facebook.com/...0965798&topic=4669


Please remember, we are not trying to have Facebook censor anti-Israeli groups. Only groups that would violate Facebook's Terms of Use. We won't try to petition groups such as "I Wonder How Quickly I Can Find 1,000,000 People Who Dislike Israel" because they have as much of a right to say what they believe in as we do.

To view Facebook's Terms of Use page, scroll to the bottom of this (or any Facebook) page and click the "Terms" button to the right. It is highly recommended that you do if you have any questions about the legality of our petition. Much more information is listed there.
recommend This comment thread is now closed
2
Paschen

I do not like the sound of this. Censorship will backfire eventually. I would agree with a set of rules and Editing or some guide lines to be followed... 

1
Emilio Lizardo

Astonishing !!!

0
gerrypopplestone

Your title says this is about Gaza!  But it's really about anti-semitic antics on Facebook!

0
notpublic2

that friend is a friend, NP is also unabashedly pro-war-crime and bashind, banning those whow are actually citizens and not from the army of blogges the IDF unleashed online.

clearyl for those of us who are also jewish, israel is an abominable mass-murdering, war criminal machine. trampling on their own history, NP rolls out the digital carpet.

NowPublic is in many ways a throw back to 5 oclock news from New Jersey with pretensions of openness and inclusiveness when actually it sucks the credibility that citizen journalism had here a chance to apply for the public good.

this sort of text relegated to footnote comment status is not enough, not public and i hope this portal goes the way of other slick and smug start ups and stops trampling on canada's citizen journalism images as rhetoric to waste venture capital on unworhty and worse planted and planned obstruction to the real news as citizens see it.

Israel is Not a Country ... is freedom of speech, could be a Bob Dylan lyric to my ears. And it is not a country in the sense of humanity and tolerance and openness and peace. If war criminals and child mass murderers snactioned and unleashed is wat a poet or writer means as a group title, a band title, then I get it. Israel is not a country.

0
tipp off

the mtippett story is advertorial for that pro-isreal facebook group. as creator of NowPublic, he clearly demonstrates with his own writing, in his own words, his total lack of jouranlism's essential and most basic ethics.

Like NowPublic, its members censored by selective interpretation of its own conveniently fuzzy CoC Code of Conduct, banning those for equal enthusiasm to the IDF-overs or mega.Zionist writers it features almost exclusively, mtippett is abusing the new found credibility of citizen journalism - its not CNN and it's by uncensored simple people, so it must be believable, right? being the motto . to further a biased and prejudiced agenda on 'his' site, that is in fact NotPublic only Now Public after its been censored. Also the choice of good ol' tolerant and open Canada, Vancouver, what a great place to hide a propaganda machine hiding unde the cover of citizen juornalism.

0
acc1dentaljouran1st

It certainly wasnt fought here Mr Tippet, under your golden 'watch'. Here there was iron-fisted censorship and bias by your 'favorite' editor AJ that was a damaging breach of cyber journalistic ethics that i spread is the swine flu for all of the openness from software to source code that respectible netheads like Richard Stallman advocate. Not NP.

I promise to do all in my ability to inform the venture capital groups that are until now supporting your efort. The sales pitch is bogus, and exploits instead of builds what citizen journalism has to offer and its role that guys like the founder of participate.net really believe is a backbone of a post-consuer concerned economy. Enjoy your moment in the sun of a yuppise screen. your grasp of CJ is wrong-footed and will trip up and fade soon enough. Your AJ damage is not to be corrected and you have yoursel not acted properly in protecting the rights of CJists. You are probably not even combing over the text and sources. That you will have time to do and kick yourself for not seeing the obvious. You know where and how to reach me and i dont hold grudges, just convictions of a pacifist and free as in freedom community member. let your censors go back to bad tv jobs if they can find them, especially the colonialist ones you encourage to pontificate here and now. imagine you have actually removed someones free content contribution, researched and clear, just to cover up. NP is Not Public, as you know. It is also Not Plausible, Not Peaceful and Now Predujiced.

The financial crisis is a moral bankruptcy not in trival sitcom ways, but in the huge ways NP denies and breaches journalistic and open media ethics. You bite the hand that feeds us all and take a bike ride and think it over Mr Tippett.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Paschen
First Flagged at 11:44 AM, Jan 12, 2009 by Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (43)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from