Girl Shot Dead By Police Iran

uploaded by Jon Azpiri June 21, 2009 at 12:56 pm
17111 views | 61 comments | 91 recommendations

Girl Shot Dead By Police Iran

Video Properties
NP! ID: 2371885
Title: Girl Shot Dead By Police Iran
File Size: 321 bytes

Created: Sun, 06/21/2009 - 12:56pm
Modified: Sun, 06/21/2009 - 12:56pm

File Type: multimedia (text/plain)
recommend This comment thread is now closed
6
Stanley12

i'm sorry to say but after viewing this a second time, i think it may be staged. notice at :11 secs, a small vial of red dye in her hands and as she proceeds to pour the liquid on her face and quickly hand the vial to someone else. then she is seen without the vial after the red liquid has collected over her face. also, if she gets shot in the torso, she wouldn't bleed from her face like that.

3
Dr. Paul

I don't think it is staged Stanley.  I have heard different reports on the location of the bullet entry but it does appear consistent with a shot to the chest or torso.  Blood could quickly flow from the face.  Notice that even before she was lowered to the ground her back and buttocks were covered with blood.  These injuries are consistent with and injury from a high powered rifle.

1
drusus

please be careful with fake-statements if you dont have proof - this is about more than just your ego.

0
D Rap

I agree. The man with the white hair presses her cheek and blood comes out of her mouth (from the left), his hand moves up toward her nose and it's the same thing. I would think that she would have to cough in order to move the blood up and out???? She doesn't do that. And somebody's hand does move over and all of a sudden she has blood all over her face (from where??).

It's so sad that we have to be so cynical when it comes to these things....

0
jon1224

Are you stupid???!?!?!


When you get shot through the heard, your system breaks down and blood spills out of you mouth, her heart has been punctured, the blood is still traveling through the artiery however, where's it going to go, straight into her esophegus (channel to stomach), and up into her mouth, and out.

Please don't be so rude next time.

0
jon122229

Of course its not staged. When you get shot into the heart, your heart is punctured, but the blood is still traveling through the artery which leads to the heart, that blood goes straight into the esophegus (which is also punctured) and up into the mouth, and spills out.


Don't be so negative the girl just died in her father's hands.

0
ham

stanley,

 you are a twat

0
Britawni

Wtf? -.- theres not vial in her hand u idiot.. thats her own friken blood on her hands..

0
darvish

this is a fake video 2 times eddited,1 when camera go behine the old man with ble shirt2 when camera go behinde a guy with white shirt with white shirt.

why is fake???

1-when they try to lay girls on the floor she put her hand on the floor thats not possible when someone shot there.

2.there is a caps uder her head and when they lay her doen there is no caps on the floor and dring video no one put the caps under her head.

3.there is a women scream which there is no women there.

4-her head has no hair in the end,and before end yo see her gead highlighted with photo shop.

5-the old guy push her face with his finger and blood  comes out first time

6-after show her eys gone and dead she move her hand end of video and her eys isstraight,how thw dead girl can do that

7-when film start and camera move yo see her jeans looks so thick which ois look like edited and when yo pase yo see the old gy hand is front of camera and the girl face is highlighted so no one can see her face,

8,end of video when you see floor its look like cut pasted and highlited.

9, she is not exist?where is her friend and family yo dont see single person pt any video or picture from her from past like birthday poicture and so on.she act and tey killed her maybe she was a prisoner who have noone in her life and regime did this ti scare people.if this girl exist5 in first place.

10.the guy who claim to be her doctor his one of the secret services from iran, mousavi and rafsanjani made this senario to show how crap is the goverment.

11-on the 2 video exist one is 16 sec 1 is 40 second yo see many people fimling with mobile what happend to their video,they all from the regimne and jst wanted to be sure this film edit properly.

12-think dont believe

0
nura

get a life...how can you people all be speaking like this.....blood when someone suffers from head injury heart puncture throat, i mean if you think, its your oesophagus that keep everything out of your mouth and nose, so of course blood will come out....rather instead of desrespecting a dead person and finding faults in her death...could you not hear how her father was screaming for her....shae on all you people.....

 

there is even a memorial for her....

may Allah have mercy on all you ignorant people....

 

get a life...for goodness sake!!!.

0
nura

actually you do bleed like that....are you a doctor?????

shame on you....if you look closely you will see it is actually real blood as the consistancy of the liquid a thicker than fake blood, and the colour is the colour of blood!!!!!!

 

0
nura

so get your facts straight before makings assumptions on matter that you have no clue on

 

the poor girl is dead...have a little respect, as i am sure you would appreciate the same respect in your hour!!!!

5
pem

U are incorrect about the torso shot. She appears to be shot it two places............the upper torso shot is in the correct placement for a heart/lung penetration which if so she would bleed violently from her mouth and nose. I believe the video is authentic,

0
geo-man

NOT good - i hope this country gets what they want...you do NOT kill your own!

0
Jamie S

geo-man are you saying that they should attack other countrys?

i do belive its wrong to kill... even your own people but i think this should be put a side...  this shouldnt of been put out like this even if it was or wasnt a scandal.

5
JJJ

You lame ass computer geek gonna sit there and try to say this is a fake.  This isn't one of your video games you dumb stupid fu^k.  She was shot in the heart and choked on the blood, which is why it flowed from her mouth and nose.  Sitting 9,000 miles away what the fu^k do you know about it.

1
D Rap

Sitting 9,000 miles away what the fu^k do you know about it.

Are you there? Otherwise the same can be said to you...

0
EsperIII

No. I believe Stanley is right.

The man on the right is very careful to keep his hand placed over the wound the entire time to obscure it from sight. If we are expected to believe this video begins seconds after the shot, these men act strangely. If a young girl were dying in your arms, would you make sure to look at the camera to make sure it was being filmed? Would you hold your hand on a gunshot wound or would you try to visually assess it?

Stanley is correct in bring attention to the motion of her left hand. Video is not fact people. Always remember this. Lives are lost every day in war and on our streets. I don't mean to lessen the impact of an atrocity occuring in another country.

JJJ, as you would say "What the fu^k do you know about it?" Are you an expert on human anatomy and gunshot wounds? Can you verify that this video is real? No, you can't. Stanley is only trying to call to attention his opinion on the matter. You trying to shut him up is just fearmongering BS. If you wish to believe the video is real, do so, and ignore those who say otherwise.

4
f-box

The only known facts right now are that people are dying for their freedom (as even admitted by the regime). As far as i know not even the mullahs are denying the dead of Neda - so why are you?

1
DrTarian

    

To the Ignorant,

This video is real and not staged.  Those of you who have commented about this video being staged/fake are not exhibiting any type of intelligence.

     This girl has been shot just inferior to her right clavicle (below right collar-bone).  A projectile entering at this location will puncture and rip through the upper lobe of the right lung.  In addition to lung injury and hemorrhage, this projectile (bullet) has possibly also punctured the subclavian artery and vein, and/or pulmonary artery. 

     Judging from the color of the blood that is seen exiting her mouth and nose, it is of venous origin or deoxygenated blood.  Though it is possible it can be a mixture of both oxygenated and deoxygenated blood.  It should be noted that the Pulmonary artery, which could have been punctured by a projectile entering the right upper chest, is the only “artery” in the human body that contains deoxygenated blood. Deoxygenated blood has the color seen in this video.

     Initially, the victim is in a sitting position before she is laid down supine (flat).  In that initial position the blood exiting the punctured vessels will pool in the right pleural cavity (right chest cavity) and will also fill the right lung. When the victim is finally laid supine the pooled blood in the right chest and lung travel up the bronchioles, bronchus, trachea and out through the mouth and nose.  This would be just like slowly filling-up a 2-liter plastic soda bottle with water while upright, then when half-way full laid on its side causing the water to pour out.  Simple physics!

     Someone commented about the victim looking directly into the camera, and that this was additional proof that this video was staged.  That comment was proof of that writer’s stupidity! 

     When a trauma victim, such as the young girl in this video (bless her soul), is losing large quantities of blood, major organ systems (e.g. Central Nervous System/Brain) become hypoperfused (receiving an insufficient oxygen supply).  In other words, the brain begins to infarct/die from the lack of oxygen that used to be delivered by the blood.  A physical sign of brain ischemia, the stage before irreversible brain damage or infarction/death secondary to the lack of oxygen delivery, is Horizontal Eye Deviation.

     The victim exhibits horizontal eye deviation, as it is apparent when it appears she is voluntarily looking into the camera.  This was not voluntary!  Both of her eyes deviate horizontally into a rightward gaze, a reflex that is completely involuntary.  This was a sign her brain was not being perfused with oxygenated blood due to her massive and severe hemorrhage caused by the gunshot.

     This video was proof of murder! These are sad, sad days we are living in people! 

2
DrTarian

    

This video is real and not staged.  Those of you who have commented about this video being staged/fake are not exhibiting any type of intelligence.  You may believe you are, but sorry its complete stupidity!

     This girl has been shot just inferior to her right clavicle (below right collar-bone).  A projectile entering at this location will puncture and rip through the upper lobe of the right lung.  In addition to lung injury and hemorrhage, this projectile (bullet) has possibly also punctured the subclavian artery and vein, and/or pulmonary artery. 

     Judging from the color of the blood that is seen exiting her mouth and nose, it is of venous origin or deoxygenated blood.  Though it is possible it can be a mixture of both oxygenated and deoxygenated blood.  It should be noted that the Pulmonary artery, which could have been punctured by a projectile entering the right upper chest, is the only “artery” in the human body that contains deoxygenated blood. Deoxygenated blood has the color seen in this video.

     Initially, the victim is in a sitting position before she is laid down supine (flat).  In that initial position the blood exiting the punctured vessels will pool in the right pleural cavity (right chest cavity) and will also fill the right lung. When the victim is finally laid supine the pooled blood in the right chest and lung travel up the bronchioles, bronchus, trachea and out through the mouth and nose.  This would be just like slowly filling-up a 2-liter plastic soda bottle with water while upright, then when half-way full laid on its side causing the water to pour out.  Simple physics!

     Someone commented about the victim looking directly into the camera, and that this was additional proof that this video was staged.  That comment was proof of that writer’s stupidity! 

     When a trauma victim, such as the young girl in this video (bless her soul), is losing large quantities of blood, major organ systems (e.g. Central Nervous System/Brain) become hypoperfused (receiving an insufficient oxygen supply).  In other words, the brain begins to infarct/die from the lack of oxygen that used to be delivered by the blood.  A physical sign of brain ischemia, the stage before irreversible brain damage or infarction/death secondary to the lack of oxygen delivery, is Horizontal Eye Deviation.

     The victim exhibits horizontal eye deviation, as it is apparent when it appears she is voluntarily looking into the camera.  This was not voluntary!  Both of her eyes deviate horizontally into a rightward gaze, a reflex that is completely involuntary.  This was a sign her brain was not being perfused with oxygenated blood due to her massive and severe hemorrhage caused by the gunshot.

     This video was proof of murder! These are sad, sad days we are living in people!  It makes no sense!

4
drusus

@EsperIII

The only known facts right now are that people are dying for their freedom (as even admitted by the regime). As far as i know not even the mullahs are denying the dead of Neda - so why are you?

3
An Iranian girl

I can't see the video, because the internet speed is very low in Iran, youtube is filtered (blocked, do you even know what it means?!!!) and we have low access to sites.

I don't know it's a fake or not. I can believe it's reall, because I am living in this country and have seen the rallies and bloods and bottoms, ... I can believe it, because I know this regime.

But I really hope this video is a fake, because if it has happened, it's a really sad story. The death of humanity.

We saw a lot of fakes things here, fake election, ..... but this is the only fake I wish is a fake!

0
nura

heeriousr name is Neda

The Calling....Allah works in mysterious ways...and he obviously chose her aa messenger...so to all you who believe in Allah , dont make a mockery of him...if you look at her poor father, and the family she comes from, look into her eyes in her pictures you will see the truth, and you will know that i am sure her family does not have time for such games and mockery, i am sure they were good people and live a harmonious and tranquil life, and had better things to do than to make fun of a very seems to be a very real and serious situation in the world!!!!1P.U.H.

AMIEN

0
nura

Sometimes in life we dont even need facts to understand things...but we can use logic and hour hearts to tell us the Truth....but maybe all you ignorant people who have made such comments have been devoured and blinded from the Truth of Life, that your Hearts have become so cold that it has Blinded you to see the Truth.

1
An Iranian girl

I can't see the video, because the internet speed is very low in Iran, youtube is filtered (blocked, do you even know what it means?!!!) and we have low access to sites.

I don't know it's a fake or not. I can believe it's reall, because I am living in this country and have seen the rallies and bloods and bottoms, ... I can believe it, because I know this regime.

But I really hope this video is a fake, because if it has happened, it's a really sad story. The death of humanity.

We saw a lot of fakes things here, fake election, ..... but this is the only fake I wish is a fake!

7
Another Human

I'm sorry to say that I have seen a few people die right in front of me over the span of my lifetime - more than I care to remember, but I do remember each and every one of them.  If this is a faked video, this young woman deserves the best award ever given for movie acting.  Unfortunately, this is almost certainly no fake as I have seen this image before with my own eyes.  The blood on my hands was real...and the blood you saw streaming from this young woman - the life you saw pass from her body - was real too.

Every decent man and woman in this world lost something very valuable when Neda was struck by that bullet.  We may be of different religious faiths and we may live our lives under the flag of different nations, but we are all children of God.  No man (or woman) is an island.  If that image doesn't burn you deep in your soul just as that bullet burned deep in Neda's body, then you need to spend some time looking in a mirror.

God bless you Neda, and all the good people of Iran.  Your voices are heard.  Your suffereing is not done alone.

0
Think

If Neda's death was really a fake, don't you think the goverment would be all over the television pointing that out?  Instead, all we hear from them is that her family is banned from giving her a funeral.

If the video was faked, a very alive and well Neda would be on display for the whole world to see and the government would be using the video as evidence of how they are being unfairly attacked.

0
David draftman

I think it's fake too. At 2 seconds the guy in white starts looking for the camera.

0
james123111

Draftman is correct! How did  the guy in white know there was a camera??

This video was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from