Gulf War Syndrome, Suicide and Neurological Damage Linked to Chemical Exposure

by patgarcia | July 9, 2008 at 10:21 am | 613 views | 17 comments | 36 recommendations

Many of us know war heroes, many of us know about somebody's broken life personally, many of us have a loved one suffering the aftershocks of war, fighting in despair against something that goes beyond themselves.... within themselves, after having fought for their country.

Click here to read about one of those heroes, Joseph Patrick Dwyer

A federal panel of medical experts studying illnesses among veterans of the 1991 war in the Persian Gulf has broken with several earlier studies and concluded that many suffer from neurological damage caused by exposure to toxic chemicals, rejecting past findings that the ailments resulted mostly from wartime stress.

Citing new scientific research on the effects of exposure to low levels of neurotoxins, the Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans' Illnesses concludes in its draft report that "a substantial proportion of Gulf War veterans are ill with multisymptom conditions not explained by wartime stress or psychiatric illness."

It says a growing body of research suggests that many veterans' symptoms have a neurological cause and that there is a "probable link" to exposure to neurotoxins.

The report says possible sources include sarin, a nerve gas, from an Iraqi weapons depot blown up by American forces in 1991; a drug, pyridostigmine bromide, given to troops to protect against nerve gas; and pesticides used to protect soldiers in the region.

Latest US Army suicide statistics from 2007 can be seen on the posted chart.

Between April 1, 1991, and December 31, 2007, 162 Gulf veterans died “due to intentional self-harm” or from other incidents where the intent was unclear, leading to open verdicts at inquests.

The latest figures appear to back up the case of campaigners seeking compensation from the MoD for Gulf veterans who have suffered traumas since the conflict ended.

The 162 deaths compare with 144 recorded among a similar group of men and women who were serving in the Armed Forces in 1991 but were not sent to the Gulf.

Weapons of Mass Destruction

Moreover, it is an incontrivertible fact that Saddam possessed and used WMD (of the chemical variety, at least) in years past - not only against the Iranians but his own people. (And possibly against U.S. soldiers in Operation Desert Storm, based on some Agent Orange reports).

Finally, it is also an undisputed fact that Saddam refused to fully cooperate with United Nations weapons inspectors. He pointedly declined to answer very specific questions about weapons and materials that were not accounted for. What was he hiding?

Highly toxic substance used at Iraq plant.

      Washington - US soldiers assigned to guard a crucial part of Iraq's oil infrastructure became ill after exposure to a highly toxic chemical at the plant, witnesses testified at a Democratic Policy Committee hearing yesterday on Capitol Hill.

    "These soldiers were bleeding from the nose, spitting blood," said Danny Langford, an equipment technician from Texas brought to work at the Qarmat Ali Water treatment plant in 2003. "They were sick."

    "Hundreds of American soldiers at this site were contaminated" while guarding the plant, Langford said, including members of the Indiana National Guard.

Approximately 100,000 may have dealt with mustard gas.

According to CNN, troops in the Gulf War may have dealt with mustard gas on several occasions. As many as seven U.S. Army divisions, or approximately 100,000 soldiers, may have been exposed during the war. While the total number remains unconfirmed, several soldiers who served during the Gulf War experienced symptoms in line with mustard gas exposure [source: CNN].

The Khamisiyah storage site
In May 1996, an UNSCOM team revisited the Khamisiyah site and decided that these rockets were binary agent (GB/GF) filled. In July 1996, the CIA presented its downwind hazard model to the Presidential Advisory Committee. Based on some modeling and assumptions, they suggested that a downwind hazard of four km might cause acute symptoms of runny noses and headaches, and an area of up to 25 km might have been contaminated at a much lower dosage level that we call the general population dosage limit. That's a 72 hour exposure at 0.013 milligram-minutes/cubic meter), which is lower than the 0.04 mg-min/m3 that govt workers at Army chemical weapons storage sites have to observe, much lower than the incapacitating dose of 2-3 mg-min/m3, and a hell of a lot lower than the lethal dose of 70-100 mg-min/m3.  That model didn't take into account hot desert weather, the 37 other bunkers exploding, or the purity of the chemical agent. But just to be safe, the DOD doubled the hazard area and announced in October 1996 that 15-20,000 troops might have been exposed to nerve agent as a result of these explosions. After re-running the models, refining the results, and adding a significant conservative safety estimate, DOD [Department of Defense] announced in September 1997 that about 99,000 troops might have been exposed to nerve agents, over a three-day period, as a result of the explosion.  In 2000, DOD ran another study and upped the number to 101,752, based on troop locations and three different models' hazard plumes. What was lost in the study was the fact that the overwhelming majority of the "exposed soldiers" were subjected to levels that, had they been exposed to those levels for the rest of their lives, would not have suffered any ill effects from nerve agent.
US Army exploded an Iraqi chemical weapons depot at Kamashiya.
At the close of the Gulf War, the US Army exploded an Iraqi chemical weapons depot at Kamashiya. In 1996, the Department of Defense finally admitted that more than 20,000 US troops were exposed to VX and sarin nerve agents as a result of the US operation at Kamashiya. This may be one cause of the Gulf War Syndrome. Another cause might be the experimental vaccines unwittingly given to more than 100,000 US troops, or the depleted uranium shells used during the bombings.

Before we learn how mustard gas works, it's important to understand what a gas is in terms of chemical warfare. Just the word "gas" may lead people to think that the substance is a vapor. That's not entirely true. Gases in warfare can be any chemical substance, including gases, solids and liquids, and generally fall into one of three medical groups.

  1. Lethal gases can lead to disablement or death.

Mustard gas, also called sulfur mustard, gets its name from its sometimes yellow appearance and mustardlike smell. It's referred to as a blister agent or a vesicant, and comes in vapor, solid or liquid form. Other blister agents include nitrogen mustard, lewisite and­ phosgene oxime.

Blister agents are no fun. Once in contact with an unsuspecting victim, they damage skin and internal areas such as mucous membranes inside your nose and throat. Mustard gas is an alkylating agent, meaning its chemicals destroy DNA and cells and liquefy tissue. In essence, mustard gas kills tissue and membranes in the areas it touches. Alkylating agents also are often used in cancer drugs.

recommend Add a comment
0
PEP

Didn't I give this a Good Stuff flag and a comment earlier! Help!

0
patgarcia

No PEP,

It was for the other story, the one about the army medic that died due to Post Traumatic Disorder. This is a subsequent story.


0
PEP

Thanks. :)  It's a busy day here and I thought that briefly I'd lost it. Are you linking all related stories together? Cheers!

PEP
PEP
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:14 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff. I wish more people truly understood *real* PTSD--which also strikes police force, fire fighters, investigators, and just ordinary people exposed to serious trauma--and the long-term effects of that, as well as chemicals. PTSD..is well...like living in a war or trauma zone, forever, at short notice. Many rape victims suffer from PTSD. Life is normal and suddenly, wham! The PTSD person somehow is jerked back into a very very bad place. One time a car backfired while we were on the Walk to Remember, and next thing I knew, this huge warrior, former Marine, had me on the ground and was covering me from gunshots. *That* fast--by the time I heard it, I was on the ground. Wild stuff.

mgmirkin
mgmirkin
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 12:12 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff.

Lots of quoting, but generally "good stuff!" Interesting. So, it seems "gulf war syndrome" may actually be in their heads. Literally. IE, actual exposure to neurotoxins that may have done neurological damage, among other things.

Regards,
~Michael Gmirkin

0
patgarcia

Michael Gmirkin,

Thanks for the flag and good comments, I did get a little carried away with the quoting didn't I?

I really appreciate your analytic comments!

Sincerely

Pat

Caoimhin1
Caoimhin1
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 13:34 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff.  Was there any mention of the Depleted Uranium ammunition used Pat?

0
patgarcia

Thanks for the flag! They do mention the use of depleted uranium ammunition even in Puerto Rico. You can read more about it, if you want.


"Another cause might be the experimental vaccines unwittingly given to more than 100,000 US troops, or the depleted uranium shells used during the bombings."

Luiz Castro
Luiz Castro
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 18:38 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff.

Muy bien, gracias por compartir!

0
patgarcia

ifcastro,

Muchas gracias por la bandera y comentario!

Bendiciones!


0
patgarcia

ifcastro,

Muchas Gracias por la bandera y comentario!

Bendiciones


0
politisite

Pat,

I see you have some updated suicide statistics from Reuters.  I was drawing on stats that were accurate when I was Practicing.  It appears that you are correct that the suicide rates per 100,000 are higher then the population as a whole.  This was not the case prior to this war.

Thanks for the correction (an making me look bad, LOL).  Great job on this story


0
patgarcia

Dear Politisite,

I just wanted to make sure I had updated correct information, I know you were using the information you had then! No other intention! I really appreciate your comment and contribution to this story, you know my best friend was exposed to mustard gas and her life has not been good since. This issue really really breaks my heart, to know that many can't handle this situation, to know that many are not understood, to know that I lost my best friend even though she's alive. I thank you so much for sharing  your experience concerning this issue. How are these persons being helped? I know my friend isn't.


Rhonda J Mangus
Rhonda J Mangus
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 21:16 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff.

politisite
politisite
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 22:25 on July 9th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff.  I was in the military during this time.  I was a mental health theapist and my area of expertise was combat psychiatry.  The suicide numbers you cited in the article are lower then the national avg.  I beleive something was going on.  Before there was anything called GWS, I had patients who came back from the Gulf who had a number of symtoms.  One year after I had sent records to St. Louis I recevied a memorandum asking if I had any patients with certin symtoms.  Since I had allready send on the records for storage, I had to track down the soldiers I could remember with those symtoms.  Many feel through the cracks as some had gotten out of the svc.  Others were at another durty station etc.

My intial thoughts of what was going on, was that soldiers who had PTSD had tranferred their emotions to physical problems.  Called a convesion disorder.  Since many of the symtoms clustered and were related by many soldiers the same we thought it was minimal exposure to biological weapons.  Many of the soldiers related that their detectors went off in the field.  They were told they were false alarms by higher in the command chain.  I think it was exposure to low levels of biological weapons that caused an auto-immune responce.  The clusters of symptoms fall within that catagory.  examples of autoimmune deseases are:  Ulcerative Colitus, Chrohns disease, skin rashes, lupis, etc.  These occur because the body sees itself as an infection and attacks itself causing inflammation, high white blood cell counts, and low grade fevers.  Fibomyagia, Body ache and pain not explained by labs or x-rays. 

I am a Gulf war vet and in 1994 discharged from the military due to medical issues.  I ended up in bed for nearly two years in 1998 and had to retire for the VA Medical center. 

 I do not know if I have GWS, I was not exposed to biological weapons as far as I know.  I did have a couple of problems before the gulf.  Some people went so far as to say that since I did breiefings with all of the returning soldiers that I may have been exposed to something.  I am in dobt about that.

Thank You for your story and I hope folks understand that these people are not Kooks.  There is something really there.

 

urbano411
  • editor
urbano411
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 15:07 on July 10th, 2008

patgarcia, I like this story. It's good stuff. These men an women deserve our respect and the best care money can buy. Thanks for this story.

0
Jagmedic

Please support Desert Storm Veterans who health deteriorate 20 yrs more than their age. We suffer chronic multisympthom illenesses. 135,000 are not longer able to work and our ages range from 39 to 60. Pass this Annoucement.

This Committee is asking for written comments for Veterans

This Committee is allowing Vets to speak before them, during Public Coment Sessions.

This Committee is allowing Vets to  Teleconferece - hearing sessions by telephone.

Silence is not an Option !  http://www.va.gov/gulfwaradvisorycommittee

VA - Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans

Department of Veterans Affairs

Office of Policy and Planning (008A1)

810 Vermont Ave, Washington, DC  20420

202-461-5758  Lelia P. Jackson, Policy Analyst ,lelia.jackson@va.gov

Additionally, the Committee will meet with a panel of Gulf War veterans who reside in the Baltimore area. Gulf War veterans living in the Baltimore area who served in the Southwest Asia theater of operations during 1990-1991 wishing to participate in the panel should contact Lelia Jackson

Public comments will be received on November 19, from 1 p.m. until 1:30 p.m. and on November 20, from 11:15 a.m. until 11:45 a.m. Individuals wishing to speak must register not later than November 14 by contacting Ms. Jackson and by submitting 1-2 page summary of their comments for inclusion in the official record. Public comments will be limited to five minutes each. A sign-in sheet will be available each day. Members of the public may also submit written statements for the Committee's review  Interested parties may also listen in by teleconferencing into the meeting. The toll-free teleconference line will be open from 10 a.m. until 4:30 p.m. on November 19 and from 9 a.m. until 5 p.m. on November 20. To register for the teleconference, contact Ms. Jackson.  Any member of the public seeking additional information should contact Laura O'Shea,

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

July 9, 2008 at 10:21 am by patgarcia, 613 views, 17 comments

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from