Have psychiatric wards changed?

by generaldecay | July 27, 2009 at 09:37 am
126 views | 9 Recommendations | 3 comments
If you found yourself locked up against your will in a psychiatric ward, you would probably do your best to get out. But in 1969 a group of people did just the opposite — they tried to get in. A young American psychologist called David Rosenhan persuaded seven friends (two psychologists, a psychiatrist, a doctor, a housewife, a painter and a student) to see whether they could convince doctors that they were mentally ill simply by claiming to hear voices. Now previously unpublished notes from Rosenhan’s private archive reveal what the experience was really like.

I highlighted a piece recently about the horrendous (and hidden) situation with mental health in the UK. The current highlighted piece describes a study which took place in the US in the 60s, which illustrated the often frightening world of the psychiatric patient.

Having claimed to hear words from “thud” and “empty” to “hollow”, words selected because they had never been recorded in psychiatric literature, every pseudo-patient was admitted to hospital for varying lengths of time, from 7 to 52 days. They were given diagnoses of schizophrenia and prescribed a total of 2,100 pills (only two of which were swallowed; in preparation for the study the pseudo-patients had learnt to “cheek” any medication).

This is a very interesting piece for anyone who is interested in psychiatry. It is perhaps not as 'helpful' as we're led to believe...

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
tikun

 Thanks. Once caught in the web of mental health professionals you are at the mercy of the insane.

0
generaldecay

I have to say that I find that an unhelpful 'conclusion', not least because it is disrespectful to an entire industry which can achieve much good. Yes, the psychiatric profession could benefit from improvement - as this piece among others shows - but one shouldn't write it off completely.

2
J2B

I was a friend of Ronnie Laing  the psychiatrist who wrote many good books in that time about the state of the British mental health service. Much of what he wrote, like "Knots" still applies today. At that time they still used electric shock therapy which was used on my Nana, because she was having strange dreams. She was never the same after that!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

enlargetom
First Flagged at 9:53 AM, Jul 27, 2009 by enlargetom

Related Stories

Recommendations (9)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from