Hillary 'Embellished' Bosnia Sniper Story

by Rob Walker | March 25, 2008 at 06:56 am
2308 views | 50 Recommendations | 15 comments

Videos

Clinton Embellishes Past (CBS News)

see larger video

sourced by Rob Walker

Clinton Embellishes Past (CBS News)

Update: Tuesday 10:51am EST - Hillary responded this morning, saying she 'misspoke' about her recollections of Bosnia. Now her story has changed a bit, apparently.

This story is already the #1 or #2 story on all the major news outlets, and is ranked twice in the top 50 google search trends. I don't see it going away or being a 'minor blip' as one Clinton advisor hopefully suggested.

Both Sinbad and a CBS news crew, who were there with Hillary during the trip, say it was safe and easy. The CBS video is on the right. 

It will be interesting to see what Obama and McCain have to say about it.

During Monday's editorial meeting -- in which Clinton was seeking the
Daily News' endorsement ahead of Pennsylvania's April 22 primary -- she
was asked about the apparent discrepancy. The newspaper reported her
response:

"Now let me tell you what I can remember, OK --
because what I was told was that we had to land a certain way and move
quickly because of the threat of sniper fire. So I misspoke -- I didn't
say that in my book or other times but if I said something that made it
seem as though there was actual fire -- that's not what I was told,"
she told the newspaper.

"I was told we had to land a certain
way, we had to have our bulletproof stuff on because of the threat of
sniper fire. I was also told that the greeting ceremony had been moved
away from the tarmac but that there was this 8-year-old girl and, I
can't, I can't rush by her, I've got to at least greet her -- so I
greeted her, I took her stuff and then I left. Now that's my memory of
it."

Her daughter was asked about Tuzla in Indiana and backed up Clinton's recollection.

"I support what she said," Chelsea Clinton said. "Yes, I was there as
well and so honored I was there and had the opportunity to travel with
her."

Clinton was asked about it too -- by the editorial boards of the two Philadelphia newspapers Tuesday.

Clinton revised her Bosnia story, admitting there was a
"misstatement" in her account describing running with her head down to
get into the vehicles. Today, she said that she "had to meet this
8-year-old girl," so, "I took her stuff and left."

 

This is going to be devastating to the Clinton campaign. Many reports are surfacing regarding a story Hillary Clinton has been often quoted as telling, regarding a trip to Bosnia in 1996.

You can check the video on the right. In it, Clinton tells of landing under sniper fire, having no greeting and 'running to our cars with our heads down'.

Unfortunately, the video quite clearly shows a large welcome, with press and the president of Bosnia. There's even an 8 year old girl!

This girl is also on the official itinerary that was released of Hillary's time as first lady, and is the only airstrip that could land that particular type of plane.

Someone's been doing their homework, and has found some pretty interesting bits of info here:[q
url="http://wwwwakeupamericans-spree.blogspot.com/2008/03/hillary-clinton-busted-on-bosnia-and.html"]The Video you are about to watch is different though... Hillary claims, publicly that a trip to Bosnia in 1996, was so rife with danger that they had to land "under sniper fire" and "no greeting ceremony", she also says, they "ran with our heads down and was basically told to run to our cars".[/q][q
url="http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/3/22/161812/428/776/482309?"]You see, Senator Clinton has made much of her time as First Lady, suggesting that her experience in the White House gives her a foreign policy edge. No matter that her argument makes as much sense, as one Kossack put it, as Yoko Ono claiming she was a Beatle, Clinton has stuck to this argument and for some people, it seems to have worked.

This week, however, Senator Clinton put a pistol to the head of her own
campaign and put it out of its mathematical misery. Matthew Yglesias quotes Hillary saying in a speech earlier this week:

"I certainly do remember that trip to Bosnia, and as Togo said, there was a saying around the White House that if a place was too small, too poor, or too dangerous, the president couldn't go, so send the First Lady. That’s where we went. I remember landing under sniper fire. There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base."

That sounds terrible. (If you'd like, you can read the original speech at Senator Clinton's campaign site)

But join me as we flashback 1996 and then return to this week.[/q]Meanwhile, Obama's party goes on the offensive, attacking Hillary's credibility relating not only to the sniper story, but her positions on NAFTA, her foreign policy resume and more.

Greg Craig, a State Department official in the Clinton administration who is now a top foreign policy adviser to Obama, said the records do not back up Clinton's assertions, including that she helped broker the Northern Ireland peace process and resolve ethnic conflict in the Balkans.
"Her claim to be the nominee is based on experience, and she argues that she is ready to be the commander-in-chief," said Craig, dubbing Clinton's trips abroad "largely ceremonial." "And yet, I think the evidence does not support her claims."
Obama's campaign also sent reporters a fact-checking analysis from the Washington Post yesterday that described as "simply not credible" Clinton's oft-told story about landing in Bosnia in March 1996 amid sniper fire. The paper posted on its website a photo of Clinton and her daughter, Chelsea, at a peaceful greeting ceremony at Tuzla military airport.
Here's Hillary's text from her side of the story.
I remember landing under sniper fire. There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base. But it was a moment of great pride for me to visit our troops, not only in our main base as Tuzla, but also at two outposts where they were serving in so many capacities to deactivate and remove landmines, to hunt and seek out those who had not complied with the Dayton Accords and put down their arms, and to build relationships with the people that might lead to a peace for them and their children.
As first lady, Hillary Rodham Clinton traveled to Bosnia in March 1996 with her daughter and several celebrities to boost troop morale and thank soldiers stationed there.
Clinton cites the goodwill trip as a part of her foreign policy experience, describing a dangerous landing where she was ordered to the armored front of the plane because of possible ground fire. She also now reports landing under sniper fire and contradicts her previous written account of a shortened welcoming ceremony at the airport.
But according to accounts at the time, she was placed under no extraordinary risks on that trip. And one of her companions on it said he has no recollection either of the threat or reality of gunfire.
Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
James Pate
James Pate
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 05:54 on March 24th, 2008

Good Stuff Rob. I wonder if Senator Clinton has heard of "the internet" and "the youtube". Is she relying on those voters who don't use them?

Karen Hatter
Karen Hatter
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:59 on March 24th, 2008

Of course, Rob, this can't trump video.

Barry ORegan
Barry ORegan
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 10:04 on March 24th, 2008

Rob Walker, I like this story. It's good stuff. Well it can be hard to dispute Hillarys story, as I am sure there were snipers about, just nowhere near Hillary, as for ducking around Cars, well rumour has it Bill loves quickies with local ladies, and in a pinch the backseat of an automobile will do, so perhaps Hillary was checking the cars looking for Bill. I don't know I wasn't there, but certainly my explanation could be valid.

0
Vinny


WASHINGTON - Hillary Rodham Clinton's campaign said she "misspoke" last week when saying she had landed under sniper fire during a trip to Bosnia as first lady in March 1996.

0
Albert Milliron

She also Mispoke in 2001 when she said chelsea was in danger as she was out jogging near the twin towers... she was at home sleeping in bed


The story is the top two on NP as my story, Is Monica Lewinsky ready, is really about the Bosnia story and others

Jarrett Martineau
Jarrett Martineau
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:11 on March 25th, 2008

Priceless. And the sad and hilarious thing is that this is going to be the defining moment of Sinbad's already illustrious career. [q
url="http://blog.washingtonpost.com/sleuth/2008/03/sinbad_unloads_on_hillary_clin.html"]In
an interview with the Sleuth Monday, he said the "scariest" part of the
trip was wondering where he'd eat next. "I think the only 'red-phone'
moment was: 'Do we eat here or at the next place.'"

Clinton, during a late December campaign appearance in Iowa, described a hair-raising corkscrew landing
in war-torn Bosnia, a trip she took with her then-teenage daughter,
Chelsea. "They said there might be sniper fire," Clinton said.

Threat of bullets? Sinbad doesn't remember that, either.

"I never felt that I was in a dangerous position. I never felt being
in a sense of peril, or 'Oh, God, I hope I'm going to be OK when I get
out of this helicopter or when I get out of his tank.'"

In her Iowa stump speech, Clinton also said, "We used to say in the
White House that if a place is too dangerous, too small or too poor,
send the First Lady."

Say what? As Sinbad put it: "What kind of president would say, 'Hey,
man, I can't go 'cause I might get shot so I'm going to send my
wife...oh, and take a guitar player and a comedian with you.'"

[/q]

0
mtippett

You beat me to it!  Who would have thought the election would come down to him?

0
PEP

Frankly, the fatigue and jet lag of not only globe-trotting but
thousands of trips is more believable as a cause of mistakes than is
sitting in a hate-spewing , racist minister's church for 20 years and
calling it "not agreeing." Obama still will not be able to dig his way
out of the Jeremiah Wright mess, no matter what gambit they try.

0
BigT

Hillary "misremembers" one trip out of thousands. Obama "doesn't recall" two decades of racist/hate America sermons.

Is there really any comparison?

Barbara McPherson
Barbara McPherson
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:57 on March 25th, 2008

Rob Walker, I like this story. It's good stuff.  What's the most rare creature in the world?  an honest politician.  Makes you wonder who elects them.

0
Albert Milliron

How do you know a politician is lying?  You can see the lips moving

Albert Milliron
Albert Milliron
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:02 on March 25th, 2008

Rob Walker, I forgot the tag, great work

Swan
Swan
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 11:13 on March 25th, 2008

Hello Rob,

Great story - I knew there were reasons not to trust her, but an out and out lie like this?   She must be insane to think that so many people wouldn't remember what really happened in Bosnia!

Either that, or she really does live in some fantasy world to have us believe that the President would put her in such danger, only to avoid it himself.

President Obama is sounding better and better with each passing day!
         ~ Swan

 

0
René

Ah, it's the "Swift-Boat Sydrome"! and you all have joined in. I thought you were journalists.

0
Rob Walker

'Swift Boating' was a number of supposed former members of John Kerry's Vietnam troop. Problem is, half of them had never served with Kerry and many made up flat out lies against him.

The difference here is that Hillary stated, numerous times, that she flew in under sniper fire and rushed to a car. The video clearly shows her walking around without a care in the world, meeting an 8 year old, a group of 7th graders and sticking around to meet US troops. 

Not really the same thing at all. 

Swift boating would be more like if a bunch of Hillary's advisors and friends during her husband's presidency years came forward and started saying all these things about her. And even then it's a pale analogy.

Also I don't see how reporting a major news event doesn't make us journalists all of a sudden.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from