I Want to Believe: Licensing Religion in South Carolina

by denseatoms | December 12, 2008 at 10:55 am
345 views | 32 Recommendations | 11 comments

Photos

"In God We Trust" Sc Tag-Photo-01

"In God We Trust" Sc Tag-Photo-01

see larger image

uploaded by denseatoms

And it came to pass that in the State of South Carolina House of Representatives and Governor Mark Sanford intended to issue license plates picturing a gold cross and a stained glass window. The words "I Believe" were to span the top of the plate.


 


That was before December 11, when U.S. District Judge Cameron McGowan Currie ruled that the plates amount to state-sponsored religious preference. Currie ordered ordered the state to "take all actions necessary to preserve the status quo."


Religious leaders -- including Christians, Jews, Hindus and Arabs -- had sought the temporary injuction, which is subject to appeal. Currie said, however, that the case is likely to succeed in court as an example of the public's First Amendment rights barring governments from establishing a religion. The judge added that the "I Believe" license plates do not have a secular purpose, failed the test of neither advancing or inhibiting religion and failed to prevent excessive government entanglement with religion.



Henry McMaster, the state's attorney general, objected to the ruling, stating that the "I Believe" tag is "completely consitutional." He recommended an immediate appeal by the South Carolina Department of Motor Vehicles. Named as defendants in the injunction are DMV director Marcia Adams and state prisons director Jon Ozmint (whose department was slated to make the plates."



In order for a special license plate to be produced, a minimum of 400 people must place orders or the Department of Motor Vehicles must collect no less than $4000.



Lieutenant Governor Andre Bauer has posted the "I Believe" tag on his official Web site as representative of the state's values.and touts the plates because he said they reflect South Carolina's values.



At least 400 motorists must pre-order such special license plates or the DMV must collect $4,000 in order for the plates to be produced. [1]



Cars with "In God We Trust" license plates are already common on South Carolina highways. These display the American flag above the South Carolina banner.



• SOURCE:



[1] Burris, Roddie. "Judge orders S.C. to end production of religious-themed license plates." The Beaufort (SC) Gazette, December 11, 2008 http://www.beaufortgazette.com/lifestyle/wire/story/646094.html. Accessed on December 12, 2008.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
politisite

Thanks for a well thought out story.  My thing here is that our Founding Fathers view on establishing Religion is no where close to what is perpetrated in the USA today.  One only needs to read Story 1811 who explains the rational for the first Amendment.  He states that the real issue was that one religion should not get advantage over another.  Nor should it create a state religion.  It further stated in his work that Christianity was to be encouraged as it helped in civil discourse among its inhabitants.  I suppose today since many faiths are represented they should be encouraged as well as Faithful folks seem to obey laws and have deep concern for ones fellow man.  

In an upcoming article on the 1st Amendment I will attempt to compel my readers that the 1st Amendment is really a 4th check on our Government.  Why would several issues be placed in one article?  Religion- Check on morality in American legislation.  The problem here is that Then Senator Johnson slip in an Amendment prior to a vote that disallowed folks speak against a candidate from the pulpit.   The issue is that the Freedom of Speech falls within the same amendment.  Another check on the Government, The downfall of the Immigration Reform is an example of free speech working to stop legislation the country disagrees with.  The freedom of the press is a continuance of a check on the Government.  So is peacefully assembly and petitioning the government.  My contention is that our religious freedom and the Government not establishing a state religion is that this freedom is transcends anything that Johnson slipped into legislation at the last minute.  So the framers had a specific desired outcome adding these several freedoms together.  One should consider this when trying to limit faith in America.

Story further related that the amendment was not added to be completely indifferent to any religion either. 

So, if I chose to pay the 30 bucks extra for a license plate like other do to save the wales, or wildlife, or education, I should have the right as the first amendment states, Free exercise thereof.  The words, "Separation of Church and State" is not found in the Constitution.  It was a statement made by Jefferson that does not relate, with proper reading,  that The State should have nothing to do with religion but that there should be no religious test for office as stated in the constitution.  How folks have arrived at the Establishment Clause to mean freedom from religion is just not found anywhere in the Founding Fathers statements nor those, Like Story, who served in the congress probably knew the Framers and could accurately reflect the thoughts of the day. 

Thanks

Glad to see you writing here once again.


1
Barbara Mathieson

I had a wonderful wildlife Tennessee plate with a bluebird for a while. I stopped using vanity license tags when political issues (that aren't political issues like abortion) became popularized on license plates. I find them offensive. Some dudes in Tennessee are still driving around with a 1998 University of Tennessee National Championship plate. Get over it. It was ten years ago.

Plus I assume that a cop who doesn't agree with my view may be more likely to stop me if a commit a traffic violation.

Give me random numbers and letters on my plate.

1
dunkelberg

In cases such as these it is not so much the desire to testify using state resources as much as it is the fulfillment of cramming down others' throats.

1
dunkelberg

So, there could be a "Gay Pride" South Carolina bumper sticker?

I mean in the real world.


1
Jordan Yerman

This is a great article, with a great comment thread.

0
dunkelberg

If the pious win their appeal, will there be plates for all religions available? 

After we get into the state sanctioning a religion, we then have to shake down exactly which denomination of that religion.  As many denominations, sects and cults say they are the only way, it should prove to be interesting.

To me, it is a slippery slope that self-serving, pandering politicians are far too eager to embrace.


0
AAAAAAAAAAAA

yup...they put "In God We Trust" on the cheapest license plates in Indiana...there was controversy.

I like animals on my license plate.

0
politisite

They would be available for those who raise the initial monies and have the same number of orders as for the "I beleive" tag..  Like the writer stated we have an "in God we Trust."  Tag.  It is nothing more than a bumper sticker embedded in ones license plate.  The money goes to foundations for good just as for wildlife, education etc.  No one is required to put on a tag so there is no establishing of a religion.  Like I mentioned in my little comment that the slope has been in a downward trend since 1958.  The establishment clause does not mean what it did when the framers constructed the Amendment.  I notice that when one argues the subject they don't use writers who were contemporary to the constitutions inception as the first Amendment is very clear and has nothing to do with freedom from religion withun governement.  It is more about an amendment that came following the Civil war, The equal protection under the law.

0
politisite

Well the fee should be the same across the board. 

0
politisite

I think that would be more difficult here as SC is VERY conservative.. But it should have an equal chance in a perfect world.

0
politisite

Tagging one what you said (oh the Puns)  One needs to be careful what they put on their cars as it has been known to happen that a traffic stop to an Obama or McCain supporter has occurred due to a bumper sticker. 

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

politisite
First Flagged at 12:54 PM, Dec 12, 2008 by politisite
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (32)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from