Iran set to execute three young men convicted of homosexuality

by Rhonda J Mangus | November 10, 2009 at 02:18 am
1002 views | 79 Recommendations | 24 comments

Photos

Iran set to execute three young men convicted of homosexuality | Photo 03

Iran set to execute three young men convicted of homosexuality | Photo 03

see larger image

uploaded by Rhonda J Mangus

"Killing people for what they did as children is wrong and repellent, and killing them for alleged homosexual conduct is just as wrong and repellent. The Iranian government has flouted its most basic human rights obligations in allowing these cruel death sentences." Sarah Leah Whitson, HRW

Iran is set to execute three young men convicted of homosexuality. Convicted as juveniles, Nemat Safavi, Mehdi P and Moshen G have been on death row for three years for allegedly committing the 'crime of homosexuality'.


The imprisonment and pending executions of the three men has outraged people all across the globe, particularly in the United Kingdom.  Commenters have pointed the finger at Tony Blair (whose name is in the hat for President of the EU)  for not doing more to stop the executions.

 

"Vile murdering theocracy," said one commenter.  "Where are the 'moderate pluralist British Muslims' who should be loudly condemning this?  Too busy moaning about "Islamaphobia".  Human Rights and true injustices done in their name are of no consequence to them. Religion, all religions ultimately (and unfortunately), are in the business of undermining human rights to allow them supremacy over the masses, they don't really care that something like this can happen."

Another commenter said, "Sadly, we are dealing with a medieval mentality. Again showing that religion has no compassion. It is an evil regime masquerading as God.  Five hundred years ago we burned people at the stake. I hope it doesn't take as long for Iran to mature and come to its senses. The thought of executing a human being of any age for being gay fills me with horror and disgust."

The last time Iran executed a young man for homosexuality was October 6, 2009.  According to Joe.My.God, Rahi Rahammadi was put to death, even though his attorney said there was inadequate evidence to prove the allegations against him.  However, the court decided that once a person is convicted of a homosexual act, he must be executed.


Under Iranian law, homosexuality (lavat) is "punishable by death so long as both the active and passive partners are mature, of sound mind, and have acted of free will".

According to Human Rights Watch, Iran has the highest rate of juvenile offender executions of any other country in the world. International Law forbids the execution of juvenile offenders under any circumstances.

Iranian Railroad for Queer Refugees
(IRQR), headquartered in Toronto, calls on all human rights organizations to take up this cause.


However, IRQR has been criticized because European cities are reluctant to grant asylum-seekers' applications, because they believe (erroneously) that the men seeking asylum are not in life-threatening situations.

Mehdi P and Moshen G denied the charges against them and no witnesses were found. Safavi was arrested at the age of 16 in 2006 and tried by a court in Ardebil, where he is being held.

Read the entire story Iran set to execute three young men convicted of homosexuality as juveniles at examiner.com.

Read related stories on NowPublic, here.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
4
Uwe Paschen

This is terrible news and the pictures speak volumes.

0
Rhonda J Mangus

Yes and yes, Paschen. Thank you for reading, commenting, and for the recommendation!


2
smkovalinsky

Yes,  those pictures are horrible and chilling.  It makes one realize just how far the human race has come,  with democracy.  Iran is living as though in the medieval times.  It is chilling,  dreadful.

1
Rhonda J Mangus

"It makes one realize just how far the human race has come, with democracy."

Democracy is both illusion and betrayal, smk. However, if one chooses to believe in it:

Iran Had A Democracy Before We Took It Away.



1
Hugh Askew

"Mehdi P and Moshen G denied the charges against them and no witnesses were found."

Have to be beyond arrogant, beyond heartless, to convict, let alone execute anyone, for any crime, without proof, without witnesses.

The law thus becomes a tool for injustice, a means to settle scores, and a blot on humanity.

Even for the religion of peace, this is an abominable corruption of justice.

0
Rhonda J Mangus

Very well said, Hugh. Thank you!



1
Roy C

And where is the outrage in the gay community, not just the Muslim community around the world?



2
Rhonda J Mangus

"And where is the outrage in the gay community, not just the Muslim community around the world?"

Where is the outrage by the US government can be equally questioned. Let us also not forget Uganda's gays. In the following link, 3 American democrats and 1 republican have written to Secretary of State Clinton "warning that it [Uganda's anti-homosexual legislation] had severe implications for the freedom and safety of gay people.

UK government 'concerned about Uganda's anti-gay law.


0
YankeeJim

Iran government is a brutal regime. As long as the population accepts this, the government and people are inseparable, just as the Nazis and the Germans of WWII.

1
Rhonda J Mangus

Thank you for reading, commenting, and for the recommendation, YankeeJim!


2
Spydermonkey

Roy, I am sure that many of us are outraged by this. 

The use of a crane for execution is designed to make the whole thing a spectacle for the masses (inside & outside Iran).  It allows for the greatest audience possible.  It reminds me of the Roman executions in that regard..:(

I looked around for more information on the pic of the hanging from the crane but didn't find it...Rhonda, maybe you can help me there?


2
Rhonda J Mangus

Spydermonkey, I do not have any information for photo credits. A Google search of "Iran executes homosexuals" will show this and other graphic photos with stories attached. The hoisting of these men into the air with cranes is clearly a brutal and very public method of killing. Yes, it allows for the greatest audience possible -- to instill fear, no doubt.

Also important, Iran is violating International Law, having signed the treaty.

I hope I was of help. Thanks so much for reading, commenting, and for the recommendation.




2
jazzyzazzy

That is just barbaric.

0
P.A.H.

While the execution of children and young adults i find savage and brutal, i do agree with the fact that homosexuals should be put to death.. I do not want my children to grow up in a world where the chance that they themselves turn to homosexuality lurk around each and every corner or on every television show. If your okay with your kids possibly becoming gay because of how media portrays all this hoopla then i don' think you truly love them. And now with the new hate law passed, you can bet your ass more people are going to turn to homosexuality because they can exploit that law in their favor, just as every other group mentioned can!

2
Rhonda J Mangus

P.A.H, thank you for reading and commenting. However, I would suggest that you educate yourself to homosexuality, and make no assumptions about the love of a parent for their child -- gay or straight.



0
YankeeJim

That is surely a polite response. I cannot be so polite.

0
YankeeJim

You are my mortal enemy.

1
Rhonda J Mangus

?

2
generaldecay

The fact that 'juveniles' and 'death row' are in the same sentence is frightening enough all by itself, never mind anything else.

0
t k kidwai

Homosexuality is as old as human civilisation,even in its primordial stage.West has accepted it and legalised it,East is least willing to accept it.Any debate on such issues is meaningless in the sense that as in all debates one doesn't shift his/her stated position.Only audience can be influenced by this argument or that argument.

Secondly,even if we admitt for the sake of argument that homosexuality is a sin,a crime,unnatural act,a social problem which can destroy family values and so on.But what can we do if in some persons of either sex it is innate,their sexual preferences are pre-determined and they find it almost impossible to do away with it.

No one would like his children growing up in an environment which is not congruous to the moral values they uphold.I am not in favour of homosexuality,may not like my children to indulge in homosexuality;but despite that I am vehemently against any form of punishment,even flogging,to homosexuals.In my opinion no one should be punished for his sexual preferences.As I said it is innate,we don't hang mentally challenged persons.Why?If in the opinion of Iranian authorities that homosexuality is a crime which can be deterred by awarding death penalty,I strongly differ.

2
Barbara McPherson

Iran is teaching us how a civilized country can quickly descend into a morass of barbarity.

1
YankeeJim

I do not believe for a moment that this is a civilized country.

1
QueensHart

I am so sorry for the families and these young men.  What can we do about it at all today?  It is a shame we cannot send snipers in there and shoot the jackasses before they can do it. 

 

1
blvdman

0 false 18 pt 18 pt 0 0 false false false /* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table Normal"; mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0; mso-tstyle-colband-size:0; mso-style-noshow:yes; mso-style-parent:""; mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt; mso-para-margin-top:0in; mso-para-margin-right:0in; mso-para-margin-bottom:10.0pt; mso-para-margin-left:0in; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:12.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-ascii-font-family:Cambria; mso-ascii-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-fareast-theme-font:minor-fareast; mso-hansi-font-family:Cambria; mso-hansi-theme-font:minor-latin;}

As an ancient culture like Greek and Rome

Having sex with another male or close to it is common in Iran due to separation of men and women

Show of affection like kissing and hugging is common between same sex

For a person to be charged with a charge a complained must be formed

Unfortunately child molestation (having sex with young boys)

 and homosexuality  is translated to English as same

If a child’s parents form a complain against a young man for having a indecent act with their boy that man is charged with homosexuality when is translated to English

Stiff laws are in place to discourage exploration of young  children

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

jjenet
First Flagged at 3:06 AM, Nov 10, 2009 by jjenet
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (79)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from