NP Rank:
The Islamic Third Solution
Islam is the fastest growing religious movement on the planet today. In spite of the fact that the Muslim nation gets so much bad press, is often directly linked with the word "terrorist" in the headlines, has no international hierarchy, and is the youngest of the world's major religions, what is the attraction that this movement is offering its' converts?
Monotheism blossomed out of the harsh desert environment between western Asia and the Middle East almost 4,000 years ago. Something about this idea of only one God rang as true in the hearts of the inhabitants and Abraham, of the Old Testament, is credited with being the first human to commit his beliefs in this way. Down through the ages this idea caught on with the general public and became a concept that much of the world embraces and adheres to today. Of all the other options, this idea of only one God, made more sense to a wider assortment of peoples than the idols formed by men. Not everyone made this transition at once or in the same manner. Words, ideas, inventions, and people travelled at a much slower rate in those days than they do now; but, travel they did, these ideas followed the trade routes and were welcomed as a sign of hope in these arid lands. Even now, when we are confronted with new ideas and concepts, it spurs great debates both oral and written, and eventually some sort of consensus or public awareness is born.
Nearly 300 years after the mission of Jesus, in the year 325 of the Common Era, a council was convened by the Emperor Constantine the First that would once and for all decide which of all these writings and oral traditions would be deemed acceptable to the new Christian movement. It was the Council of Nicaea that chose what the Christian Bible would become. The Jewish writings, unchangeable by Constantine's councils, were much older and were included as the Old Testament and the common history of Jews and Christians was forever bound under the one living God of Abraham, Moses, and Isaiah. This new Book also made it's way along the trade routes of the Middle East, Asia, North Africa, and the Arab Peninsula.
The city of Mecca was the largest at the time on the Arabian Peninsula and was a crossroads of trade and commerce for Jews, Christians, Arabs, and Africans. It was here, about 300 years after Nicaea, that the Prophet Mohammed began his mission to bring the estranged descendants of Abraham back to the one living God. It was from Abraham's sons, Ishmael and Isaac, that the great peoples of Arabia and Judea came. As if a long lost rememberance was re-kindled in the minds and hearts of the Arabian nation they followed Muhammed back to the God of their ancestors and joined their brothers and sisters in believing in the one true God of Abraham. Allah, Yahweh, and God are the different names of the same Supreme Being. The similarities between Christians, Muslims, and Jews far outweigh the differences and in time it will be these similarities that will allow us to co-exist in tolerance, compassion and peace.
In the world today diplomacy between different nations and peoples allow us a relatively comfortable existence in the West. We need to overcome our differences and embrace our sameness with everyone, this can be a successful achievement even though our track record isn't stellar. All nations and peoples are guilty of abandoning the Faith and committing atrocities. If you think you can find justification for your actions in the Scriptures, Proverbs, or Surahs of your written tradition then think again. Instead, check your interpretations with the Ten Commandments of The Book, if there is a contradiction with your version and the Word of God, can you guess who is wrong?
The threat from Islam does not come from it's religious beliefs it comes from it's economic ones and it is aimed at the rich and powerful. The socio-economic philosophy of Islam is to redistribute natural resources among all who need it with no regard for private profit, a banking system with no interest payments, and an idea that all basic human needs be cared for. It is a system that blends the positive aspects of capitalism with a type of communism that includes incentives for the ambitious. Is it any wonder that this Third Solution is gaining converts faster than any other?
News Tools
July 16, 2008 at 03:39 am by Caoimhin1, 606 views, 34 comments




Add a comment
Comments (34)
at 05:32 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff.
Jewdaism, Christianity, Islam is the third evolutions out of Jewish God! Maybe a fourth will emerge still!
at 05:36 on July 16th, 2008
Thanks Pashen for the flag! These three philosophies have much in common in their histories! Cheers!
at 06:05 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff. Now that is what I call great stuff
at 06:10 on July 16th, 2008
Thank you very much Barry!
at 20:53 on July 16th, 2008
Certainly what Moon says is true, radical islam is not predominate, there are way more moderates than whackjobs. We have moderate christan religions as well, and we have our whackjobs too.
at 08:02 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, very good stuff. I think that with the Taliban and the current extremist version of the Muslim religion--the one that seems to be dominant today--the problem now has moved beyond the original religion.
Funny thing about all this--I never understood the Crusade before. Now I do.
at 09:20 on July 16th, 2008
Actually extremist Islam is not dominant today. That most Muslims are extremists is a pat fallacy that people who don't know any better accept as the truth because they were sold a bill of goods. Of the world's billion and a half Muslims those that fit your description of extremists probably measure in the tens of thousands. Most are just like you, ordinary people trying to raise families, buy homes, work a meaningful job and just get along with their lives living within the peaceful constraints of their religion.
The problem is the news we get is only about the extremists. Average lives of average people are not considered newsworthy by a violence hungry mainstream press, and governments need to demonize whole groups of people to carry out their nefarious geopolitical plans, with that same supine corporate press in collusion with them.
Do you think their are no extremist Christians? Those in the USA who work diligently to foment war and worse to speed the arrival of the rapture, or blow up buildings and kill people in the USA? Do we hear about the hundreds of millions who carry on quietly living by the tenets of Christianity?
Look past the facade of your fear and you will find that what most Muslims want are the same things you do, and would hurt no one.
Painting them all with the same brush is exactly what those who direct your life want you to do, and many do not seem to have the capacity to see through this simplistic ruse.
I would also point out that this brief item most certainly does not explain the complexity of the Crusades or the era in which they occurred. To say you now understand that complexity only demonstrates a lack of knowledge on the subject. There are many historians world wide who have spent their entire academic careers digging for the facts of the Crusades who still cannot explain the times or the causes and effects.
at 10:51 on July 16th, 2008
Sorry, I'm not operating from fear. That's a nice cliche comeback, but it isn't true. Nor are many people who choose to view things differently from you operating from fear. As far as how dialogue and articles here affect those of us engaged in respectful dialogue and our own explorations and readings--that's personal. Maybe to you I have a lack of knowledge. Maybe you didn't get what I was saying, but no matter. Maybe you have a Ph.D. in history of that era, and are an expert, and if so, then write about it and teach the rest of us.
Moonwolf, people can know that "ordinary people" are all alike, and still be able to name our enemies. You've never gotten that as a Native American, I have far more personal experiences dealing with racism (and as a woman, sexism), and also the complexities of juggling stereotypes, religious differences, and all the things that come with being multi-cultural than does frankly, a white male in Canada. That's not an insult, that's just a fact.
One day I sat down with a visiting Native American guy, full-blood, an artist and writer. Great guy. Reservation-raised. I wasn't reservation-raised. We wound up talking about how each of us, starting from different positions, wound up in the same place--building bridges between cultures. We share that bridge and very comfortably. And we know a lot, from tribal, cultural, and personal experiences, about building bridges.
Remember, a basic religious and cultural belief for most Native American tribes is "we are all related." But even knowing that, we know that the human family, like all families, has those who are evil, mean, and who choose to become enemies. And we don't mind naming them and discussing it. It's a part of survival.
Did you ever stop to consider that in your vehement hatred of the U.S., and your attacks on the U.S., its peoples, and other members here that maybe you're expressing your fear? If your hypothesis about others is true, then it's true for you, too.
at 08:14 on July 16th, 2008
Thank you PEP! I think the extremists seem dominant only because they are getting all the headlines...
at 10:38 on July 16th, 2008
And the Crusades were fired by the communications and pot-stirring of the time. Different media, but same things happening. At least now we have more sources of information than back then. ;}
at 08:52 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff.
at 08:57 on July 16th, 2008
Thanks a lot Moonwolf!
at 09:18 on July 16th, 2008
Sorry, Cao, I suggest everybody do their own research on this subject. Just google ISLAM, or 'Religion of Peace'. See what it is really all about. Don't neglect the sites directly from Islamists. and: "Evaluate the sources, evaluate the sources, evaluate the sources."
at 09:31 on July 16th, 2008
Why are you sorry Rene??
at 10:00 on July 16th, 2008
Sorry you bought into it. and sorry I may seem to be dissing you. Too many buy into it, Cao. Do the research and you will see. It is not easy and takes time.
at 10:14 on July 16th, 2008
I did do the research Rene and wrote an article. Is it the content you dissaprove of, or the way the piece was written, or the fact that it poses reaching a peaceful solution as your reason not to give the article a GS flag?
at 10:37 on July 16th, 2008
Don't believe you did enough research to reach the conclusions you did, so, no, I do not think it is a good story. So, sorry about that. You do do a lot of good reporting.
at 11:03 on July 16th, 2008
Rene, I wrote an article (with background material) to explore one reason why Islam is the fastest growing religion today. The only conclusion that I implied was that it appeals to the downtrodden. The research is valid.
Thanks for your opinions! :)
at 09:55 on July 16th, 2008
Right on René!
at 10:05 on July 16th, 2008
Oh, moonie! not what you think at all.
at 10:11 on July 16th, 2008
No, I mean about the research. What conclusions one draws is up to them. (:D)
at 10:53 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff.
at 11:04 on July 16th, 2008
Thanks very much Karen! :)
at 11:39 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff.
An interesting look at the history of Islam - I learned some things here - thanks!
at 11:46 on July 16th, 2008
Thank you very much Amy!
at 11:50 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff.
at 12:01 on July 16th, 2008
Thanks for the GS flag jaydeepmensa! :)
at 12:35 on July 16th, 2008
Caoimhin1, I like this story. It's good stuff. You were saying that the differences are what separate us and naturally they would. There are some huge differences between Islam, Muslim and Christianity. This site has some of them on a chart. http://muslim-canada.org/islam_christianity.html But thanks for sharing the word of God. It takes guts to do that!
at 12:45 on July 16th, 2008
Thank you MsMcReality! There are huge differences between these religions. There are also huge differences among the peoples within each individual religion too. I hope it doesn't mean that we all can't get along! :)
Thank you for the link!
at 14:52 on July 16th, 2008
Great post.