Jailed for 10 years, Muslim pilot, Co-pilot, who paused to pray

by Roy C | March 24, 2009 at 08:00 pm
1310 views | 62 Recommendations | 16 comments

Videos

Tuninter Ditching Black Box

see larger video

sourced by Roy C

Tuninter Ditching Black Box

This story came out of the UK today. Italian courts sentenced the pilot and co-pilot to ten years in jail on what we in the Anglo-American jurisprudence system would call negligent homicide. Several other employees of TunisAir were also convicted. I will be adding  reports on this one in Italian newspapers and update the report.

This entire outcome is unprecedented.

No pilot and co-pilot have ever been found negligent in the deaths of passengers because they had prayed instead of following established emergency procedures.

The plane had been furnished with a fuel gauge, the wrong model and a contraband version of the wrong model, designed for a smaller plane. The end result was that there was not enough fuel on the plane. The motors went out, first one, then the other, in mid-flight.

Even the black box was contraband and not original approved equipment, according to a report in La Repubblica.

According to the Corriere della Sera, the pilot said (translation), " I am a hero. I wanted to save everyone, but I failed.

'If I had gone done hard on the runway or near the airport at Punta Raisi, as I had intended to do, I would have risked not only the life of the passengers and crew, but also the lives of the people on the ground.

'The plane would have exploded. Who knows where? This is why I chose to land in the sea."

More news to come on the YouTube video claiming that the black box had been jettisoned.

Jailed for 10 years, the Muslim pilot who paused to pray before taking emergency action in plane crash that killed 16

A Muslim pilot and co-pilot who paused to pray before taking emergency measures as they ditched a passenger plane in the sea, killing 16 people, has been sentenced to 10 years in jail.

Pilot Chafik Gharby and co-pilot Ali Kebaier were convicted of taking inadequate emergency measures by an Italian court.

The 2005 crash at sea off Sicily left survivors swimming for their lives, some clinging to a piece of the fuselage that remained floating after the ATR turbo-prop aircraft splintered upon impac

There were 34 holidaymakers and five crew on board the plane when it went down.

A fuel-gauge malfunction was partly to blame, with technicians putting the wrong type of gauge on the plane before it took off.

It meant the pilot and crew believed they had more fuel than they actually did. The plane's engines cut out simultaneously when the fuel ran out.

However prosecutors also said the pilot succumbed to panic, praying out loud instead of following emergency procedures.

They claimed he then opted to crash-land the plane instead trying to reach a nearby airport.

'This was an unprecedented sentence but we have always maintained that it was an unprecedented incident,' observed Niky Persico, a lawyer for one of the victims.

'Never before in the history of aviation disasters has there been such a chain of events and counter events,' he added.

Another five employees of Tuninter, a subsidiary of Tunisair, were sentenced to between eight and nine years in jail by the court, in a verdict handed down yesterday.

The seven accused, who were not in court, will not spend time in jail until the appeals process has been exhausted.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Amy Judd

Wow, what a story; I think it's always important to follow procedure in an emergency situation, even though you might want to do otherwise.

2
Paschen

This may make some waves yet.

2
Roy C

I am trying to read the accounts in La Repubblica, one of the best Italian newspapers and one that allows you to read the archives.

So, far, I don't know the particulars. That video, though, I want to listen to. It has the whole thing.


1
Roy C

You have the wrong gauge, a contraband version of it, and how come when the plane was refueled that no one noticed that less fuel went in than usual?

Italian newspapers don't like paragraphing off the page. Difficult to read.


0
jazzyzazzy

The jail for praying ? When it is mechanical failure.A think i would pass out never mind pray.So the mechanics are getting slack. Perhaps the pilots should be called fall guys after all if someones to get the blame why not the pilots,another one down I said about the dutch plane crash there does seem to be a lot of crashes these days the air seems to be less safe than the roads. God love the passengers.

2
Iffy

That's why I never fly airlines with muslim pilots. It is worth re-capping their past exploits: the recent crash in Amsterdam of Turkish airlines, or the Egypt Air flight that went down because the pilot decided to scream 'allah akhbar' and do a jihad thing. Think about it: would you want Captain Sully, or Captain 'maybe the plane stays in the air en shallah' Muhammed?

0
car1edb

fair point, but how do you go about checking your pilots religion these days? - is it on the booking form?

But still, as a pilot you're in command of lives of people, who come before your own "the captain always goes down with the ship" and all that/you do anything to result in the best outcome.

0
John Jeter

dude ur very racist


ok if u were the pilot in that plane im sure you would have prayed too at the end


oh yea and the pilots was trying to save everybody not kill them


 and it doesnt matter what type of person is in the cockpit seat of your plane



0
chanaka

Wow really a good story.

1
Barry Artiste

Guess these guys cant pray and fly a plane at the same time?  What is it, like prayers 5 times a day?  Perhaps they should have chosen another profession, like ground work!

0
harringtola

Astounding story and verdict. Thanks Roy.

1
The Truth

Redicilously written and redicilously sentenced. First of all they did not disrupt the emergency procedures to pray, as you can hear from the recordings. They only made some shorter prayers simultaneously. And you idiots that compare the Captain Sully ditch to this one are redicilous as well. The Hudson River has no waves, which makes it much easier, compared to the Mediterranean Sea where the waves were about 2 meters high at the time of the crash. Don't get me wrong, Captain Sully is a hero, but these guys are too! Actually after the crash the Tunisian pilots were honoured for their actions. Please stop being so foolish whenever you here something about muslims.

2
lady aya

this is really rediculeous!!

 it is absurd to read that pilots sentenced because they were praying instaed of making emergencies!! how can you belive that!! you readers are very stupid...whenever you hear sth about islam and moslems you start to beleive everything and never try to look for the truth..

first of all the pilots were not praying ..this is not true ...what they did was the right thing..they tried to save the plane from crush intil the last minutes of their lives..and when they got hopless and at the exact time of  the crush they were calling god saying " besmellah besmellah"
 which means "under the name of god" ..it is like when u say .".godness godness."..do you think those 2 words prevented the pilots from saving the plane?!!! this is absurd and very very stupid!!  this is unfair!! the pilots were heros ..and they should be honored !

stop beliving in bull shiit!!

0
Chadif

This is just another misleading story.

The word prayer coupled with Muslims will most certainly invoke images of men bowing down in prostration which would obviously be a very negligent thing to do in this situation but this is obviously not the case here. From the video clip above it's clear that the pilot was in command at all times and he only invoked supplications to GOD while still going through the emergency procedures, I mean it was very clear that he and his co-pilot were going through the "ditch" emergency procedure.

Muslims have traditional sayings and supplications that they do and say in lots of common situations such opening the house door, driving a car, after eating, before sleeping etc let alone in urgent or distressed situations. If the headline was “Western pilot paused to curse before taking emergency measures” I’m sure some of you will find it absurd.

This does not take away the fact that there was gross negligence on the part of the airline and its mechanics which unfortunately cost lives in this case and should definitely be persecuted but to blame this whole incident on the actions of the pilot which were grossly misinterpreted is non-sense. Maybe the media was just selling the sort of hype that some of the earlier commentators fell for.

0
RalphL

Roy, you are an idiot, you should check your facts before writing such a stupid article. You have none of the facts. Roy, if you are about to dive from 10,000 feet into the ocean, and you are facing certain death wouldn't you pray, whatever religion you have christian, jewish or boudhist for that matter. So stop this nonsense of always portraying muslims as nutcases always willing to die.  In fact these pilots are Tunisians, and how the hell did you know they are muslims anyway? 

0
Roy C

All of that was established at the trial, not from conjecture. I was only reporting what was reported.

They didn't go to prison because they prayed, but because of when they prayed, instead of attending to business.


This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Amy Judd
First Flagged at 8:16 PM, Mar 24, 2009 by Amy Judd
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (62)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from