Janet Napolitano, Homeland Security Chief: "The System Worked"

by Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke | December 28, 2009 at 04:33 am
552 views | 61 Recommendations | 15 comments

Former Arizona Governor, now Secretary of Homeland Security, Janet Napolitano, says the system worked.  Really?

Responding to the botched terrorism attempt on board Delta flight 253 from Amsterdam to Detroit Janet Napolitano replied yesterday that the system worked.  One has to ask how she could possibly make this statement in light of the fact, that the suspect Adulmutallab, 23 was known, had his VISA revoked by the UK and the family had notified the U.S.embassy in Nigeria?

The father of the suspect had first given his concerns to Nigerian Security Forces and then informed the U.S. embassy in Nigeria of his sons radical beliefs.

The son returned to Nigeria for one day to board a flight, obviously a weak link found to get past full security screening once in Amsterdam.  Once there, he boarded Delta flight 253 enroute to Detroit.

A syringe, intended to ignite the explosives, malfunctioned, avoiding a disaster on Christmas Day over the skies of Detroit.

What is the knee jerk reaction of Western governments?  Let's inconvenience the flying public with further restrictions, when it is obvious that the problem clearly lies with bureaucracy. 

Napolitano said that Homeland Security notified all the other agencies after the incident happened.

In a FOX News Interview this morning around 5:40 EST, Napolitano was asked the question if she ever personally reviewed the system in place. Her initial reaction, no surprise, was that the system was in place when she took over Homeland Security.  When pressed further she acknowledged that she had reviewed it.

Napolitano's reaction and statement after the incident should earn her a pink slip.  Will Obama replace her?

On Dec. 24, Nigerian officials say Abdulmutallab re-entered Nigeria for only one day to board a flight in Lagos, where he walked through airport security carrying only a shoulder bag, with explosives hidden on his body.

"We were hopeful that they would find and return him home," the family said. "It was while we were waiting for the outcome of their investigation that we arose to the shocking news of that day."

Abdulmutallab, 23, is being held in a federal prison in Michigan after suffering burns in the botched bombing. U.S. authorities have said he claimed to be carrying out an attack on orders from al-Qaida.

Advertisement
recommend This comment thread is now closed
2
Barry ORegan

Of course the system worked, just not for the US.

2
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Nine Hours to Munich without my blankee and pillow will really piss me off.  Damn and no bathroom break for an hour before landing.  This ole spunky cowpoke won't be too happy.

2
Susan Marie Kovalinsky

Ha,  I agree with Barry.   Yes,  it is alarming in the extreme that this man was on a terror list and had his own father giving warnings,  yet none of it prevented him being on this flight.  It is a good thing that his act failed,  or all would have been killed,  and that would have been a considerable act of terror against the US, on Christmas day. 

2
Susan Marie Kovalinsky

Here,  she back-pedals:

A day after saying the system worked, Napolitano backtracked, saying her words had been taken out of context.

"Our system did not work in this instance," she said on NBC's "Today" show. "No one is happy or satisfied with that. An extensive review is under way."

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20091228/ap_on_go_ot/us_airliner_attack

1
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

I saw her interview early this morning on FOX.  She said the system worked after the incident had occurred.  They were able to notify 128 overseas flights and all the other agencies. 

When pressed on the issue whether or not she had reviewed the policy since she was Homeland Security she first played the blame game and said she had inherited it.  After being pressed again she said she was aware of the policy.  On the third attempt when asked if she had personally reveiewed it, she kind of agreed she had but made no definite statement.

4
Jordan Yerman

The only thing that worked was that airline passengers no longer see being hijacked as safe. In fact, it made everyone a bit paranoid. That's the #1 reason why you don't see more incidents like this: facing a cabin-ful of pissed-off coach class passengers is not a high-percentage situation for a terrorist.


0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Jordan now that I think of it that way, you;re right.  258 pissed off passengers wouldn't be fun.  Just imagine the pissed off flight attendants. 

2
Barbara McPherson

These "security measures" seem designed to give the impression of safety to the public.  The homeland security of the U.S. has been a very expensive failure. It looks like what they are best at is blaming others for their short comings.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thanks for commenting Barbara, Janet Napolitano certainly demonstrated that this morning.  Her facial expressions during the FOX interview say it all.

1
snuffysmith

ForeignPolicy.com: "No, Madam Secretary: The System Is Not Working"

In the wake of the failed Al-Qaida terror plot targeting a Delta/Northwest airliner traveling from Amsterdam to Detroit, Evan Kohlmann published a new piece over at ForeignPolicy.com, titled "No, Madam Secretary: The System is Not Working."

As someone who generally considers himself a supporter of the Obama administration -- and who recognizes the exceptionally complex and at times intractable nature of the problems it faces -- I watched with a sense of deep dismay on Sunday as Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano attempted to defend the handling of would-be terrorist Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab. According to Napolitano, the fact that ordinary passengers stepped in and intervened to stop Abdulmutallab's failed effort to down a U.S. airliner is a positive sign that the "system is working smoothly." In fact, nothing could be farther from the truth -- and this fiasco is only further evidence of the ongoing mismanagement of U.S. national security. Although this breakdown began during the chaos of the last Bush administration, Obama and his advisors are now looking down the barrel at their own "Brownie" moment -- when Bush publicly praised Federal Emergency Management Agency Director Michael Brown for his response to the Hurricane Katrina disaster. The current administration does not seem to grasp that the solution lies in finally fixing the system, not more empty excuses or a further expansion of ineffective bureaucratic policies...

The whole article can be viewed at ForeignPolicy.com.

1
Quagmire

Geez, just looking at this woman makes ya think if her and Janet Reno ever trade Lesbian Horse Stories?

1
Barry ORegan

Highlarious!

1
snuffysmith

Al Qaeda's Clear Message - Wall Street Journal editorial. Apparently the fellows in al Qaeda took as a personal insult Secretary of Homeland Anxiety Janet Napolitano's comment Sunday that their role in the foiled Detroit airliner bombing wasn't clear but would be investigated. Yesterday, al Qaeda's ascendant franchise in the Arabian peninsula saved Secretary Napolitano the trouble of plowing through all the layers of the national-security bureaucracy for an answer. The terrorist organization put out a pointed statement not only claiming responsibility but also mocking the U.S.'s ability to stop them. Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, they said, "dealt a huge blow to the myth of American and global intelligence services and showed how fragile its structure is." What this means is that we have to think more broadly about jihad and the potential recruitment of terrorists anywhere in the world, including inside the United States.

1
snuffysmith

Screening for Terrorists - Los Angeles Times editorial. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano wisely has backed off her statement that "the system worked" because a Nigerian terrorist failed to blow up an airliner on Christmas Day. The system decidedly didn't work if an explosive could be brought aboard a plane by a man whose radicalization had been brought to the attention of the United States by his father, a prominent banker. But as Congress and the Obama administration undertake inquests into this near disaster, their primary focus should be on lapses in human intelligence, not technology. It was only thanks to chance or ineptness that Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab failed to quickly detonate a plastic explosive and destroy a Detroit-bound Northwest airliner and the 290 people it was carrying. Abdulmutallab, a recent resident of Britain who says he received training in Yemen, wasn't on a no-fly or watch list and was spared a pat-down search that could have revealed that he was carrying a weapon. Had his name been flagged, more attention might have been paid to the fact that he paid cash for his ticket and checked no baggage. Actually, Abdulmutallab's mission could have been aborted even earlier.

0
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke

Thanks very much for all your updates Snuffy, much appreciated.:)

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Uwe Paschen
First Flagged at 4:38 AM, Dec 28, 2009 by Uwe Paschen
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (61)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from