NP Rank:
Just one in 15 domestic violence cases results in a conviction
There has been a huge rise in domestic violence attacks - but prosecutors are only securing convictions in one in 15 cases, it has emerged.
There is, unfortunately, nothing terribly new about this statistic because the clear up rate for domestic violence has always been low (see also: rape cases).
For a reason not terribly difficult to figure out (given that this is the Daily Mail), the article puts the statistics on female acts of domestic violence first. Considering the differences between the numbers of female-on-male domestic violence and the numbers of male-on female domestic violence each year, the Daily Mail's agenda is yet again clear. *
The number of women convicted of domestic violence is up 268 per cent in five years, from 806 in 2004-5 to 2,968 in 2008-9. Convictions of men were up 144 per cent, from 18,659 to 45,484.
In any case, academics, policy makers, police forces, and criminal justice agencies have been talking for years about improving the clear up rates for domestic violence, but rates do not appear to have changed at all.
Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Chris Huhne said: 'It is nothing short of disgraceful that fewer than one in 15 reported incidents of domestic violence results in a conviction.
--
* No, I'm not denying that females also commit acts of domestic violence against males - of course they do - but I AM marvelling at the Daily Mail's consistent attempts to paint women in a poor light.
Recommendations (70)
-
a211423
Clearlake, California, United States -
Rhonda J Mangus
North Tonawanda, New York, United States -
Karen Hatter
All Locations, Everywhere, United States -
Amy Judd
Vancouver, Canada
-
dvmemorial
Bloomington, Indiana, United States -
jazzyzazzy
Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom -
Spydermonkey
huntsville, Alabama, United States -
Sputnic
London, United Kingdom -
Barbara McPherson
Nanaimo, Canada



Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (9)
at 11:43 on September 15th, 2009
Trust the Daily Mail - can't be surprised about that either I'm afraid
at 12:16 on September 15th, 2009
Amy, agreed. It would be a cause for much eye-rolling if they didn't have such a large audience for their bias.
Thanks for the recommendation and comment.
at 15:31 on September 15th, 2009
So, if domestic violence where the woman is the culprit is up more than where the man is the culprit, the newspaper owes it to women's "image" to present the men's violence first?
What?????????
at 16:49 on September 15th, 2009
Women are held to higher and different standards than men. People expect men to be violent; they are also carefully taught to deny or minimize male violence ("I don't believe any father would rape his own child") and to forgive violent men ("He's been under a lot of pressure"; "He's willing to go into therapy"). On the other hand, people continue to blame women for male violence ("She must have liked rough sex if she stayed married to him"; "She provoked him into beating her").
Also, people do not expect women to be violent, not even in self-defense. In fact, most people consistently confuse female self-defense with female aggression. In addition, people demand that women, but not men, walk a very narrow tightrope of acceptable behaviors. Most people are psychologically primed to distrust/dislike any woman who, in addition to failing to embody ideal behavior, dares to commit other morally questionable acts, such as having sex or parenting children outside of marriage. Few women are deemed perfect enough to be seen as credible, or to merit serious compassion even in the justice system.
These psychological double standards of perceived violence result in a double standard of punishment. Studies document that women are often punished more severely for lesser, primarily "female" crimes, such as prostitution, than men are for the more violent "male" crimes of femicide and homicide. When women commit "male" crimes such as spouse or stranger murder after being raped, and in self-defense, or when they protectively kidnap a child, they are usually punished more harshly than their male so-called counterparts.
Another example: as noted, battered women who kill in self-defense account for about half of all women who kill. Even here, men and women are not "equal." Non-battered men kill their female domestic partners three to four times more often than (battered) women kill their domestic partners/aggressors. Despite some "newsworthy" exceptions, battered women who kill in self-defense rarely are found not guilty and to date are rarely granted clemency; most are given long or even life sentences without parole.
There is a Canadian film about women who killed their husbands in self defense and who had histories of asking for help from law enforcement only to have their pleas ignored. I could not find it to post here, but I will continue look for it. I saw it in a sociology class in the 1990s.
at 17:08 on September 15th, 2009
I found the name of the film: When Women Kill; 1994; National Film Board of Canada
The author Ann Jones answers the question, What would make an ordinary woman kill her husband?
This documentary focuses on the experiences of three battered women who after years of violence kill their husbands in self defense.
It explores the reason for this action and how they were treated by the courts. Ms. Jones offers historical background, and challenges the legal system and the wide spread violence that men inflict daily on women.
at 17:12 on September 15th, 2009
Any thinking woman knows that her husband could kill her with his hands. Most women could not present the same danger. Women accept the risks and for most, it works out well and a sunny, happy relationship ensues, or at least a mutually respectful one. Women always walk a fine line in our society. They are either madonnas or whores in the psyche of many. We have achieved much in the way of equality in our N. American society, but we have a very long way to go before equality is achieved between the sexes.
at 17:19 on September 15th, 2009
Barbara
Well said.
I would only add that women should be treated equally by the courts and the justice department. The film I talked about above is a sad comment on how these women were persecuted as the criminals when in fact, they were the victims.
at 06:41 on September 16th, 2009
Domestic violence committed by anybody is wrong. Equality between the sexes should not mean we are all allowed to be as bad as each other. In many ways things seam to be going backwards, not forwards. Have drink and drug use gone up in line with these statistics ?
at 16:08 on September 20th, 2009
Pressures of life hit us all at some stage.How to handle them is the key to resolving them. Violence of any sort is deplorable. However, Many men and woman suffer violence and unacceptable behaviour,and resign themselfs to a life of misery.Till the kids grow up.