Listeria Hysteria "Worker says meat plant filthy": Maple Leaf Foods

by Barry ORegan | August 30, 2008 at 06:57 am
4252 views | 63 Recommendations | 42 comments

Photos

Listeria Hysteria "Worker says meat plant filthy": Maple Leaf Foods

Listeria Hysteria "Worker says meat plant filthy": Maple Leaf Foods

see larger image

uploaded by Barry ORegan

Opinion

Barry Artiste

Certainly this new allegation will not bode well considering the pending lawsuits against Maple Leaf Foods from Victims of Listeria which has been linked to the 15 deaths of consumers and counting.

Listeria can take months to show symptoms to show up after eating the contaminated food, making it hard to tie in the food eaten to any particular source, such as from who, and where the contamination came from.  That may be Maple Leaf Foods defence when lawsuits result in a court of law.

Listeria can be a hidden killer and time bomb affecting mostly the elderly, children, pregnant women and anyone with an immune deficiency. Listeria a bacteria found in animal feces has been reported worldwide, and may result in more deaths or illnesses.

Maple Leaf Foods a Canadian Monopoly has been accused of lax quality control by workers and consumers alike.  Funny, how a cup of bleach, say worth a few pennies could have averted a disaster, but workers on the other hand cost more, and perhaps worker mentality of perhaps "It's Not my Job", it's coffee break break time, or another excuse may have contributed to it.

 We used to have worker ethics 2 decades ago, now it seems with frequent food recalls all over, that surely that ethic is lacking. 

One contaminated animal on the process line can contaminate any meat which passes after along the assembly line.

Comments range from stricter controls and testing to  using several local independent abbattoirs instead of one or two large Maple Leaf owned and operated process facilities.

By using several abbottoirs,  this would have at least contained the listeria outbreak to a local abbatoir instead of an entire Nations.

The fault can lie with not only the company, but human complacency in that workers can be faulted with laziness, as they too, especially long time workers knew full well the dirty conditions and did nothing about it. 

Some may have brought it to managements attention, it may have been ignored, but in due diligence, it should have been actioned and cleaned for our safety, either by union demands, employee demands, or company demands. 

I also blame provincial and federal Health Inspectors as well, because clearly if they cannot use a flashlight, glove test, swab test, or bend their Fat Asses down to inspect machinery, clearly they should be fired.

Clearly by this story it was not, and now negative media attention on a "Iconic Canadian Meat company will suffer the consequences by Consumers, which may see Maple Leaf Foods hit the "killing floor" as lawsuits of insurmountable proportions may be realised.

Maple Leaf will pay for these Lawsuits, on the backs of workers who ignored safety and hygiene, employee non diligence in protecting our foods will surely hit the unemployment lines due to a today's Mantra of  "It's not my job mentality", when clearly it is everyones job to ensure the food we eat won't kill us. 

For Now Public readers, many who do not know or have ever seen a Abbattoir Killing Floor or Meat Processing Plant and Meat Process Equipment.

I have posted photos (Not Maple Leaf Foods Abbattoirs) but similar operations from other abbattoirs for viewing. Some of these photos are not for the faint of heart, but tell you what is involved and how easy it can be to contaminate your food if not careful in skinning an animal and knicking it's intestines with a knife, resulting in a spillage of feces on a process table which if not cleaned and sanitized will contaminate the next carcass as well and every other carcass after that. 

Meat cutters are not tasked to clean feces spillage on the table for obvious reasons as food handlers, this task falls to the decontamination staff most likely are alerted to decontaminate any feces spillage immediately before any other carcass is processed.

Resulting in an entire process line being contaminated with feces as it passes from one stage to the next all the way to your dinner table.

And if I were the company president, firing the lot of them for laziness, I would not feel sorry for those employees who let us down.

Because when it comes down to it, the President who hired workers to ensure our safety, will now fall on the corporate sword, and bleed by the hands of others paid to do a job, but didn't. "Et tu, Brutus" would be an accurate assessment.

Below is my previous Op/ed piece on Consumer Groups charging Maple Leaf and the Feds were not doing enough to protect consumers.

http://www.nowpublic.com/world/canada-outbreak-outrageous-consumer-group-blasts-feds-over-listeriosis-deaths

Todays story and source below

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/2008/08/30/6616136-sun.html

August 30, 2008

Worker says meat plant filthy, But Maple Leaf denies claims machines not properly cleaned

By AMY CHUNG, SUN MEDIA

Workers at the Maple Leaf Foods plant linked to a fatal, nationwide listeria outbreak cut corners when they cleaned food processing machines, a longtime employee claims.

"They haven't cleaned some of the machines' (interiors) in four, five years," said the worker, who asked to remain anonymous.

Machines used to process meat at the plant on Bartor Rd. in North York haven't received a thorough scrubbing until this week, after the listeria outbreak, he told the Sun.

"When they opened the (machine) lid (this week), it smelled like hell," he said. Public health officials are reviewing 15 deaths - nine of which have already been tied to the outbreak - and more than 40 cases of illness they suspect are linked to meat products processed at the plant.

Maple Leaf issued a massive recall of its products following the outbreak and shut down the North York plant. This week, half the plant's 300 workers went back to sanitize production lines, and media and TV crews were invited in to watch.

While the machines were cleaned daily at the plant prior to the outbreak, the whistleblower suggested daily cleaning procedures were not consistently followed or thorough enough.

The Maple Leaf worker also claimed a shoestring night staff only manages to clean "what they see" and the production line where the recalled corned and roast beef were handled was not always cleaned thoroughly.

"They clean the surface, but not underneath. You can see the dust and meat sitting on it," he said. For thorough sanitization, the slicing machines should have been occasionally disassembled and deep cleaned, the worker insisted.

"They should get a flashlight and look inside. It was terrible -- leftover meat -- the smell," he said, recalling what happened when workers did completely disassemble the machines this week.

What they found inside were the gritty, pasty remains of leftover meat.

"We used so much chlorine to kill the bacteria, my eyes were burning," he said. Maple Leaf spokesman Linda Smith rejected the suggestion workers cut corners while cleaning and said employees at the plant in fact have "exceeded" the manufacturer's sanitization processes for all the equipment.

"This is a highly sanitized facility," Smith said. "I can tell you that they do daily sanitization and 3,000 environmental swabs in the microbiology lab that are verified by external sources.

" The United Food Commercial Workers Canada, the union representing Maple Leaf workers, says it has never received a complaint about health and safety at the plant.

Listeria is a common bacteria found in soil, vegetation, sewage, water and the feces of animals and humans. Listeria bacteria can also be found in unpasteurized dairy products, raw vegetables and meats.

Young children, pregnant women and the elderly are most vulnerable to illness. It is not clear whether the federal government requires meat processing equipment to be regularly disassembled and thoroughly cleaned as part of normal procedures.

The Sun repeatedly asked spokesmen at the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) yesterday what specific sanitation procedures are mandatory, but the agency could not provide a specific answer.


Maybe the onus is on Canadians to look after themselves, if we as paying consumers and taxpayers cannot trust Iconic Companies and Governments to protect us. 

For over a decade, Consumer Groups, Local Farmers and Media have been warning us about our food supply and it's safety being in jeopardy, and unfortunately we may not have been listening, till now when it hits so close to home.

Below are my past op/eds from last year from the National media, perhaps now a wake up call is in order for Canadians to be informed and look out for Number #1, "Ourselves" !!!

http://www.nowpublic.com/health/update-canada-food-imports-china-safe-eat

http://www.nowpublic.com/world/new-rules-canadian-food-labels

http://www.nowpublic.com/environment/product-canada-dont-bet-it-0


http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/2007/10/24/product_of_canada_eh/

Advertisement
recommend Sign In or Join to post comments
Uwe Paschen
Uwe Paschen
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:05 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

Are the Worker not supposed to keep it clean and or advise management or the health unit if things are not going the way they should be.? 

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Paschen, my argument all along, dont expect the president of the company to go crawling along the ground looking for feces or rotted meat, that is why he hired workers to do it.  But clearly in the last two decades or so, work ethic has gone by the wayside in worker mentality of "I am just going to do the bare minimum" required by my job description and union agreement. 

0
Frank Fortune

Infused with Naomi Klein-whining, and powered by Tory cost-cutting measures, standards in Canada have been on the slide for the past ten years or more. It's a toxic combination: the left makes childlike moans about the 'burden' of living in a rich country, with their spoiled little girl guru Naomi leading the charge, and the Tories with their corrupt, back-slapping, yup yup yup, cronyism, dragging the 'Swiss' USA down the toilet.

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks for the comments Frank, Boy, now there is a comment, which surely shows someone unclear on the concept of Employee responsibility, Hence my argument, glad you don't work for Maple Leaf Foods, or perhaps you do? Perhaps a worker mentality as yours is why we are in the predicament we are currently in. 

Blame everyone but the person hired to clean the plant. Perhaps you did not read the article whereby an employee states the plant was dirty!

If he knew as I surmise many did, there are plant OH&S committees in place amongst other employee and committee groups who knew, cause clearly a two minute inspection of the meat cutting machines would have proven the fact someone was not doing their job.

But hey, frank, thanks for the comments and validating what I said, "It's not my job Society" so I ain't doing it.

Barbara McPherson
Barbara McPherson
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:36 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff. The centralization of food processing, as you have stated, makes these outbreaks inevitable.  In BC the new slaughter regulations are forcing small abattoirs out of business because of the costs to bring them up to export standards.  With a local knacker, you knew what the facilities looked like, and more importantly, what they smelled like.  Now, to kill the animals they must be transported to a larger facility where there is a much more likely chance of encountering contamination.  People need to think about it -- when you vacuum the guts out of a chicken, do you think there is no "spillage" onto the meat?  When you kill hundreds of cattle a day, do you think the kill floor is pristine?

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Barbara for the comments and flag, perhaps after this incident, they may rethink their centralised abbattoir policy

Emilio Lizardo
Emilio Lizardo
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:37 on August 30th, 2008

Indeed ...

All these problems with the human consumption of meat, the one dealt with in your article, trichinosis with pork, and something nobody want to discuss, bovine spongeform encephalitis, BSE or mad-cow disease ( spongeform - turns your brain into a sponge, not to be confused with alzhiemer's which turns your brain into something more like a coral ... ).

All these problems shed light on why many cultures still in touch with their ancient history are either vegetarian, won't touch pork, etc ...

Important story, Barry!

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Emilio for the comments and flag. Certainly this story and accompaning photos may turn some into vegans.

dunkelberg
dunkelberg
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:38 on August 30th, 2008

The Sun repeatedly asked spokesmen at the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) yesterday what specific sanitation procedures are mandatory, but the agency could not provide a specific answer.

Interesting.

I imagine Maple Leaf Food will follow the example of its American cousins and make sure everyone responsible from the lowest supervisory post on down will be held responsible and that executive salaries and bonuses will be protected with layoffs to cover any losses.

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Dunk for the comments and flag, CFIA have QC on their websites, as for giving specific instruction, like most government agencies they hesitate, as they too could be held liable, they usually come in after the fact to lay charges, as per usual.

0
dunkelberg

QC?  Queen's counsel?  Legal beagles?

Come to think of it, I've run into lack of specifics here south of the border.  I guess, outside of being held liable, an incomplete or erroneous answer by a word merchant in the "information" office could be used against them.



0
Barry ORegan

Not Queens Council, Quality Control!

0
Emilio Lizardo

Executive salaries should be increased !!

For saving the company money by firing as many as possible over this incident ...

Rhonda J Mangus
Rhonda J Mangus
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:53 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Rhonda for visiting and flagging this story

lgal3824
lgal3824
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:06 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff and scary! Next, the FDA will probably require all processed food to be irradiated to kill bacteria and not just spinach and lettuce. Which is explained here: http://www.newsinferno.com/archives/3689.

In 206 the FDA approved the viral spraying of food to kill other types of bacteria, http://www.newswithviews.com/Richards/byron7.htm. Both of these methods were unknown to me until Barry got me started on this Listeria issue.

You should have seen the look on my "Vegetarian" friends faces after the lettuce and spinich recalls recently! They had to get off their "High Horse" when they realized even the veggies aren't safe to eat.

I think I will try living off bottled water. Oh yeah, they found bacteria in bottled water too, http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20041104/bacteria-found-in-bottled-mineral-water.

*stomach growling*

Thanks for the story Barry!

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Lgal, you know as "Roseanna Danna Anna" used to say "it's always something!

World_Groove
World_Groove
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:20 on August 30th, 2008

I am having microwaved malt o meal made with distilled water this morning.


0
Barry ORegan

Thanks groove for the comments and the flag, as for me, I am having cheerios and blueberries.,

Pat Garcia
Pat Garcia
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:30 on August 30th, 2008


0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Pat, for the flag and dropping by

Paul Conneally
Paul Conneally
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 09:46 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff. We've had Listeria outbreaks here in UK usually down to poor slaughter practce - stomach and bowel contents contaminating the rest of the carcas. It's unforgiveable for a food plant to cause such danger to the public.

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Lotus for the comments and the flag, definitely unacceptable

Tanasha
Tanasha
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 10:59 on August 30th, 2008

Thank you for this story.  I must say I have not eaten much meet since this situation came about.  After seeing those images, I will probably eat even less.




Amy Judd
Amy Judd
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 12:22 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

This is so gross - I haven't eaten processed meat since this all came to light.

That top picture is so horrible. Where did you get it?

Mikasi
Mikasi
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:00 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

I work in a restaurant. When a recall comes in we have to halt sales of the particular product and call our supplier to make sure things are ok to serve.

BigT
BigT
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:53 on August 30th, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

0
Barry ORegan

Thanks Tanasha, Amy, Mikasi and BigT for your comments and flags, as you say Tanasha, I too have sworn off processed meats forever, as I care not for their new Slogan, "Taste the Difference Feces Makes" , Amy I pulled the photo off the UK Meat council, and Mikasi, as you say, I think Restaurants are most likely more on the front line in lawsuits if a customer becomes ill, whether their fault or not, bad publicity can be a Restaurants Death Knell!  Guess the Ham and Rib BBQ is off BigT. HA!

I received a private email from a reader who is an electrician in our lower mainland, who services equipment, both commercial style deli and butcher, his horror story of maggots living inside this machinery is a story in itself.    He named names of recognizable companies and supermarkets.

Long story short, Only buy meats, local, not imported fish, local poultry from small, real small local neighbourhood butcheries and fish markets, and poultry from Lilydale in Abbotsford. 

Whether all his statements are true? Who knows? Now we know!  And I am so friggin grateful for that info.  Granted  we may pay a tad more, but you know what? From what he told me, it is either do as he says, or be a vegan and grow your own food.

As I am addicted to only local, (never imported) toupe ham, steak, chicken, salmon and halibut, a vegan lifestyle is not for me.

You know Maple Leaf was the last company I would have thought would make the list endangering Canadians.

Some may recall my story last year, when I posted a W5  piece on Food suppliers stating their Foods including Seafoods were made in Canada, and we later found out on the only the seasoning and packaging were from Canada, with the seafood and or ingredients of almost every food staple, including vitamins we consume comes from China and Vietnam, just Chock full of Carcinogenic Goodness, especially in their seafood with Malachite Green.

Well Bingo is his Nameo, so there's your hint.  Buy local.  Whenever there was a case of way too much information, his email was it.


Below are my past op/eds from the National media, perhaps now a wake up call is in order for Canadians

http://www.nowpublic.com/health/update-canada-food-imports-china-safe-eat

http://www.nowpublic.com/world/new-rules-canadian-food-labels

http://www.nowpublic.com/environment/product-canada-dont-bet-it-0

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/2007/10/24/product_of_canada_eh/

0
dunkelberg

Actually, this finally reminded me to look up sausage casings.  I can't find them locally (Fort Worth/Dallas, Texas - if anyone knows), and must order them online.

Making your own is not that difficult and very tasty.


Mike Wood
Mike Wood
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 07:01 on August 31st, 2008

Barry Artiste, I like this story. It's good stuff.

As if the Consumer doesn’t have enough day to day worries with being over taxed, gouged at the pumps, employment, economy, etc., and etc. Now one can't enjoy a good meal at the end of this daily endurance.

All this largely falls on the hands of the government. A government which will always demand more of the Tax Payer but do less and less in return.

Now rumours are flying that Harper's Conservatives cut funding to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. I would not be surprised if this is true as the Conservatives were also at the helm in Ontario during the Walkerton tragedy. A tragedy which was blamed in part on provincial government cutbacks. Maybe our Health Minister Tony Clement should be among those walking the plank towards the meat grinder.

Obviously there needs to be better quality control and safety measures put into place. Sanitation training and a weekly or monthly sanitization of all facilities that handle food perhaps. Mr. & Mrs. Consumer should demand this.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from