Memphis Police Department Hiring – Perhaps Blacks Need Not Apply

by duo | July 11, 2008 at 07:11 pm
2645 views | 2 Recommendations | 11 comments

Photos

MemphisPD

MemphisPD

see larger image

uploaded by duo

There are 500 police jobs up for grabs on the Memphis Police Department, but according to an Associated Press article released July 9, 2008, perhaps African Americans need not apply.  The article reports that some city council members expressed concern that blacks may be barred from the positions because of trivial issues designed to keep them from the hiring pool.  So intense is the search for “qualified” applicants that the police department has requested permission from the city council to recruit from outside the city to fill 125 of the police openings this year. 

 

See the AP article at: http://www.knoxnews.com/news/2008/jul/07/memphis-police-hiring-questioned/?printer=1/

 

If the allegations of discriminatory hiring practices are true, then non-black people should contact the MemphisPD right away.  The Memphis PD has immediate openings due in part to officers recently fired for restraining, beating, and pepper spraying transgender detainee Duanna Johnson in February 2008.  Ms. Johnson’s abuse, caught on tape and broadcast all over the nation in June, caused much criticism against police brutality, particularly from the gay, lesbian, bi-sexual, and transgender community.  Ms. Johnson is pursuing a civil action.  In another case, a Shelby County Sheriff’s deputy, Alvin Dortchs, was just placed on administrative leave (paid vacation) after a young motorist’s death.  Apparently the lawman’s account of the citizen’s death did not agree with the video on his dash cam and the testimony of an eye witness.

 

Link to Officer Dortchs v. Video Dash Cam

 

http://www.badcopnews.com/2008/07/02/lies-shelby-county-tennessee-deputy-sherif-alvin-dortchs-story-of-mans-death-doesnt-add-up-caught-on-video/

 

There are pages of links regarding Duanna Johnson's abuse on the Internet.  The lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, and transgender community was particularly offended at the brutality evident on the tape, as well as others who are concerned about justice and human rights.  See more about Duanna Johnson's case, the video, and information on other lawsuits alleging police brutality and wrongful death against Memphis law enforcement at this link:

 

http://www.nowpublic.com/world/memphis-police-taped-beating-transsexual-detainee-1-3-million-lawsuit-filed-mary-neal

 

According to the AP report, Memphis rates first in the nation for property crime and second for violent crime. 

 

***OPINION***

 

Police recruits chosen for the 125 positions to be filled this year are likely to face many challenges upholding law and order, perhaps not all coming from outside the department.

 

Mary Neal

Assistance to the Incarcerated Mentally Ill

Website:  http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com

 

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
PEP

Also from the article: "Among police officials who deny discrimination is Sgt. Michael Rallings, who is African-American and serves as commander of the police training academy.

A former requirement that applicants have a college degree has been eliminated."

OK, Rallings' views don't count? And, if my local PD lowered its current educational requiremens, I'd be upset.

Also, could you tell us exactly what the criteria are for being hired? And also identify what the so-called "trivial" issues are that the very very short article refers to. It doesn't tell us what those issues are.

I'd also suggest that you identify this as an "Opinion" piece as it clearly is. :)

0
duo

Thanks, Pep.  I added "opinion," since the very last sentence was my personal thoughts.  Also, please note that Officer Dortchs, on administrative leave after the motorist's death,  is also African American, like Mr. Rallings.  According to reports, so were two of the officers in the Sean Bell incident.  In abuse of power issues, apparently, race is largely irrelevant.

Mary Neal

0
PEP

I thought that I'd do a little research on the hiring practices to help you answer the questions, above.

Here's an op-ed from the Memphis Commercial Appeal. In part, it says: "With African-Americans in positions of authority in city government, it's hard to make a case for the notion that the city is discriminating against black applicants for the Police Department.....

There is little to support the notion that discrimination exists, however.

White applicants have been hired at the rate of about 20 percent between 2006 and 2008 and the percentage of successful black applicants is closer to 11. Nevertheless, the MPD has been hiring more black officers than white officers over the past two years.

An African-American mayor has been in office here since 1992 and a substantial number of black police officers are in significant positions of leadership and authority."

And an earlier story: "

Between 2006 and 2008, black applicants accounted for 57 to 65 percent of new officers hired, mirroring the demographic makeup of Memphis, according to 2006 U.S. Census Bureau statistics.

Police records indicate that every year most applicants are rejected because they simply don't show up.

In 2006, 25 percent of applicants were disqualified as "no shows." The number was 23 percent in 2007 and 25 percent through June 1 of this year.

The next biggest reason for disqualification is failure of physical or written tests.

The third major reason is the psychological exam. Between 2006 and June 1 of this year, 12 to 20 percent of the applicants were rejected because of the psychological test."

The article also pointed out that one council member was upset because applicants with arrest records were being rejected.

Is there a police department web site that lists hiring criteria?


0
duo

Thanks for the follow-up info, Pep.  Perhaps some would believe the particular psychological exams and other tests that disqualified the black applicants were themselves racist.  Some such allegations have arisen in the past about tests.  Of course, I do not know why some council members reportedly believe the hiring policies may be racist.  Maybe the AP reporter who wrote the piece that originated my article can clarify that point for you.

Mary

0
TETE

I have been thinking of applying with MPD. I am a graduate of the University of Mississippi and had completed the application and then I withdrew because I felt that I was not good to pass the PT test. Now I see that racial profiling is going on. Are these facts or a myth. If true I will not reconsider applying with MPD. I'm looking for a career and an agent to work with that I can be proud to say so. I want to serve and protect....nothing less.

0
duo

Memphis PD has many problems - ethics and police brutality are two major ones.  I am not sure whether Memphis PD has more problems than other cities, or whether my personal loss due to corruption in Memphis law enforcement colors my perception.  See http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com

Regarding employment discrimination, the AP reports that city council members made that allegation.  I cannot imagine a more credible source than council members who are in a position to know what is going on in their own city government.

You could be a positive addition to the Memphis PD.  We are blessed with many dedicated persons in law enforcement in this country who serve their communities with bravery and integrity.  It is up to our law enforcement to catch and prosecute criminals, even when police officers are the culprits.  Memphis could do a better job of that.  Don't stay away because of the sorry reputation the Memphis PD has -- get in there and help effect positive change! 

Mary

0
Anonymous1

In regards to the post about whether or not the psychological examiners are racist....Dr. Turner, the psychologist who performs all of the psych exams, is black.

0
duo

Thanks for your comments.  This article quotes an report by the Associated Press (AP).  The link to the AP article is provided.  Apparently, some city officials expressed the view that the hiring practices at the MPD were racist. 

Mary

0
danoman

why are the MPD recruit classes cosnsistently 60% black.....if it were the other way around there would be lawsuits galor.  maybe some people just apply when they are not qualified thinking that they will slip through the cracks or maybe they just think it is their costitutional right to have a government job.

0
Rebecca Smith

Yeah, "trivial" things like passing psych exam, physical exam, and written exam, no criminal record.   Oh, dear, if some black people can't pass those criteria, then we should just LOWER them, right?  I mean I am all for a sociopathic, uneducated, out of shape, criminal becoming a police officer, as long as he is black !!  How DARE they have requirements for becoming an officer.  

Memphis has one of the highest violent crime rates in the country, so by all means, let's delay the hiring of much needed police officers and/or simply hire unqualified people to take those positions because they are the right color.

And for this quote:   cannot imagine a more credible source than council members who are in a position to know what is going on in their own city government.

Please remember that city council members are just elected officials and may or may not be in any better position to know what is going on within the government.  ANYONE can be elected.  I CAN imagine a more credible source:  the officials who are having problems hiring, and the people who are being robbed, raped, and murdered on a daily basis.  Do you really think if  you were the victim of a crime you would care if the cop who helped you lived in Bartlett or Germantown instead of the city proper?   They don't even want to allow hiring within the COUNTY that Memphis is in.  JUST the city proper.  IF there are not enough QUALIFIED applicants then  they should be allowed to search outside the city limits.  

I am against racist hiring practices, and I don't believe there are any going on in the memphis police department.  It would behoove the citizens to have QUALIFIED applicants hired and not just hire people BECAUSE of their race which is inherently racist!!!  If I said that they should hire someone just because they are white, I would be labeled a racist.  Well our city councilwoman who is stating that some people should be hired simply based on their race, is a racist.  She has NOT done any research and is simply spouting outdated rhetoric in the hopes of shining a light on her own star.  Somebody said the words "hey I couldn't be hired and it's cause of racial profiling" and she just ran with it. 

When I'm running away from the guy with the gun, screaming for help, and there's no cop to hear, I'll be sure to keep her in  mind.

 

0
duo

Thanks for responding.  I wish everyone would get along and race not be a factor in how we interact.  The comments in the article about prejudice were by the AP.  The Asso. Press reported that some of the city council members told the AP reporter this.  As so often happens when I post information about Memphis law enforcement, the AP article seems to be no longer available.  humm.

All I know about personally about law enforcement in Memphis is in http://wrongfuldeathoflarryneal.com - they need to CHANGE. Check out the link and you will agree.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Anonymous
First Flagged at 1:27 PM, Nov 19, 2008 by Anonymous (not verified)
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (2)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from