The Middle East and Barack Obama.

by gerrypopplestone | November 8, 2008 at 11:31 pm
383 views | 28 Recommendations | 6 comments

Photos

Kids in Ramallah, Palestine

Kids in Ramallah, Palestine

see larger image

uploaded by scottmontreal

We know it.

Barack Obama knows that we know it.

And he knows it too!

The key to sorting out the conflicts in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Ethiopia can be summed up in one word:

Palestine

Obama has just a few months to give Israel some clear signals on what he is thinking, before they go to the polls in February. Although it is not up to the US to tell the Israelis how to vote, we know that Israeli prime ministers like to be persona grata in Washington.  And everyone knows what a mess the Israelis (and the Palestinians for that matter) have got themselves into.  We all had hopes that Tzipi Livini would make it as prime minister.  She looked as if she might have the necessary courage and punch to sort out the two-state solution that is inevitable, once and for all.

But she fell short - stupidly in my judgement. She could have stepped into Olmert's shoes without an election had she got enough of a coalition together. She almost did it but she failed.  She refused to give one small party the funds they asked for and she would not refuse to talk to the Palestinians about Jerusalem.  Maybe that was a mistake that some more wily negotiator would have handled better.  She may win in February:  Then too Binyamin Netanyahu may win.  Even if he does win, all may not be lost.  Hawks usually are better at winning the peace than are doves.  Look at Northern Ireland!

What we don't yet know is how Brack Obama will tackle the issue.  He blundered during the campaign when he promised that Jerusalen would not be divided.  Ok, that might be understandable in electioneering.

Obama had to deal with serious Islamaphobia during the election.

Yet he left it to Colin Powell to say clearly that there is nothing wrong with being Islamic.

There is nothing wrong with being Jewish either.

Barack Obama has many Jewish friends.  His chief strategist, David Alexrod, is a Jewish-American.  His chief adviser on the Middle-East, Dennis Ross, is a Jewish-American.  His chief-of-staff, Rahm Emmanuel, is a Jewish-American, who identifies with hawkish right-wing Israeli politics and himself did a stint in the Israeli military. And Candidate Obama has repeated America's usual support for the Jewish state, calling its security sacrosanct.

Imtiaz Muqbil, in today's Bangkok Post, lists the disappointments in his campaign.

ONE:  on the campaign he visited many synagogues, especially a large one in Florida.  Yet he never visited any mosques.

TWO:  two Muslim women wearing the hijab were removed from the backdrop of the photo-ops at the August 2008 Democratic Convention, where he won the nomination.

THREE:  Jimmy Carter who has done so much to bring peace to the Middle East, could not even get a speaking slot at that convention because of his views on Palestine (and Carter's recent book - Apartheid - was a bit over the top, to my mind).

Robert Fisk, the journalist on the Middle East for the Independent, and a leading authority on these issues, pointed out in an interview with Aljazeera, that Obama's victory speech never once contained the word - justice.

Now none of this may matter.  We might put it all down to the need to win the election.

Obama has promised change. And the Economist this week did point out that he has shown more sympathy than most previous presidents for the plight of the Palestinians. So how much will he actually deliver?  Those who are affected by change will fight hard to resist anything they do not like.  The Jewish lobby is well organised.  Always has been; always will be.  George Bush promised a two-state solution but we always knew he never would deliver on it.  Condy Rice has been to Israel and talked with both sides; eighty times (oops!  that should have read eighteen times!)I think.  But there is no peace in sight.

Oh I know things are difficult.  But President-Elect Barack Obama does have a Palestinian friend, Rashid Khalidi, (a prominent Palestinian-American scholar) formed in Chicago.  Call me naive if you want:  will he appoint Khalidi as his adviser on Palestinian affairs?  That would at least be a start.

The rest is up to us!

We need to make sure that Barack Obama knows that we know that peace will never fully arrive anywhere in the Arab world until the US President knocks heads together over the Middle East, as only he can do.We all know the two-state solution has to come.

Vigilence, brothers and sisters, vigilence.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
Sputnic

Good stuff, the two state solution is the only diplomatic choice. Israel should also return stolen lands or of course pay compensation

0
gerrypopplestone

Thanks, Sputnic.  I think Tony Blair is doing quite a good job as the EU/Quartet Envoy, but he recopgnises there are still huge problems to be sorted.  He has good experience through the Northern Ireland Peace process:  did a great job there, listening to Ian Paisley, that Protestant guy, wittering on about his Mum, apparently!

0
scottmontreal

Ramallah, Palestine, Dec 2003. It was a 'quiet time' in Palestine & Israel when I took that photo. Very few shootings, only the sounds of Israeli bulldozers demolishing Palestinian homes and farms. A slow but sure form of ethnic cleansing.

scottmontreal has contributed a photo to this story.

0
gerrypopplestone

Many thanks for your photo and the details on it.  I like the graffiti in the background especially.

0
scottmontreal

Hi Jerry,

I join many others in celebrating the Obama victory, but critical of his Zionist stance. Rahm Emanuel is very Zionist and a scary choice if Obama is serious about a just solution. The two state solution is no longer viable for the Palestinians, as Israel has stolen too much of their land and aquafers - especially with the construction of The Wall inside Palestinian territories. We need to think of a single state solution for both peoples - a democratic rather than apartheid state. Like South Africa's solution.

Also, for us progressive Jews, catering to the right-wing-neoconservative-Zionist leadership in our communities does us no favours.

0
gerrypopplestone

I agree with you about Emmanuel (although he is probably a good choice for keeping jerks away from the President-to-be).  It is somewhat scary that he has no Palestinians around him.  Let's hope he is properly briefed.  It is outrageous that the occupatyion has been allowed to continue for so long.  But only the US President can knock heads together.  And I doubt very much whether either side(s) in Israel will be ready to work to a solution.  You know much more about the issues than I do:  maybe you are right about an all embracing state.

Many thanks.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Heritage
First Flagged at 6:11 AM, Nov 9, 2008 by Heritage
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (28)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from