Montecito Tea Fire Caused by Student Bonfire. Some quick to consider Westmont. Authorities:"Students belong to SB City College"

by Patrick Price Photographer | November 19, 2008 at 12:31 am
4107 views | 51 Recommendations | 58 comments

Photos

Montecito Tea Fire Caused by Student Bonfire. Some Point Fingers to Westmont. Report: "No CURRENT Westmont Students involved"

Montecito Tea Fire Caused by Student Bonfire. Some Point Fingers to Westmont. Report: "No CURRENT Westmont Students involved"

see larger image

uploaded by Patrick Price Photographer


The Santa Barbara and Montectito Communities respond to release by The Santa Barbara Independent.  Some say the non-release of the students school is political maneuver.

See the comments for yourself at link here:

http://www.independent.com/news/2008/nov/18/tea-fire-cause-determined/


A smoldering bonfire built by students on a ridge-top overlooking Montecito apparently sparked last week's disastrous Tea fire, Santa Barbara County Sheriff Bill Brown said Tuesday.

Ten men and women, ranging in age from 18 to 22, had gathered at an abandoned property called the Teahouse late Wednesday night and built a bonfire to warm themselves, Brown said.


They told fire investigators that they thought the bonfire was out when they left early Thursday morning. But embers continued to smolder for more than 12 hours and were reignited by Santa Ana-type winds that evening, authorities said.

In what became one of Santa Barbara County's most destructive wildfires, fast-moving flames destroyed 210 homes and damaged nine others. At least 25 people were injured, three of them with burns.

Brown told a news conference that investigators believe that the group did not intend to start a wildfire.

"It appears this was the result of carelessness," he said.

Brown declined to identify any of the men and women involved, saying that the matter was still under investigation. However, he said they all lived locally and attended the same school. He declined to say which one.

Westmont College, a Christian university with 1,200 students, sits immediately below the mountain ridge where the Teahouse is located. But Brown would not confirm or deny that students from the private campus were involved.

The group could face charges of negligence or recklessness with fire, he said. It will be up to the district attorney's office to decide what, if any, criminal charges will be filed once the investigation is completed, Brown said.

Investigators learned about the group's late-night outing from an anonymous tipster who called a fire hotline, Brown said. Each person was then contacted and questioned about the night's activities, he said.

"They have been cooperative," Brown said.

Nancy Phinney, a Westmont spokeswoman, said the college did not think that any of its students were involved. The school lost several buildings and 14 faculty homes in the fire.

"We have been working closely and cooperating fully with fire officials and at no point has anyone said that any of our students have been implicated," Phinney said.

Asked whether the Teahouse property was a student hangout, she said that dating back to at least the 1960s, "Westmont students have known that area. . . . It's very near our campus."

Other colleges in the area include the Brooks Institute and UC Santa Barbara.

News about the fire's cause spread rapidly in Montecito and Santa Barbara. Jack Milton, who lost the ocean-view home he had lived in for more than three decades and all of his belongings, said he was angered to learn about the group's apparent carelessness.

"I hope they press charges to deter anyone else from doing something so stupid," Milton said. "Anyone with fire up in those hills is just ignorant."

Saillant and Merl are Times staff writers.

catherine.saillant       LA Times

recommend This comment thread is now closed
2
Ron Ald

Westmont represents less than 3% of all Santa Barbara's 41,000 college students including also UCSB, Brooks Institute and Santa Barbara Community College.  The author of this article is irresponsible to suggest that Westmont students are the cause without any evidence.

2
good neighbor

It's interesting that little has been mentioned about the Tea House being on private property. As I understand it, there is a locked gate one must crawl under/over to gain entrance in order to trespass on this privately owned property. And where does the wood come from for the bonfire? It would seem this "outing" would require a lot of effort and preplanning.

 

2
Patrick Price Photographer


Everyone should focus on rebuild efforts at this I point I think. Along with giving to the red-cross several efforts will develop over the coming weeks to help find housing for displaced residents and victims of the fire. Myself, I will be making all efforts possible to help victims of the fire. I will be having an Art-Photo show in January.  A portion of the proceeds will go to funds for victims of the Tea Fire that are left picking up the pieces.

2
Ron Ald

Patrick Price, as others, used their preexisting prejudice against Westmont as a chance to kick them while they are down.

2
Ron Ald

How about an apology for spreading the rumor that the fires were started by Westmont students?

1
TruthTeller

You should be embarrassed by implicating anyone is this incident until it is reported by a credible source.  I have a credible source that has confirmed that NO WESTMONT STUDENTS WERE INVOLVED IN THE FIRE.  This is a fact and you are a rumor-monger.  Shame on you!

1
Patrick Price Photographer

The article was changed, and no Westmont students are being accused as of right now. This is not a rumor. The article states facts. The 10 people whom are believed to be responsible for the fire are college students, and they all go to the same school. Which school is yet to be released to the media.

1
Allen Clemens

Although the media has been speculating that, due to the proximity of Westmont College, the fire was started by students who attend the school, the fire department has stated that the suspects they are questioning are not Westmont students.

Patrick Price: Please do your research.

1
Patrick Price Photographer

My post never said Westmont students were responsible.  I'm flattered that my images are so persuading, but really the facts are right there and the post is non biased and based on facts.

1
Patrick Price Photographer

Allen, if you could read, you would see that I never stated Westmonts students were, in fact, responsible for the fire. And when I did mention Westmont students in my previous edit of the article, it was in the context of possibility. I did my research, and listed factual info. Please don't make this a personal protection campaign for Westmont. And please list a link or a quote for "the fire department has stated that the suspects they are questioning are not Westmont students." listed from your comment. Please be thorough. Thanks!

1
Mike Crawford

This is extracted from the Westmont College Website home page and is part of the "Tea Fire Update from President Gayle Beebe"http://www.westmont.edu/
".....1. Were any Westmont students involved in causing the fire?

No. On Wednesday afternoon at approximately 2:45 p.m., Drew Sugars, the public information officer for the Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office, officially informed the college that no current Westmont students were present nor in anyway involved with this tragic incident.

We have been in regular contact with investigators since the fire and have been providing any information that might be helpful toward determining the exact cause of the fire. This is our responsibility as a community citizen. Our surrounding coastal region is home to many colleges and universities, and like all of them, we are awaiting new information.

It should be noted that at this point, the group of individuals responsible for starting the fire are under the jurisdiction of law enforcement authorities. Again, no current Westmont students were involved with this incident...."

1
Patrick Price Photographer

is that confimed? we all want to know


1
lyrical


Tea Fire Update from President Gayle Beebe


Dear students, faculty, staff and friends:

It has nearly been a week since the Tea Fire ravaged our campus and 

the larger Montecito and coastal community. Our thoughts and prayers 

are with all devastated by this fire as each of us affected 

throughout the region continues to face the reality of having our 

everyday lives turned upside down.


Due to the close proximity of the college to the off-campus site of 

the fire, we have been inundated with questions from many concerned 

audiences. I'm sure that you have also been contacted as a source of 

information by friends and family.


There are a few questions that have come up repeatedly, and I'd like 

to share my responses with you. The most accurate source of 

information about the fire investigation will come from the 

authorities themselves; misinformation will only cause greater 

suffering for the region. For information concerning the 

investigation, please refer to the Sheriff's department at www.sbsheriff.org.


Sincerely,

Gayle D. Beebe, President



1) Were any Westmont students involved in causing the fire?


No. On Wednesday afternoon at approximately 2:45 p.m., Drew Sugars, 

the public information officer for the Santa Barbara County Sheriff's 

Office officially informed the college that no current Westmont 

students were present nor in anyway involved with this tragic incident.


We have been in regular contact with investigators since the fire and 

have been providing any information that might be helpful toward 

determining the exact cause of the fire. This is our responsibility 

as a community citizen.  Our surrounding coastal region is home to 

many colleges and universities, and like all of them, we are awaiting 

new information.


It should be noted that at this point, the group of individuals 

responsible for starting the fire are under the jurisdiction of law 

enforcement authorities. Again, no current Westmont students were 

involved with this incident.



2) When will students and faculty be able to return to campus?


The campus will reopen Saturday, Nov. 29, at noon, and classes will 

restart Dec. 1. We are tirelessly working to clean up the campus and 

accommodate the entire campus population after the Thanksgiving holiday.



3) When will new information about the cause of the investigation be 

made available?


We have been informed by authorities that the investigation is still 

underway. It is important to resist the urge to speculate beyond what 

is currently known. Ultimately, the public needs to let the 

authorities do their job.



4) How is the college addressing rumors speculating about Westmont students?


Investigators have determined that no current Westmont students were 

involved in the fire. Any suggestions to the contrary are false and damaging.


Despite rumors and speculation on the Internet, our utmost priority 

throughout the investigation has been addressing the needs of our 

campus and the surrounding community. That means providing 

information requested by authorities, cleaning up the demolished 

sites on our campus in preparation for returning to the academic 

term, and generally being a good neighbor in a time of great 

need.  Second, we are providing accurate information directly from 

investigators to our college community in as timely a manner as possible.


Ultimately, the findings of the investigation will be made public by 

authorities and the individuals responsible for the fire will enter 

the jurisdiction of the law. Until that point, I ask that each of you 

do your part by avoiding undue speculation and by communicating 

responsibly, as is reflected in our values and mission.



5) How can I help?


Along with your family and friends, I strongly encourage you to 

participate in our Wildfire Relief Fund (link). As a longtime member 

of the Santa Barbara community, we will be working in unison with the 

region toward rebuilding efforts and we will be releasing more 

information about those possibilities as appropriate. For now, I ask 

that you continue to keep all victims of this fire in your thoughts 

and prayers, and become involved in our community efforts.



_______________________________________________

Testlist mailing list

Testlist@mail.westmont.edu

http://mail.westmont.edu/mailman/listinfo/testlist

1
lyrical

A statement from Santa Barbara City College President Andreea Serban confirmed Thursday that nine of the ten people allegedly responsible for the Tea fire were enrolled at the school.
(The headline to this article was libelous and irresponsible and should be removed immediately.)

1
lyrical

A statement from Santa Barbara City College President Andreea Serban confirmed Thursday that nine of the ten people allegedly responsible for the Tea fire were enrolled at the school.
(The headline to this article was irresponsible and should be removed immediately.)

1
lyrical

A statement from Santa Barbara City College President Andreea Serban confirmed Thursday that nine of the ten people allegedly responsible for the Tea fire were enrolled at the school.

1
lyrical

A statement from Santa Barbara City College President Andreea Serban confirmed Thursday that nine of the ten people allegedly responsible for the Tea fire were enrolled at the school.

1
lyrical

A statement from Santa Barbara City College President Andreea Serban confirmed Thursday that nine of the ten people allegedly responsible for the Tea fire were enrolled at the school.
Oops, Patrick Price's headline was irresponsible and should be removed immediately, just to clarify....

1
lyrical

Just to clarify... Patrick Price's headline was irresponsible....

1
'04 Alumnus

Interesting feedback from the community.  Bottom line.  It happened, and now we need to pick up the pieces and support those who lost everything.  Let this be a valuable lesson to everyone that we live in kindling and need to be EXTRA careful and aware of the dangers a fire.

Although I love your contributions to this story Patrick, I take a little exception to your comment above: "If you've seen what I've seen from Westmont students, present and graduated, you would easily admit it is possible. I've seen a Westmont student setting fire to twigs in the park near there while they were stoned on Marijuana. Now THATS IRRISPONSIBLE. EVEN FOR A WESTMONT STUDENT. This article quotes authorities whom have spoken with the 10 people who believe they are responsible. Their collegiate affiliation is yet to be confirmed. Read The Article!!!!!"

Bro, how is it relevant what you've seen from current/past Westmont students in the form of irresponsibility?  And why would you feel the need to point to those students being "stoned on marijuana"?  I don't think the reader's protests on the very clear assumption in the article (due to proximity) that Westmont students were rumored to be responsible was based on Westmont students being 'holier than thou.'  It has to do more with leading the reader to believe that it is more likely that the fire-starters are from Westmont than other local educational institutions.  Subsequently we've been notified that the students hail from SBCC.  Either way, I'm not offended by the article, but by the way you allowed your own subjectivity to interfere with your solid and otherwise objective report.  At least it was only in the form of a comment, which is minor in this kind of forum.  Anyway, call me later...

1
lyrical

Well, you ripped off the story from the L.A. Times.  Why not rip off their decent headline as well?  It was certainly more professional than the one posted here, which cites finger-pointing weblog rumors and seeks to skew the statement of the Wesmont president.  Check your files for the original title which stated that the fire was "possibly started by Westmont students."  That's irresponsible reporting.

1
Caral

This is currently posted on the Santa Barbara City College website:


SBCC Issues Statement Regarding Tea Fire

November 20, 2008

 SANTA BARBARACITY COLLEGE STATEMENT
REGARDING TEA FIRE INCIDENT


From: Superintendent/President Dr. Andreea M. Serban
Santa Barbara City College

The Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Department notified me yesterday, November 19, that nine of the ten individuals identified as allegedly responsible for the Tea Fire have been confirmed as Santa Barbara City College students.

We are deeply saddened by this news and extend our heartfelt sympathies to all members of the community and their families who were affected by this tragedy. This tragedy also has had a direct and significant impact on SBCC faculty, staff and students who were among those who lost their homes and personal possessions during this fire.

Our students, as with all college students, have personal lives outside of the college. We acknowledge these boundaries and do not oversee students' personal activities away from campus. We will cooperate with local authorities to the extent possible in their ongoing investigation.The authorities will decide any further course of action for these students who were involved in this tragic accident.


1
Roberto V

Unbelievable that this journalist would write such a slanted piece trying to paint the fires on Westmont students.  The journalist left out that Santa Barbara City College is also in the area and the SBCC president has already admitted that at least 9 out of 10 of the students came from Santa Barbara City College.  Terrible journalism!!!

1
hornitos

Good thing this guy is a photographer and not a writer huh Roberto? And if you think that all of the posts on here are journalism school grads gettting paid to upload this stuff, you are a fool. Plus the person who posted this article, didn't write it. This is a re-post. Keep commenting though. More the merrier.   Terrible Journalism!!!! Whaaaaaaaa *hickup* someone get me a hanky. 

1
Ron Ald

Thank you for changing the article to be more accurate as more information was available.  At one moment in time the headline read "Montecito Santa Barbara Tea Fire Caused by Westmont College Students Bonfire."  The headlines before and after this were more accurate and this headline was removed soon after it was posted so I appreciate your concern that noone got the wrong idea. 

This was especially important since so many were ready to kick Westmont while it was down.  So seemed to base this on their beliefs or disagreements regarding land use approvals.  None of these are valid reasons to spead vicious rumors without any proof.

You have been the only person on this blog or the Independent to care about what kind of damage this false rumors can cause a small college of about 1,000 students that seems to be trying to be a good nieghbor in spite of the cheap shots it is having to endur unfairly.  Bravo!

1
Ron D

I have a copy of Partick Price's headline which falsely states that the "Montecito Santa Barbara Tea Fire Caused by Westmont College Students Bonfire."  It is one thing to jump to a seemingly obvious conclusion but quite another thing to deny the mistake by accusing the fire victims of past drunkedness, pot smoking and twig igniting behavior as a justification.

I would post the link to the false headline but this site rejects my attempted links as "spam."  I'll keep trying so you all can see.

0
pwprice80@yahoo.com

If you've seen what I've seen from Westmont students, present and graduated, you would easily admit it is possible. I've seen a Westmont student setting fire to twigs in the park near there while they were stoned on Marijuana. Now THATS IRRISPONSIBLE. EVEN FOR A WESTMONT STUDENT. This article quotes authorities whom have spoken with the 10 people who believe they are responsible. Their collegiate affiliation is yet to be confirmed. Read The Article!!!!!

0
pricephoto

This article is a direct quote of an article based on releases from Authorities in the Santa Barbara area.  While the possibility of another student group has not been ruled out, the main flow of young students going to the Tea Gardens for recreation comes from Westmont for obvious geographic reasons.  I've witnessed very irresponsible behavior from present and graduated students from Westmont, including fire play while under the influence of libation. That's Irrisponsible.

0
David Cowan

I graduated from Westmont.  Stupid behavior comes in every flavor.  Despite its overt religiosity, it has its share of normal people.  But ones religious views have nothing to do with common sense (be the culprits from Westmont, UCSB, Santa Barbara City College or visiting from Yale)     Seeking comfort, many choose to suggest a miracle or the blessing of a diety for sparing certain structures on campus while others burned to a crisp.  Fire is caused by carelessness and is spread by winds with hypo-humidity over highly combustable fuel.    Fire is not aimed or directed by a supernatural diety.  It sounds as if the fire was an accident.  Nobody died.  Lots of people terribly effected.   Give the college credit for the way they handled the crisis so far.  If the investigation concludes that its students were responsible, let's give the college a chance to make ammends to the community.        

0
Barbara McPherson

It makes me wonder about the intelligence level of people who would light a fire in a place like that.  Surely they won't get off with a "sorry, it was an accident."

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Jordan Yerman
First Flagged at 5:39 AM, Nov 19, 2008 by Jordan Yerman
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (51)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from