Mumbai Attacks: 160 Dead, Over 320 Injured

by Rob Walker | November 28, 2008 at 10:00 am
4780 views | 33 Recommendations | 11 comments

Videos

Mumbai Attacks Condemned by Catholic-Jewish-Muslim Dialogue Group in Southern New Jersey

see larger video

sourced by slubetkin

Mumbai Attacks Condemned by Catholic-Jewish-Muslim Dialogue Group in Southern New Jersey

Photos

Taj Hotel

Taj Hotel

see larger image

uploaded by ramesh_lalwani

NowPublic Mumbai Channel A coordinated series of attacks took place across Mumbai on November 26, 2008. Follow updates on this unfolding story from NowPublic members, consult Mumbai resources and emergency information — and tag your stories, photos and videos "Mumbai" to see them featured here.
 

Update 7:13pm PST, 8:43am in Mumbai on Saturday November 29th

The Taj Mahal hotel is still not secure.

Smoke is billowing from the Taj Mahal hotel Saturday as Indian forces battle suspected Muslim militants making a last stand inside the Mumbai landmark.

Flames can be seen in several windows on the building's ground floor.

As fighting stretches into a fourth day, the luxury hotel has been wracked by hours of intermittent gunfire and explosions.

Indian forces are keeping up a counterattack with grenades and trading gunfire with what authorities believe is one or perhaps two militants holed up in the ballroom.

Update 2:47pm PST, 4:17am in Mumbai

The situation is still not resolved and fighting is still going on.


New explosions and heavy gunfire can be heard from the Taj Mahal Palace Hotel in Mumbai where up to 4 terrorists are still inside.

India is being blamed by some international media for their haphazard response to the attacks, despite how courageous they were:

Indians are used to their Government’s chaotic approach to security, but the first terrorist attack on their soil to target foreigners on such a large scale has exposed it to international scrutiny for the first time.

India’s media led the charge, panning the country’s intelligence and security agencies for failing to anticipate the attack, as well as a series of multiple bomb attacks on Indian cities this year.

“Mumbai Maimed, Nation Shamed” read a headline in the Mail Today newspaper.

“How many blasts, how many attacks, how many AK47s, how many hand grenades does a country have to face?” asked Prannoy Roy, the president and chief anchor of NDTV. “If ever there was a watershed, it is now.”

Update 2:20pm EST, 12:50 am in Mumbai

Twitter feeds and news sources say at least four gunmen may still be hiding out in the Taj Mahal Hotel, throwing grenades and firing at Indian troops.

Two americans are among 15 foreigners killed in the attacks. Alan Scherr worked with the Synchronicity Foundation , who were hosting a meditation conference at the Oberoi extension of the Taj Mahal Hotel, and his daughter Naomi Sherr died in the siege.

Alan and Naomi are survived by wife/mother Kia Sherr; you can express your  condolences to the Sherr family on a memorial guest book hosted by the Synchronicity Foundation.

16 police officers died trying to stop the men, while 11 gunmen were reported to have been killed.

"Hotel staff (Taj Hotel) told us that three-four terrorists have gone inside. We got the layout from the staff .We also wanted to know what all explosives were held by these terrorists," he said.

There was lot of smoke into CCTV room and entry was not feasible. The staff indicated that terrorists indicated have gone into new building of Taj. When we tried to enter into the building they started to fire and one commando was injured," he said.

Two Americans from Virginia were among the 160 people killed in the attacks on Mumbai, India. Kia Scherr told CNN her husband, Alan, and daughter, Naomi, died in the siege.

A single gunman is holed up at the Taj Mahal hotel, while India security services cleared the Oberoi hotel earlier. The Jewish center has been cleared, however five of the hostages are reported to be dead.

The death toll is up to 160 people at this point, and at least 15 of those were foreigners who were apparently targeted directly.

The death toll from Wednesday's attacks in nine locations was 160 -- including three Germans, two Americans, an Italian, a Briton, an Australian and one Chinese among the at least 15 foreigners killed -- with a further 327 injured. 

The killed Americans have been identified as Alan Scherr, 58, and his daughter Naomi, 13, from Virginia. They were visiting India with a meditation group and died at the Oberoi.

Maharashtra state official Bhushan Gagrani said the death toll is expected to rise further and includes civilians, military personnel and police, but not the attackers.

NowPublic staffer Sanjay Jha has been covering the attacks extensively and has posted numerous stories covering different angles:

Indian TV reports are suggesting that the Nariman House encounter had come to an end, However, Mumbai police commissioner Ghafur has said the operation is not yet over.
The terror attack in Mumbai is going to further deepen the hostile relationship between two South asian nuclear armed nations.
"Hotel staff (Taj Hotel) told us that three-four terrorists have gone inside. We got the layout from the staff .We also wanted to know what all explosives were held by these terrorists," he said.

There was lot of smoke into CCTV room and entry was not feasible. The staff indicated that terrorists indicated have gone into new building of Taj. When we tried to enter into the building they started to fire and one commando was injured," he said.

Timeline

There are a number of timelines out there showing what information has been learned so far - that a group of at least 20 gunmen arrived by small boats around 9pm local time and began carrying out separate, co-ordinated attacks throughout the city.

There is also a video timeline here.

The exact sequence of events remains unclear, but security personnel are establishing a picture of how the operation was planned and executed.

One of the first targets was the Chhatrapati Shivaji railway station, where at least two men fired automatic weapons and threw grenades at crowds of people waiting in the main hall.

Shooting starts at Chhatrapati Shivaji rail station, one of the world's busiest, handling thousands of passengers each day.
The attacks began around 9:20 pm, when two terrorists armed with AK rifles entered the passenger hall of the Chatrapati Shivaji Terminus railway station, opened fire and threw grenades,[1] killing at least ten people.[3] Two terrorists held fifteen hostages, including seven foreigners, in the Taj Mahal hotel.[33]

Member stories:

A number of NowPublic members have been writing stories about the attacks ever since it happened. You can find more in our Mumbai channel:

Jasmine Bhurji was one of the first to be gunned down during the Mumbai attacks Wednesday night.  She was a Mumbai resident managing the five-star Oberoi Hotel, having the sad fate of working the front desk that night.
Some reports seem to indicated that British citizens were involeved in the Mumbai attacks.
As the enemies of Pakistan are tightening noose around the only nuclear Islamic state to disarm it on the pretext of being "a failed" state, the Pakistan government has acceded to the request of Indian Prime Minister Mahmohan Singh to send the chief of Pakistan's prime intelligence agency -- Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) -- to India to help investigate the Mumbai attacks.
Advertisement
Jarrett Martineau
Jarrett Martineau
flagged this story as Breaking

at 11:03 on November 28th, 2008

Rob Walker, thanks for getting this story out so quickly. It will now show up on the home page for four hours. If new developments justify it, I'll renew this flag for another cycle.

Rachel Nixon
Rachel Nixon
flagged this story as Breaking

at 15:32 on November 28th, 2008

Rob Walker, thanks for getting this story out so quickly. It will now show up on the home page for four hours. If new developments justify it, I'll renew this flag for another cycle.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
yona loriner

Wow very scary

0
ryanjohnr

This attack can give a message to the people of Mumbai to very observant of what is the happening of their place. And if there is unusual report directly to the police.

0
dunkelberg

CNN/IBN via cnn.com says there are conflicting reports as to whether all terrorists have been accounted for.

Fire still is burning at the Taj Hotel.  Explosions shortly after dawn seemed to spark the fires in the lobby and on the first floor.




0
dunkelberg

CNN/IBN via cnn.com reportingone terrorist shot as he was in window to throw a grenade.  Originally reported as someone who jumped, media says now was a terrorist.

Fires continue to burn at the hotel, but are under control.



0
dunkelberg

"Two terrorists have been killed." head of operation.

0
Amy Judd

Thanks for the updates

0
dunkelberg

Final chapter is a room-by-room search, looking for hostages, terrorists posing as hostages, bodies, explosives or whatever.

0
Scrivener

Alan Scherr, the 58-year-old former UMaryland art prof who was killed in attacks along with his daughter Naomi... am trying to confirm if it's the same Alan Scherr I knew as a boy growing up in Wilmington, DE.   The picture looks like an older version of the friend I remember.  So sad.  I have scoured the web and cannot find a complete bio on him.  The Delaware News-Journal dos not list a phone number anywhere I can find on its web site, not even for news tips.  The website for his Synchronicity Foundation does not give his birthplace.

Can any fellow NP contributor supply a phone number for the newspaper so I can call them?

Having just read Alan's web site, there's a poignant back story here that no one has done yet.  Maybe I will, tomorrow. 

Knowing the odds, I believe it is highly likely that this is my old friend.  I am so saddened by this unspeakable tragedy...


0
Milieunet

Latest news: everything is clear. All terorist are dead and everything is safe.

0
moi plaatjes

This picture is taken almost a year ago, luckely I wasn't around during the madness.

moi plaatjes has contributed a photo to this story.

0
KULDEEP CHAUHAN

I m suggest all of u please don't kill this bastered because after death he doesn't fill pain

We will do that Tadpao is kutte ko jitna Tadpa sakte hai hum.My suggestion is this.

 

Thanks

Kuldeep Chauhan

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

NowPublic on Facebook

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

kate
First Flagged at 10:06 AM, Nov 28, 2008 by kate
These members have powered this story:

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (33)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from