A Nuclear deal law for US, A Treaty for India

2008-10-09 13:03:52 - US in fiscal sunnami wants badly a deal to revive their economy .123 agreement eventually allow American businesses to have a share of India's 100 billion dollar nuclear pie and India looks for an opportunity to nuclear trade with other countries for their rapid progress but  do the nuke deal a complete durable work out for the two biggest democracies in long run.
Absent of Winding up procedure,artbitration heads, from the two nation on their disagreement, absent clause for even pity disputes not mentioning make the agreement irks the opposition.

Bush signed the legislation on Indo-US civil nuclear deal and made a law.This nuke deal is if US law then two nations are bind with US law or International laws and do India laws have anything in case of windingup procedure of this deal or any two authorities from the two nation has the right to hammer out the differences.

Left parties today slammed the Indo-US nuclear deal maintaining that there was a "wide gap" between the Indian and the US governments' understanding of the deal.

CPI leader D Raja said while Washington considered 123 agreement to be governed by the Hyde Act, the Atomic Energy Act and other American laws, New Delhi was of the view that only 123 agreement was binding.The signing of the deal can be seen as a result of "mutual desperation," he said.

"While Manmohan Singh (PM) wants to show some achievement at the fag end of his tenure, the Americans are desperate to help the military- industrial establishment at a time when US is passing through a mega financial crisis," Raja said.

Mr. Bush assured India of fuel supply and reprocessing rights of the spent fuel subject to IAEA safeguards.

The big brother dominate theory to prevail in the name of International law. Is Bush signing Indo -US civil nuclear agreement as the nuclear trade between the two great nations or its dragging the young brother.Will the International law be applicable to both countries or the national law of one nation to prevail on India.Who will reign,the Hyde act,Atomic Energy Act or American law ,do India has any stake to hold its say in the time of differences, disputes.disagreement on matters at time of execution,currency of agreement or else to call off.

Congress hailed the signing of legislation into law by Bush, asserting that the Indian nuclear programme would be intact.

BJP and Left parties today said that history will prove that the accord was a "defeat" for India with Washington remaining "silent" on nuclear testing. American nuclear companies are waiting for the massive Indian market to open up for their revival, he said "they see the Congress-led UPA government helping them in this.

"Nobody knows what the economic cost of this deal will be for India. It will simply be huge...It will have very serious consequences for India and its future," Raja said.

http://www.pr-inside.com/a-nuclear-deal-law-for-us-r852396.htm