NP Rank:
The Obama Administration Mishandled the Flight 253 Incident
Some critics may say that hindsight is always perfect and any forethought is impossibly unpredictable without knowing all the facts. For starter, the security of a nation and her people should be a concern for all Americans regardless of their political leanings and stripes.
A quick review of the attempted bomber on Flight 253 incident and the ensuing events has led to more troubling questions than answers. The Obama administration's silence is not a sound strategy to "calm" the public, but instead reflects another disconcerting missed opportunity in leadership. The Office of the US Presidency is 24/7 even if the President wants to have a relaxing vacation, however deserving.
Customarily, the nation turns to its president whenever there is a national incident, however benign, to hear the Commander in Chief's assessments. Since the President is on vacation, the task is left to his Department of Homeland Security Secretary, Janet Napolitano to be the voice and face of the Obama administration.
Over the weekend, countless Americans watched and listened in dismay, as Secretary Janet Napolitano declared in an oddly jubilant manner that “the system worked.” The “system” as Ms. Napolitano referred to, in fact, did not work because it took average citizens and a foreign visitor to subdue successfully, a would-be bomber in the Airbus 330 jet. None was working for the Department of Homeland Security at the time.
It was disturbing enough that the Secretary claimed credits for all the things that went right, but that she was steadfastly dismissive of the warning signs of the terror suspect. She stuck to her position even when challenged by journalists who asked her why her department did not put this terror suspect on a no-fly list?
At a glance, the signs were enough to be deduced by any person: Mr. Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab was traveling on a one-way ticket paid in cash, without any luggage, the British authority had already rejected his visa application, the suspect’s father, Dr. Alhaji Umaru Mutallab had expressed concerns to the US Embassy in Lagos, Nigeria about his son’s potential terrorist activities, and the suspect's name appears on the Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment (TIDE).
The older Mutallab, as at the time of filing this report, had just left his Katsina hometown for Abuja to speak with security agencies, family sources say. According to the family members, Mutallab has been uncomfortable with the boy's extreme religious views and had six months ago reported his activities to United States' Embassy, Abuja and Nigerian security agencies.
In fairness, it took Secretary Napolitano a full day to realize her follies after the public railed against the nonsensical phrase, "the system worked." The President also came out of seclusion to talk to the public, which by then, had already read and heard from a plethora of domestic and international news available in prints, online, and television.
Evidently, the administration including Ms. Napolitano did not consider any of the above-mentioned signs as significant enough to warrant any meaningful concern or measure to stop Mr. Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab from boarding the plane in Amsterdam.
Ms. Napolitano insisted that there weren't any valid reason to update the Terrorist Screening Data Base (TSDB) based on the TIDE list. In this advanced technological age, the process of data analysis and updating should take minimal manpower, time, and effort.
Further, it appeared that the US Embassy in Lagos did not communicate with its London colleagues since the latter issued a multiple-entry visa to Mr. Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab. A flagging or revocation of his US visa entry would have been helpful.
To date, neither the US Embassy in London nor US Embassy in Lagos has provided any explanation. The US State Department has not issued any statement concerning an investigation to this glaring lack of communication between its two embassies.
The public does not expect the US Homeland Security Secretary to be well versed in the ramifications of Al Qaeda's fluid international operations and favored locations such as Yemen, Somalia, and Sudan. The public, however, does expect the Homeland Security Secretary to be a well-informed representative of the US government in the absence of the President.
Further, the public does not need to hear the White House Press Secretary Gibbs saying that the President is "on top of things" and recounting the number of security briefs and video conference calls. That is to be expected as part of the job, just as the public also expects the office of the presidency and administrative branches to function without whining about the responsibilities and hard work.
It is hoped, with due respect, that once the President is reinvigorated from his vacation, he will be a tad more nimble to handle arising problem(s) and better prepared to reassure the American public on a timely manner.
Silence was not a satisfactory response to the public who voted the President into office.
-----
Note: Some of other NP posts related to Flight 253 incident were hyperlinked in this Op-Ed.
------
Department of Homeland Security
Crowd Power
-
A. Tran
New York, New York, United States
Recommendations (56)
-
Yuliya Talmazan
Burnaby, Canada -
Amy Judd
Vancouver, Canada -
Rhonda J Mangus
North Tonawanda, New York, United States
-
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
Barry ORegan
Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada -
Rory Cripps
New Port Richey, Florida, United States -
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpoke
Redwater, Alberta, Canada -
snuffysmith
Washington D.C., D.C., United States







Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (25)
at 13:31 on December 29th, 2009
Um, yes I think we can safely say the system did not work.
I thought he was on a no-fly list already? Or was he on a watch list? (I've been away for a few days, am a bit out of the loop, sorry)
I also think one of the big warning signs was that he paid for this ticket in cash, that's pretty suspicious to me!
Good piece, I enjoyed the read!
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Yuliya Talmazanat 13:44 on December 29th, 2009
A very interesting point. Thanks for this.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 14:07 on December 29th, 2009
Hi Yuliya,
Thanks for your read and comment on my Op-Ed.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 15:39 on December 29th, 2009
Hi Amy,
Thank you for your read and comments.
The suspect was on the TIDE list, but DHS deemed the elder Mutallab's warning was not valid enough to be added to the TSDB, which is the no-fly list.
Never mind about the fact that the UK had rejected the suspect's visa application, while the US Embassy in London issued a multiple-entry US visa to the suspect. The US Embassy in Lagos evidently didn't communicate the elder Mutallab's warning to its colleagues in London. The visa could have been flagged by US officials in Lagos, and in Amsterdam before Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab boarded the plane.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Iffy (not verified)at 13:57 on December 29th, 2009
Leaders should not be buck passers: that should be the first sign that a leader (Napolitano) needs to be fired. The right response should have been: "The system failed: I shall now spend all my waking hours to find out how and why, and I will then report back to you, the people, what I find, and I will also give you a time-specific plan as to how I will remedy this situation."That's what leaders do who are honest and have integrity. By covering your ass like she did, Napolitano proved herself worthy of a mid-level union shop steward job, and that is about it.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 15:41 on December 29th, 2009
Thanks for your read and comments, iffy.
at 14:06 on December 29th, 2009
Did Obama Respond Too Late to Terror Plot? Critics Assail President ABC News The Obama administration has come under fire from critics who said the president waited too long to address the nation publicly about the Christmas Day terror plot, and that his administration has not been tough enough on terrorism.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 14:09 on December 29th, 2009
Hi Snuffysmith,
Thanks for your read and the link to the ABC News piece.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpokeat 14:24 on December 29th, 2009
Napolitano yesterday started out by blaming the Bush Administration for the in place rules. Her interview with FOX a video which is in my story yesterday is very telling. When asked if she had reviewed the policy since she was Secretary of DHS she hummed an hawed about three times making comments as , "I'm aware of it, to a half acknowledgment that she had reviewed it.
She didn't seem to see the difference of action prior and after the event. Her highlight was that DHS had been able to notify 128 flights already enroute from Europe. So what?
Removal of blankets and not permitting passengers to use the washroom during the last hour must have been an impressive knee jerk reaction.
Yep Iffy, mid-level shop steward, if that, Obama needs to tell her to resign.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 15:38 on December 29th, 2009
Hello Albertacowpoke,
Thanks for your read and comments.
Ms. Napolitano's interviews about the incident have been disastrous, and up until yesterday, she was the face of national security on behalf of the Obama administration. Mr. Gibbs was just a mouthpiece since he repeated everything Ms. Napolitano said.
The administration has fumbled and bumbled its way through this incident so far. It is not reassuring that the President came out again today, just to say all the things that the public has already known - well, he acknowledged that they've made mistakes.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
Karl Gotthardt - albertacowpokeat 16:28 on December 29th, 2009
Not only did the President repeat things that were public knowledge, they have been discussed to the nth degree on every media outlet and all the blogs. I agree.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 15:40 on December 29th, 2009
Thanks for your read and comments, Queenshart.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
anon comment (not verified)at 16:35 on December 29th, 2009
www.schneier.com/blog/ --------------------------------------------------- Bruce Schneier is an internationally renowned security technologist and author. Described by The Economist as a "security guru," he is best known as a refreshingly candid and lucid security critic and commentator. When people want to know how security really works, they turn to Schneier. ------------------------------------------------ (He was on Rachel Maddow last night and makes a lot of sense, IMO,
at 17:30 on December 29th, 2009
Yep, when crap hits the fan, it is typical governments will use any idiotic methods to wipe themselves clean of blame.
at 20:54 on December 29th, 2009
I saw "O" looking like he was repeating something someone had told him to say! Then he left!
That was it! He fuxked up! If he had added at the end of his brief statement, "And I am going to find someone to blame" it would have had the same impact. After this, he will have to do better than just pull a rabbit out of the hat!
Remember!!!! "When I become Prezudent, every soldier will be home in the US in six months! AND YOU CAN TAKE THAT TO THE BANK!"
Had the plane detonated and plunged to the ground, in a ball of fire! What would the bog "O" have said then? Whom would he have blamed? Or would he have said, "And I am looking for someone to take responsibility!"
The Commander-in-Chief should do as President Reagan was always prompted to do! Do not say anything! Just read the the cards out loud! This young coloured boy from Nigeria has bitten the greatest actor in the world, right in the Az!
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 09:12 on December 31st, 2009
Thank you everyone for your read and discussions; and extra thank you to those who recommended my Op-Ed.
Happy and Safe New Year to everyone.
at 11:54 on January 1st, 2010
Shadow of 9/11 Is Cast Again - Scott Shane, New York Times. The finger-pointing began in earnest on Wednesday over who in the alphabet soup of American security agencies knew what and when about the Nigerian man charged with trying to blow up an airliner. But the harshest spotlight fell on the very agency created to make sure intelligence dots were always connected: the National Counterterrorism Center. The crown jewel of intelligence reform after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the center was the hub whose mission was to unite every scrap of data on threats and suspects, to make sure an extremist like Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, the would-be bomber, would never penetrate the United States’ defenses. “NCTC is supposed to be the nerve center,” said Amy B. Zegart, who studies intelligence at the University of California, Los Angeles. “It’s the fusion center of all fusion centers. So if something was missed, that’s where the blame is going to go.” Officials at the counterterrorism center - a small agency in a modern glass building in suburban Virginia - maintained a stoic silence on Wednesday, noting that the review ordered by President Obama was still under way. But those who led the major studies of how the United States government failed to prevent the Sept. 11 attacks watched the unfolding story of the Christmas Day attack with growing dismay.
at 19:53 on January 1st, 2010
Abdelmutalib's Act of War
from Counterterrorism Blog by Walid Phares
Source: counterterrorismblog.org
at 20:00 on January 1st, 2010
U.S. Will 'Find And Fix' System's Vulnerabilities -- Janet Napolitano, USA Today
Friday's attempted terrorist attack against Northwest Flight 253 near Detroit is a powerful illustration that terrorists will go to great lengths to try to defeat the security measures that have been put in place since September 11, 2001.
While we took swift action immediately following last week's incident at airports around the country and throughout the world, our defenses should never have allowed this individual to board a plane bound for the United States. The administration is determined to find and fix the vulnerabilities in our systems that allowed this breach to happen.
Read more
at 20:00 on January 1st, 2010
More News On Homeland Security
Obama on Napolitano: Official: POTUS has full confidence -- Politico
US will 'find and fix' vital security gaps: Napolitano -- AFP
Homeland chief Napolitano says airline security system failed -- USA Today
Napolitano Reverses Course, Says Air Security Did NOT Work -- Wall Street Journal
Fingerpointing Begins in Aftermath of Failed Terror Attack -- FOX News
Who Should Be Held Responsible for Security Failures in the Christmas Day Bomb Attempt? -- ABC News
Burton calls for Napolitano's scalp -- The Politico
National Post editorial board: Napolitano must go -- National Post
You're Doing a Heck of a Job, Janet -- Richard Grenell, Huffington Post
Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano is not fit for position, recent events prove -- Michael Daly, New York Daily News
Protect us from Homeland Security? -- Ballard J. Powell, Chicago Tribune
at 20:02 on January 1st, 2010
EDITORIAL: While Terrorists Plot, The FAA Parties -- Washington Times
The congressional pork barrel comes before public safety.
While a terrorist was plotting to kill Americans over the Christmas holidays, what was the Federal Aviation Administration doing? Why, spending $5 million on a three-week-long Christmas party, of course.
A series of seminars in Atlanta officially were aimed at training managers on a new air-traffic-controller contract but degenerated into one big bash. According to ABC News, the seminars didn't even cover half of the 100 new provisions in a contract that went into effect two months ago.
Read more ....
at 20:03 on January 1st, 2010
Cartoonist Michael Ramirez comments on the failed Christmas bombing of Flight 253.
at 20:09 on January 1st, 2010
A Guide to the Blame Game Following Failed Terror Attack
A Guide To The Blame Game Following Failed Terror Attack -- Wall Street Journal
Keeping track of who is blaming whom for the failures in U.S. intelligence that allowed Nigerian national Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab to almost blow up a U.S. airliner last week can be confusing, so Washington Wire compiled a guide in an attempt to make some sense of the Washington blame game starting with President Barack Obama.
According to the president, it was the whole system that failed. “But what’s also clear is this: When our government has information on a known extremist and that information is not shared and acted upon as it should have been, so that this extremist boards a plane with dangerous explosives that could cost nearly 300 lives, a systemic failure has occurred. And I consider that totally unacceptable,” Obama said Tuesday from Hawaii, where he is vacationing with his family.
Read more ....
at 13:32 on January 11th, 2010
Shifting the blame from the security folks at the airports to "Obama", maybe we can blame Obama for all the world's problems - that way folks don't have to deal with issues
- Sign In or Join to post comments
A. Tranat 10:17 on January 24th, 2010
Thank you to additional comments > Nice to hear from you, B. Zelley, thank you. It is not about blames, but rather pointed to glaring mishandling of the situation, which even President Obama has readily admitted as such.