Obama Campaign Following Lincoln Blueprint

by jhaber | March 1, 2008 at 06:52 am | 1731 views | 12 comments | 32 recommendations

It is rather silly to compare, as some have done, Barack Obama to Abraham Lincoln. But it is fair to compare their means of assent in the nomination process. How is Obama on the cusp of defeating the party establishment? This is not the first time an upstart candidate came out of nowhere to win a party nomination. There are a few interesting examples in American history to compare it to, but perhaps none are as tantalizing as the republican nomination for President in 1860.

Both Lincoln & Obama ran against the establishment party candidate, who in 1860 and 2008 were from New York. Like Hillary Clinton, William Seward’s march towards the nomination looked like a lock. In fact, in Seward’s hometown (255 miles away from Clinton’s home), cannons were already positioned and ready to be fired in celebration of Seward’s nomination.

Unlike Clinton & Seward, Lincoln and Obama were new to national politics, and had little enemies. It was thought that in nominating Lincoln, the Republican party would have a greater chance of getting more votes in places it was weaker, such as the West. The Obama campaign argues it can get more votes out of the South, and can bring out young people in droves to vote.

Obama’s speaking abilities have drawn much adulation, as did the stoic speeches of Lincoln. Both held elected office for 8 years in the Illinois state legislature, and two years in Washington before running for President. Each used vivid imagery on the campaign trail to drive home their message - from ‘the rail splitter’ to ‘yes we can.’

After starting off slowly, Lincoln began to gain delegate votes at the convention. Many of the more partisan delegates were offended by Seward’s tactical move to the move center wing of the party and instead looked elsewhere. The Lincoln campaign staff moved deftly to secure the support of key delegates. Then there was a swift sea change in support and his opponents – Seward, Salomon Chase, and Edward Bates, began to lose steam, and the party rallied behind the lanky man with the broad smile yet unfamiliar name.

Years of failed leadership have left the United States in a quagmire. The world opinion of the country had fallen, as did its economy. There was no doubt that this was a time of war. The outgoing President was extremely unpopular, and thought by many to have failed in a time of crisis. Is this 1860 or 2008?

It’s both. History has a funny way of repeating itself.

Some have called an Obama/Clinton or Clinton/Obama ticket for the democrats the “dream ticket.” It’s called the “dream ticket” because in reality most assume it will not happen. But consider the cabinet of Lincoln - all his former rivals for the nomination became his top officials. Despite personal animosity towards each other, they found a way work together and steer the country through some treacherous times.

That’s the kind of leadership and sacrifice we could use today.

recommend Add a comment
Rachel Nixon
  • super editor
Rachel Nixon
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:08 on March 1st, 2008

jhaber, interesting comparison - thanks.

amyjudd
  • super editor
amyjudd
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 08:57 on March 1st, 2008

jhaber, I like this story. Very interesting observation.

0
Karen Hatter

This is indeed an interesting piece but, in order for any correlation to be drawn, the most glaring fact, dismissed through omission, must be discarded out of hand, that being, when Lincoln made his run for president of the United States, people of African descent were enslaved and not allowed to participate in the political process. It would seem inclusion of that crucial historical fact makes the comparison a non starter. 


Here's knowing that the final historical scenario that was Lincoln's will not be realized or be repeated in this time.

0
jhaber

karen - i appreciate your comment but completely disagree with your argument. The article above compares the similarities of the two men and the similarities of the campaign. The piece makes no attempt to compare the changes in racial relations or the progress that African Americans have been in the interregnum of time between the two campaigns. That, as im sure you would agree, could be a whole other article in and of itself.  The point of the article is that two men, of two different eras, had some similar experiences and used their abilities to secure the nomination, and when you examine it through that prism, it is a compelling comparison.

0
Karen Hatter

Jhaber, my previous comments, posted in an effort to be brief, were meant to highlight what would seem, to many, to be the most profound point to be used as a springboard for the thrust of your piece, with all other elements falling in line after such an evaluation.


A man, who came to be known as the Great Emancipator, his campaign and the campaign of a man of African descent, fast forwarding 148 years into the future, whose candidacy is focused on gaining his party's nomination, in an against all odds mode of occurrence.


The status of Americans of African descent in America prior to the cessation of slavery, that is without being duly convicted of a crime, is a key issue in any discussion or discourse that relates to matters of the past when contrasted with matters in the present or matters in the future to come.  

0
quietdeluxe

Photograph of the Flatiron building in Wicker Park; Chicago, IL; featuring Large portraits of Barack Obama and Abraham Lincoln.

Please note that I don't know the identity of the person who made these paintings. (If that person is YOU, make contact and I will give proper credit!)

quietdeluxe has contributed a photo to this story.

0
mimi227

This photo was taken in Lincoln, Ne on Friday, 08/02/2008 after Michelle Obama spoke at the Lied Center for Performing Arts on the University of Nebraska Campus.

mimi227 has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Screwy Hoolie

Taken near Wicker Park in Chicago, IL.

Screwy Hoolie has contributed a photo to this story.

cynthia yoo
cynthia yoo
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 20:13 on March 2nd, 2008

jhaber, I like this story. It's good stuff.

0
janafaustus

This photo was taken at the "O" Street Obama rally in Lincoln, Nebraska. Pictured is Lincoln resident Amy Lage.

janafaustus has contributed a photo to this story.

0
Aster-oid

Let me take this opportunity and thank the NowPublic staff for inviting my photo of Lincoln's statue, for the purpose of illustrating this article. Although I do follow American politics as much as I can, I am not in a position to offer any kind of rally valid insight, since I live in Greece. On the other hand, when I was in Washington D.C. in late January and visited the Lincoln Memorial, certain comparisons between Lincoln and Mr. Obama did cross my mind and this is the basic concept behind this photo, which was published immediately after my return in Greece, on my Flickr page... http://www.flickr.com/photos/aster-oid/ I am glad my concept was kind of reflected in this article by jhaber. It seems I am not alone in making these comparisons!..

Aster-oid has contributed a photo to this story.

Jarrett Martineau
  • super editor
Jarrett Martineau
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 19:13 on March 3rd, 2008

Fascinating analysis, thanks for this.

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

March 1, 2008 at 06:52 am by jhaber, 1731 views, 12 comments

Crowd Power

Rachel Nixon
First Flagged at 8:08 AM, Mar 1, 2008 by Rachel Nixon
These members have powered this story:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from