In one town, Gazans yearn for previous Israeli presence

by dfrankfurter | August 17, 2008 at 01:43 am
216 views | 4 Recommendations | 9 comments
In one town, Gazans yearn for previous Israeli presence Mawassi residents say life was better before 2005, when they were part of an Israeli settlement enclave. Few can find work now.
recommend This comment thread is now closed
judyinjerusalem
judyinjerusalem
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 01:48 on August 19th, 2008

dfrankfurter, I like this story. It's good stuff.

1
Heritage

Here's a little more information from the story:



Still, despite their economic hardships, most Gazans insist that they prefer life here without the Israelis.

But in Mawassi – a mixed ethnic Palestinian and Bedouin town that was completely isolated from the rest of Gaza inside a Jewish settlement enclave – it's a different story.

Israel may have withdrawn from Gaza but it still has complete control over Gaza's air space and territorial waters, as well as movement in and out of Gaza, including overseeing all crossing points between Gaza and Israel.

Gaza is the World's Largest Prison. It has 1.5 million inmates.

Gaza has become a prison, say church and human rights groups

Though Israel withdrew from Gaza in August 2005, leaving it in the hands of the Palestinian Authority, it still holds what a coalition of Israeli human rights groups said in a November statement is "decisive control over central elements of Palestinian life in the Gaza Strip".

This includes complete control over Gaza's air space and territorial waters, as well as movement in and out of Gaza, including overseeing all crossing points between Gaza and Israel.

The Israeli rights coalition includes groups such as B'Tselem: the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, Rabbis for Human Rights, and the Israeli sections of Amnesty International and Physicians for Human Rights. The groups acknowledge Israel's right to defend itself and that all parties in the current conflict, including Israel and Hamas, the Islamist movement now in control of the Palestinian legislature, must respect international humanitarian law.


1
David Frankfurter

We all feel for the suffering of the every day citizen of Gaza.  If Hamas and its proxies stopped attacking the crossing points every time they were opened, and stopped smuggling weapons instead of food and medicines, and stopped hijacking supplies for use by militants instead of the citizens .... then the average \gazan would be better off and not yearn for Israeli return.

1
Heritage

"Still, despite their economic hardships, most Gazans insist that they prefer life here without the Israelis."

The average Gazan does not want the Israelis to return.

The Israeli Occupation/siege of Gaza is the root cause of violence. If you treat people like animals, they will act like animals.

Do you condone the collective punishment of 1.5 million people in Gaza?

1
dfrankfurter

Your comments are a little detached from reality.  Israel tried to disengage from Gaza - and was met with attacks on border corssings and constant barrages of rocket attacks on its citizens.  Even the European Union border crossing supervisors gave up & ran away.  These attacks are double war crimes - attacking civilans, and using civilians as human shields.  I do not condone collective punishment - nor do I condone war crimes.  What I do condone is legitimate action which is backed by international law to protect citizens from attack.  Especially when backed by a demonstrated desire for complete territorial withdrawal.  When the Gazan government genuinely seeks peace (not just a rearmament pause in hostilities) the Palestinian people will get almost everything that they want.

0
Heritage

Israel may have withdrawn from Gaza but it still has complete control over Gaza's air space and territorial waters, as well as movement in and out of Gaza, including overseeing all crossing points between Gaza and Israel.

In effect the disengagement created the world's largest prison. Israel also fires rockets in to Gaza at will, and enters whenever she deems fit. How can this be a solution for peace?

Collective punishment is a war crime. Sealing Gaza's borders is not legitimate action backed by international law. Your comments are a little detached from reality.

It's so ironic that the drafters of the Geneva Conventions wrote the section on Collective Punishments with Nazi attrocites in mind.

1
dfrankfurter

By the way - why don't the Gazan people use their border with Egypt?

0
Heritage

Egypt does what the US and a nuclear armed Israel tells it to do.

0
Heritage

dfrankfurter, do you have any friends in Gaza? Perhaps you could contact Sameh Habeeb...

Here's a related story from NowPublic's Sameh Habeeb who reports from Gaza City, Gaza Strip,

Gazans live back in the Middle Ages

The suffering and the torture could be a reason for nation's collapse or fall down. However, it could be a way to achieve victory or some of its commencements. I always gather my ideas to penetrate this suffering to tell the story of my people through my words.


I having nothing but a strong will to write and tell the untold story of my people in the besieged Gaza strip. I truly became addicted on reporting daily sufferings encountered by 1.5 million besieged in Gaza, the New Biggest Concentration Camp!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

judyinjerusalem
First Flagged at 1:48 AM, Aug 19, 2008 by judyinjerusalem

Most Recommended Stories in World

Recommendations (4)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from