Police still dismiss rape victims

by generaldecay | June 24, 2009 at 10:07 am
304 views | 48 Recommendations | 9 comments

Quote

"... everyone knows most women and girls who report rape can't be believed".

This article indicates that, not only is the Criminal Justice System in England and Wales unlikely to achieve a criminal conviction in rape cases, the very 'rape champions' it has introduced are openly hostile to rape victims. This perspective is summed up in the following paragraph.

Police forces across the UK and Wales have all been allocated "rape champions" to oversee the roll-out of their sexual violence action plans, to implement good practice guidelines and to tackle the "negative mindsets" within their forces. Along with specially trained officers, they have received sexual violence training and are part of the initiative that we have been assured will help to address the culture of disbelief that we know, from what women tell us, still exists. However, at the Home Office violence against women consultation in the east of England in May, a rape champion for one of the police forces in the east of England stated openly that "everyone knows most women and girls who report rape can't be believed".

How prevalent these views are is not clear - they could be held by one 'rape champion' or by 100s of them. My inkling, from working with many Criminal Justice professionals, is that it is a widely held perspective. It's little wonder, really, that so many women are fearful of reporting sex crimes and that conviction rates for rape are as a low as 3% in some parts of the UK.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
1
Care

Something need to be done to stop this foolishness. 

1
Babel-Fish

Its very easy to blame the police in such issues however in approximately. 60% of rape cases there is in fact a lack of witnesses and its the woman's word against the man's about condolence of sex. The case is therefore is considered as being weak. If no human where programmed without the ability to lie then of course the case would be strong. But reality is people of both sexes can and many do lie.    

Angie Conroy  the author of the Guadian article is a spoke person for Rape Crisis:   http://www.rapecrisis.org.uk/contact.html and it worries me to see in her article no name mentioned concerning  "a rape champion for one of the police forces in the east of England stated openly that "everyone knows most women and girls who report rape can't be believed". she should of quoted this source!  In my opinion, it leads to possible thoughts of anti police propaganda. It does look like the home office is trying to do something about the problems concerning rape.

We would not want to see men convicted falsely concerning rape and justice really needs to be balanced. The point is clear rape cases are presently won and men do go to jail for such an offense because there are witnesses and good evidence. 

I have a feeling Angie Conroy wants her organization to have more power and push for every rape case weak or strong to go through court. The problem is that most of the weaker cases will see the rapist be declared not guilty, because the evidence is too weak.

Unfortunately that is the reality its a very sad one and such organization will be attacking the police and government to improve the system and I am glad they do, but there again their actions never should lead to anyone being charged convicted because of lies. These cases need good evidence and if there is none then its just word against word. 

I feel that women should be given confidence of taking a rapist to court when there is very good evidence and should not be told its hopeless but the facts that the case is too weak if its a case of word against word. It need balance and the police and rape crisis organizations should work together to get such a balance. 




0
Amy Judd

This is terrible

0
generaldecay

I agree Amy. IMO , there has been an institutional hostility to rape victims for as long as I have been studying such things.

Thanks for the recommendation and comment.

0
Spydermonkey

I did not realize that sexual crimes in the UK were dismissed so casually, in the states, an accusation will be investigated usually.

Thanks for the story

0
Babel-Fish

I have seeded a friends article concerning rape that broadens the view.

http://my.nowpublic.com/world/rape-case-more-difficult-accused  it shows a differ light on rape cases.

0
generaldecay

Spydermonkey, do you happen to have any figures on conviction rates for rape cases in the US?

0
Grace H

They are not something to be proud of, at least not in Houston.

0
Spydermonkey

link to Bureau of Justice Statistics

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Tina Kells
First Flagged at 10:53 AM, Jun 24, 2009 by Tina Kells

Related Stories

Recommendations (48)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from