Prejudice blamed for slow governmental response to flooding in Bihar region

by Tina Kells | September 3, 2008 at 09:49 am
659 views | 19 Recommendations | 7 comments

Was India slow to warn residents in the flood ravaged Bihar region of rising water levels after the Kosi dam burst? Controversy has been brewing after Goa minister Ravi Naik made racist remarks about people from the poverty stricken area.

Does it hurt when Goa minister Ravi Naik said that people of Bihar are coming across and bringing poverty, when Raj Thackeray said that the people of Bihar must get out of Maharashtra? When racism and prejudice is directed against the people of Bihar, does it hurt and one feel that there is something that one must do for the state?

Residents of Bihar are claiming that no warning was given of the growing flood danger. In fact, some people have told reporters that officials assured them there was no danger at all.

"I do not know where to look for them, there is no one to help me," said the 24-year-old woman, sitting at a government relief camp in Bihar, one of India's poorest states.

The floods have claimed at least 90 lives, displaced more than three million people, and destroyed 250,000 acres of land. Flooding began when a dam in the Kosi river burst last month and was made worse by torrential rains. It is the most devastating flooding the region has seen in over half a century.

Some media reports say the death toll has been seriously understated by the Indian government and is actually 10 times higher than the official figures. Questions are being raised about the warning given the people of Bihar and the apparent mismanagement of relief efforts. Shock has been expressed about the disregard the matter was given by some Indian officials.

But the tragedy is not entirely nature's doing. Experts and aid agencies blame government ineptness for not only failing to warn people but also for mishandling relief.

In the most shocking example, SOS fax messages sent by engineers at the Kosi dam warning of impending disaster were ignored in Bihar's capital Patna, the Mail Today newspaper said.


Human error is being blamed for some of the tragedy, as warnings from engineers at the Kosi dam went ignored by officials in Patna, the capital of Bahir. The bureaucrat in question is said to have been on vacation when the flooding began and had no deputy to take up his duties. Local media is now calling for charges of criminal negligence against the responsible officials.

recommend This comment thread is now closed
duo
duo
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 16:00 on September 3rd, 2008

Tina Kells, I like this story. It's good stuff.

My goodness!  It was like reading about Katrina all over again!  When I first glimpsed your headline, in fact, I thought it might be an article revisiting Katrina, because Friday was the third anniversary of that disaster.  Sorry to see that the Indian government is plagued with similar problems.

Mary

Paschen
Paschen
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 18:07 on September 3rd, 2008

Tina Kells, I like this story. It's good stuff.

0
Sanjay Jha

There is some good news for the millions of flood affected People in India. Water has receded in some part.

The flood situation in Bihar's Supaul, Madhepura, Araria and Saharsa districts on Wednesday eased a little further with the discharge in the Kosi river, which has played havoc after changing course, coming down marginally.

However, fresh areas were inundated in Purnia district, one of the worst-hit by the deluge, as several panchayats were submerged in Naugachia sub-division of Bhagalpur district where the Kosi breached its embankment near Dhodia village on Wednesday morning.

According to water resources department sources, the discharge in Kosi from Barahkshetra in Nepal was 1.11 lakh cusecs at noon, marginally less than 1.18 lakh cusecs on Tuesday.

Water is receding in various blocks of Birpur subdivision in Supaul district as also in Madhepura, parts of Saharsa and Araria districts, the sources said.

Meanwhile, nearly 5000 army, navy and air force personnel continued to evacuate the marooned and reach them relief.

Sources in the disaster management department said 30 army columns comprising about 3360 men with 300 motorboats, four navy columns consisting of 180 personnel and 12 boats and 635 personnel of the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) were assisting the state administration in the rescue and relief operation.

Ten IAF helicopters pressed into service have together airdropped 69,192 food packets so far, while 1,39,485 packets were reached to those marooned through boats apart from the cooked food being served at relief camps.

So far over 6.48 lakh people have been evacuated to safe places, of whom, more than 2.52 lakh are taking shelter in the 257 relief camps set up by the government.


Barry Artiste
Barry Artiste
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 03:06 on September 4th, 2008

Tina Kells, I like this story. It's good stuff.

White Noise
White Noise
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 06:03 on September 4th, 2008

Meanwhile in our own backyard...

Can you say ethnic cleansing, the GOP way ?

BIG EASY TO BIG EMPTY: THE UNTOLD STORY OF THE DROWNING OF NEW ORLEANS

Investigative reporter Greg Palast uncovers the clandestine political agendas and hushed-up eyewitness reports surrounding the devastation of New Orleans while visiting the city to witness the reconstruction process firsthand. The troubling facts that Palast uncovers during his visit to New Orleans stand in stark contrast to the hopeful spin of the nightly news; not only has the population of the city dwindled, but reconstruction seems to be woefully inadequate and suicide rates are steadily climbing. This is the untold story of New Orleans, conveyed by an independent voice and featuring exclusive footage.

PART 1 

http://freedocumentaries.org/theatre.php?filmid=128&id=751&wh=1000x720

PART 2

http://freedocumentaries.org/theatre.php?filmid=128&id=1024&wh=1000x720

PART 3

http://freedocumentaries.org/theatre.php?filmid=128&id=1025&wh=1000x720

EXECUTIVE RESUME
http://whitenoise.webnode.com/

Meanwhile...

"We are watching a poorly staged rendition of Wag the Dog , interpreted for the morbidly stupid and performed by the criminally insane." - Jules Carlysle

Rhonda J Mangus
Rhonda J Mangus
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 14:33 on September 4th, 2008

Tina Kells, I like this story. It's good stuff.

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from