Rethinking foreign occupation

by morris.sadek | October 18, 2009 at 03:21 pm
97 views | 2 Recommendations | 6 comments


national american coptic assembly 
washingtonDC
Mr. Morris Sadek-ESQ President 
Many scholars criticized the foreign occupation of Egypt during the past 200 years. However, I suggest looking at the occupation from a different perspective. I believe the occupation helped in building Egypt’s infrastructure and established the science of Egyptology.


When Napoleon arrived in Cairo, he brought with him a wide array of engineers and archaeologists. After the three years that he spent in Cairo, the city would never again be the same Oriental town that it had been. The French left a legacy that is written all over the European parts of Cairo. Their tastes were mainly of a French middle-class influence and desire. The French invasion of Egypt also had an important effect because of the publication of Description de l’Egypte, which detailed the findings of the scholars and scientists who had accompanied Napoleon to Egypt. This publication became the foundation of modern research into the history, society and economics of Egypt.


In 1875, Egypt had its first civil legal system when the government succeeded in establishing the Mixed Courts. These courts had jurisdiction in civil cases involving Egyptians and foreigners, or foreigners of different nationalities, and had both foreign and Egyptian judges, who administered judicial codes based on French law. By that time, the social consequences of the agrarian and political changes inaugurated by Muhammad Alī were clearly appearing. The projects of the Suez Canal as well as the first Egyptian railroads were almost completed.


The impact of western values and principles on the Egyptian “Eastern” society was clearly manifested in the way Egyptians think and behave. They began drawing their ideas from not only Islamic and Eastern traditions, but also western sources and schools of thought.

recommend Add a comment
0
djermano

You expect the people who were killed and maimed accept your analysis? Even though it was 200 years ago....time seems to make people forget the real tragedies of those times, and go on to believe that the War helped change society...I find it incredible people and you believe that nonsense. In fact usually after War...people do the best they can to recooperate, and revive to make the reminder of war disappear...It has nothing to do in believing War is a good thing or occupation is justified.  I think you would believe me if it was you who got his leg blown off back then....I bet you would have a different opinion than the propaganda you wrote in this article. How calleous and crude can you get? No wonder the world is in a constant paralysis even in this modern time.....

The Rev

0
Hugh Askew

I suppose it would be better to have left Egypt mired in the 16th century. A life expectancy of 30 years, most of the population illiterate, and still at the mercy of any outside power.

That would be wonderful indeed.

0
Sputnic

Any French heritage mr Sadek ?

0
djermano

I suppose Hugh...you never heard of giving a helping hand? Helping to educate... and inspire.

The Rev

0
Hugh Askew

Certainly, Rev.  Do both frequently.  Also give a helping hand thru both time and money. My wife and children do the same. 

What has that to do with the state of Egypt? Do you seriously think that, absent the French and the British, they wouldn't have spent another 150 years in abject poverty, some in slavery, most dead before old age because of disease and poverty?


0
djermano

I was referrng to how nations treat other nations Hugh. I do not think War is an answer to relieving poverty.. The French and British were not so interested in helping the people of Egypt in more to how conquest would help them in the scheme of things. And it depends on how you define poverty... Britain certainly took control of India...and many would consider India still a poverty problem...a long with the French's involvement in IndoChina, Vietnam. I would claim War has the opposite effect..

The Rev

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

Hugh Askew
First Flagged at 2:46 AM, Oct 19, 2009 by Hugh Askew
These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

Recommendations (2)

Most recently recommended by:
 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from