by
BelaynehKassaWubie | June 16, 2010 at 12:33 am
161 views | 4 Recommendations |
2 comments
There is an initiative in Africa that rewards leaders of African nations for their peaceful power transfer and good governance. This reward is USD 5 million. The objective seems good as most African leaders die for retaining their power. But is this right in principle?
In my opinion, this initiative undermines peoples’ power to replace their leaders when they are unwanted. Not only does this undermine peoples’ power but also is an insult for the leaders themselves. It is only kids who can be tempted by something new and exciting. How can individuals leading nations influenced by monetary reward mechanism?
After all, the real promoter of individuals is intrinsic reward mechanism like thank you, recognition, popularity, respect, etc and not material reward. Specially, for leaders who had achieved their needs to a self-actualization level, it is hard to think that material rewards can encourage leaders for a peaceful power transfer and good governance. Of all, this initiative undermines the sovereignty of people and, thus, need to be discouraged.
Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (2)
at 01:24 on June 16th, 2010
"It is only kids who can be tempted by something new and exciting" - not true, many adults are as well.
"for leaders who have achieved their needs up to a self-actualization level" - Maslow's psychology is flawed, check my essay on that and other related matters at http://sites.google.com/site/ilyashambat/psychology - most of these leaders are not interested in self-actualization anyway, and even if they have achieved self-actualization they may find uses for money.
"the real promoter of individuals is intrinsic reward mechanism like thank you, recognition, popularity, respect, etc and not material reward" - that's true for people who are most interested in social standing, which is in no way everyone.
"this initiative undermines sovereignty" - same can be argued about American Red Cross and Medicins Sans Frontiers, but we aren't seeing these organizations being told to leave Africa.
at 04:11 on June 16th, 2010
Good point Ishambat. One size does not fit all situations either. Africa is full of vast differences and situations affecting capacity for change and improvement by various means. I don't know anything about Africa, I must say, other than the apparent.