Rider Alert Proves Available Technology Would Easily Prevent Chatsworth Metrolink Accident in San Diego

by panzerlawyer | September 21, 2008 at 07:47 am
178 views | 5 Recommendations | 7 comments

Photos

Rider Alert Proves Available Technology Would Easily Prevent Chatsworth Metrolink Accident in San Diego

Rider Alert Proves Available Technology Would Easily Prevent Chatsworth Metrolink Accident in San Diego

see larger image

uploaded by panzerlawyer

On September 15, 2008, the North County Transit District expressed its condolences to the victims of the Chatsworth Metrolink accident, in its “Rider Alert” and basically proved beyond a shadow of a doubt - perhaps not on purpose - that the Chatsworth Metrolink Train was negligent. On its online “NCTD Commuter Alert”, NCTD discussed the fact that the “commuter train and a freight train in the Chatsworth area of Los Angeles” would not have occurred if it had in place the same, cheap, basic safety program that is currently in place in San Diego.

Readers will recall that Metrolink admitted liability, and then later the spokeswoman for Metrolink Chatsworth, Denise Tyrrell, resigned, allegedly under pressure from her supervisors. The investigation into the Chatsworth train crash has so far uncovered that the Metrolink train engineer failed to “observe and obey a stop signal on the tracks just before the accident occurred”, the "Rider Alert" explains.

NCTD uses an operating contract partner, TransitAmerica Services, Inc., and has in place operating rules, procedures, and mechanical equipment that could have prevented the September 12, 2008, Chatsworth train crash. NCTD requires train engineers to call out all signal indications over the radio, as each signal is approached by one of their trains. NCTD rules also prohibit train engineers from using cell phones during train operations. NCTD also explained that “Adherence to these rules is regularly monitored and tested through field observations.”

NCTD in addition to the above, has mechanical equipment such as a “a built in audible warning system in the train cab.” And get this, when a train engineer doesn’t stop the train at a red train signal, THE TRAIN AUTOMATICALLY STOPS!! On top of that, the train dispatcher is automatically notified of the problem.

So basically, the Rider Alert proves that the accident could have easily been prevented with available technologies already being used in another California city. In other words, the "Rider Alert" proves Chatsworth Metrolink negligent!

recommend This comment thread is now closed
0
panzerlawyer

I appreciate your comment.  It seems the press missed the boat on  this.  San Diego Metrolink proved in an innocent rider alert this accident could have been avoided cheaply with basic failsafe procedures.

0
drrexdexter

Sadly, it looks like the only viable solution, since, evidently, the engineer forgot his GRADE SCHOOL training wherein he learned that a RED LIGHT MEANS STOP AND GREEN LIGHT MENAS GO.(I DO remember, so maybe I should have been driving the train-eh?)

0
panzerlawyer

@drrexdexter

Well.  In San Diego, they seem to realize that humans are fallible at least.



0
dunkelberg

This accident, more and more, just comes down to pure stupidity and arrogance.  That driver and transit authority saw no need to take simple precautions speaks volumes for the culture of that organization. 

I love the San Diego system, it was one of the highlights on a visit back to visit childhood hausnts.

Personally, the more ALL people stay off mobile phones on public transit, the happier I am.


0
panzerlawyer

Hear hear.

Paschen
Paschen
flagged this story as Good Stuff

at 05:25 on September 22nd, 2008


0
panzerlawyer

Thank you all!

This story was created over 3 months ago, the comment thread is now closed.

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from