NP Rank:
Right Wing Media Pundits Scoff at Stories of America's Uninsured
Since the debate over the Obama administration’s efforts to reform health care began, the atmosphere has been contentious, Democrats on one side, Republicans on the other.
Republicans have organized around the principle that if they are successful in defeating any planned health care reform supported by Democrats and President Obama, with Republican Senator Jim DeMint of South Carolina remarking in July 2009 that if health care reform is defeated, it would be President Obama's Waterloo, it would mean, calculating in their estimation, that the President and the administration would never recover politically from such a defeat.
Things really came to a boil during the summer of 2009, with various elements arriving at events advertised by those aligning themselves with the so called Tea Party movement, with many of the events sponsored by the health care insurance industry, displaying signs calling for watering the tree of liberty, a Thomas Jefferson quote regarding martyrdom, and arriving armed at planned health care townhall meetings where the President of the United States was scheduled to speak.
All during this time, a number of Democratic legislators, from the House of Representatives and the Senate, have shared a variety of stories underlining the difficulties facing their constituents as they face tough decisions regarding attending to the health needs of themselves as well as their families.
After President Obama’s Health Care Summit on Thursday, February 25, 2010, well known and popular Right Wing media pundits chose to ridicule or downplay the suffering and hardships confronting those in anecdotes shared by the representatives attending the summit with those in attendance at the summit and the American people.
At the health care summit on Thursday, February 25, 2010, Democratic Representative Louise Slaughter of New York shared the story of one of her constituents, prompting less than empathetic, compassionate commentary and responses from Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Laura Ingraham and other Right Wing pundits.
SUMMARY: Right-wing media figures have mocked Democrats' descriptions of hardships faced by their constituents who lack health insurance, including a story Rep. Louise Slaughter told about a woman who wore dentures that previously belonged to her dead sister. For example, Rush Limbaugh said, "So if you don't have any teeth, so what? What's applesauce for?"
Media conservatives ridicule the uninsured
Limbaugh: "What's wrong with using a dead person's teeth? Aren't the Democrats big into recycling?" Responding to Slaughter's account, which he called the "sob story of the day, Limbaugh stated:
LIMBAUGH: You know I'm getting so many people -- this Louise Slaughter comment on the dentures? I'm getting so many people -- this is big. I mean, that gets a one-time mention for a laugh, but there are people out there that think this is huge because it's so stupid. I mean, for example, well, what's wrong with using a dead person's teeth? Aren't the Democrats big into recycling? Save the planet? And so what? So if you don't have any teeth, so what? What's applesauce for? Isn't that why they make applesauce?
Glenn Beck remarked he hadn’t read anything in the Constitution about anyone being guaranteed teeth.
Laura Ingraham stated the Representative Slaughter’s constituent’s story “ …. won the Olympics of sob stories.”
Fox Nation referred to Representative Slaughter’s story as “summit insanity”.
Also at NowPublic:
Republicans Wrong, Reconciliation Used for Past Health Reform
An Allusion to Watering the Tree of Liberty
An Increasing Potential for Right-Wing Terror? Prof. Says 'Yes' by Susan Marie Kovalinsky
NowPublic on Facebook
Crowd Power
-
Karen Hatter
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States -
kentness
Roseville, Illinois, United States
Recommendations (13)
-
Susan Marie Kovalinsky
Ledgewood, New Jersey, United States 
Anonymous user
-
Rhonda J Mangus
North Tonawanda, New York, United States -
Uwe Paschen
Narita, Chiba, Japan -
mudricky
Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom -
stejeb
United Kingdom -
YankeeJim
Arlington, Virginia, United States







Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (7)
at 13:16 on February 28th, 2010
I can see why the health insurance companies don't want change, I can why the drug manufacturers don't want change.
Everyone knows exactly why the Republicans would oppose it, even if it were the best thing for all concerned.
The thing I don't understand on this issue, as with so many issues the American people are at loggerheads about, is why Americans are so manifestly, obviously afraid of change.
at 15:19 on February 28th, 2010
To a large degree, Stejeb, the majority of the American public has short attention spans. They hear random information thrown out by the mainstream media, like the totally false idea of death panels being included in the health care reform bills.
Of course, no one talks about the monthly meetings/panels that meet at every insurance company that choose to deny coverage to millions of Americans each year. These monthly meetings are death panels to thousands of Americans.
Once some idea is implanted, mainly due to lack of time but, often do to reliance upon faulty information, the American public will go along with what has been heard most often and during this battle, as the Republicans and the Right Wing have loudly trumpeted all manner of untruths and nonsense, the President and the Democratic Party dropped the ball.
There seemed to have been some form of thought process and strategy, in addition to whatever other moves were implemented, that made the Obama administration decide that some of this idiotic stuff was so out in the far-out field of rational thought, most Americans would know it wasn't true but, I submit, they were wrong to believe that on any level, if that was ever the case.
The push back for refuting this stuff was too long in coming so now, here we are; the queen of the promotion of the theory of death panels, Sarah Palin, coming in second as a possible Republican candidate for president in 2012 at the CPAC conservative meeting, where at the same conference, there was a call for the return of the use of literacy tests for voting by Tom Tancredo, which were banned almost 45 years ago, because Barack Hussein Obama was elected president AND findings in a poll that indicate 53% of Republicans think Sarah Palin can do a better job as president than President Obama.
What a world, what a world!
at 15:37 on February 28th, 2010
Short attentions spans, no long view, and where the average intelligence, I bet is slipping.
at 15:59 on February 28th, 2010
God, let's hope not, Jim.
at 13:57 on February 28th, 2010
Roy, we always have "horrible headlines" about all public services, usually from the right wing press, many of the headlines have merit for their accuracy (occasionally).
The main difference though is we have one to write horrible headlines about. It hasn't stagnated what from it's lowly beginnings, it has changed, is changing and will continue to change to meet new challenges and problems.
It doesn't just chuck someone off the books because they are getting old or lost their job or have a recurring illness....our "cover" doesn't run out because we are no longer a profit to them.
And when the idea was first introduced by Aneurin Bevan in the 1940's guess who fought hardest against it? Yes, conservatives. okay there were a few skeptics within his own ranks, but it was the tories who fought it the hardest, and Tory voting Doctors who nearly sank it before it could begin.
You want to see horrible stories, go talk to the people who can't afford health care....oh, we don't have them here by the way.
at 14:28 on February 28th, 2010
Stejeb, there are a phenomenal amount of stories hardly ever heard if one extrapolates the odds of hearing of the hardships of one or more individuals who each in turn have been told, first hand accounts, of those having difficulty of receiving care in the health care system here in America.
I mentioned only a few of which I am aware in my narrative, This Shouldn't Happen in America, including the story of one of my dearest friends, a self employed craftsperson, physically removed from his local hospital for not having insurance.
He was thrown out of the hospital AFTER he was diagnosed with a life threatening condition that required heart surgery.
At the heart of all of this is the conservative's and Right Wing's dedication to doing nothing to reform health care in this country.
Whenever their party is in power, Republicans never seem to be able to make health care reform a pressing priority for more than a few items.
When the Democrats are in power, the conservative's and Right Wing Republicans block progess of any sort, bringing up tort reform over and over and EVEN now, with various tort reforms open for discussion or included, they can't support it.
During this current cycle of governance, after spending the entire time since President Obama and the Democratic Congress took control of the government railing that 'Obama is a socialist! He's gonna kill Grandma! He's not a real American! He wants to destroy America!', with these statements coming from elected Republican officials, the Republican Party has backed itself into a corner.
They either have to admit they were wrong to say those things, which in all probability they will NEVER do or, they must stick to the current script from which they're reading and that seems to be the ongoing game plan.
at 15:40 on February 28th, 2010
Obama will beat them at the game, I think. His gambit is do something, versus do nothing.