Sarkozy Berlin Wall Photo on Facebook: Was He There on Nov. 9?

by Scott Wu | November 9, 2009 at 10:27 am
389 views | 0 Recommendations | add comment

Photos

Sarkozy Berlin Wall

Sarkozy Berlin Wall

see larger image

uploaded by Sudha Krishna

French President Nicolas Sarkozy posted on his Facebook page a photo of him chipping away the Berlin Wall on the night of November 9, 1989. Sarkozy posted the photo yesterday for the 20th anniversary of the fall of Berlin Wall. However, critics casted doubt and accused him of "reinventing history".

Photo: Nicolas Sarkozy taking down the Berlin Wall.

Photo description on Facebook in French:

Souvenirs de la chute du Mur de Berlin, le 9 novembre 1989.
J’étais alors secrétaire général adjoint du RPR. Le 9 novembre au matin, nous nous intéressons aux informations qui arrivent de Berlin, et semblent annoncer du changement dans la capitale divisée de l’Allemagne. Nous décidons de quitter Paris avec Alain Juppé pour participer à l’événement qui se profile. Arrivés à Berlin ouest, nous filons vers la porte de Brandebourg où une foule enthousiaste s’est déjà amassée à l’annonce de l’ouverture probable du mur. Là, par le plus grand des hasards, nous croisons un jeune élu français que nous connaissions, à l’époque spécialiste des questions de défense : François Fillon. Nous filons ensuite vers Check Point Charlie pour passer du côté est de la ville, et enfin confronter ce mur dans lequel nous avons pu donner quelques coups de pioche. Autour de nous, des familles se rassemblaient pour abattre le béton. Certaines venaient nous parler pour nous expliquer leurs sentiments, leurs ambitions nouvelles, et partager leurs émotions après des décennies de séparation. La nuit s’est poursuivie dans l’enthousiasme général : les retrouvailles du peuple allemand sonnaient la fin de la guerre froide et le début d’une période de grande liberté en Europe.
C’est cette liberté que nous défendons toujours avec l’Europe, et que nous fêtons 20 ans après.

English version as translated by Google:

Memories of the fall of the Berlin wall, November 9, 1989.
I was then Secretary General of the RPR. On November 9 in the morning, we are interested in information coming from Berlin, and seem to announce the change in the divided capital of Germany. We decide to leave Paris with Alain Juppé to participate in the event looming. Arrived in West Berlin, we careen toward the Brandenburg Gate, where an enthusiastic crowd had already gathered at the announcement of the probable opening of the wall. There, by the merest chance, we meet a young French elected we knew at the time expert on defense: François Fillon. We then seams to Check Point Charlie to pass on the east side of town, and finally confront this wall where we could give some pickaxes. Around us, families gathered to break down the concrete. Some came to speak to us to tell us their feelings, their new ambitions, and share their feelings after decades of separation. The night continued in the general enthusiasm: the reunion of the German people sounded the end of the Cold War and the beginning of a period of great freedom in Europe.
It is this freedom that we stand still with Europe, and we are celebrating 20 years on.

Critics argue that Sarkozy was in Paris that night and the earliest he could arrive at the wall was November 11th. Council records show he was celebrating the anniversary of Charles de Gaulle that night.

Critics also find it unlikely for him to have foreseen the fall of Berlin Wall with limited information.

Journalist Alain Aufray, of Liberation newspaper, said : ‘Nobody in Paris, not even in Berlin, could tell that the Wall was going to fall...

‘Radios and televisions in West Germany had began to describe what was happening at 8pm... It was not until 11pm that Berliners in the west began to gather infront of the border.’

Aufray also pointed out that the West Berliners only started to take down the Wall the next day on November 10th.

Furthermore, Alain Juppe, whom Sarkozy mentioned to had traveled with, said in a radio programme that he was in Berlin on November 11th, not 9th.

A closer look at Sarkozy's account shows that he did not actually say he arrived Berlin on November 9, 1989. He merely said they were interested in the change taking place in Berlin on that day. In the next sentence he said he decided to leave Paris without specifying when the date was.

Does the original French text say the same things?

Comments (0)

Add a comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.

What is NowPublic?

NowPublic lets people work together to cover news events around the world.

Find out more

Crowd Power

These members have powered this story:

Related Stories

 

closeSign in to NowPublic

is reporting from