NP Rank:
Scapegoating of Jews and Wall Street
In even the more respectable circles, there has been much clamor about Jews on Wall Street. The Jewish bankers have been blamed for the Wall Street scandals and collapse. There is only one thing that needs to be said to people who have such beliefs, and it is as follows:
If Jews are responsible for Wall Street collapsing in 2008-2009, then they are also responsible for Wall Street growing in capitalization ten times since 1980. Which means that a vast portion of America's boom that preceded the crisis of 2008-2009 is owed to the Jews.
Of course we will not hear such things from the people involved in this attack. The prosperity of 1980s and 1990s are supposedly the merit of America - particularly of the people who most loudly claim to be America and the rest of America (including the Jews) not to be. Supposedly it's "money talks BS walks"; supposedly it's "America: love it or leave it"; supposedly America being prosperous is the favor of God or a product of Republican policies or a result of American people's common sense and virtue and responsibility. So that when the same system, run by the same people, has a crisis, then it could not possibly be the fault of the same people who got credit for the prosperity in the first place. No. It must be damn Jews.
The Jewish people have a long and rich history of encountering vicious ingratitude for their contributions to the countries in which they have resided. America has had strong influences to guide it away from this path, the result being that America hosts more Jewish people than does Israel and has richly benefited from their contributions - in science, in medicine, and in business. There is an easy logical step to refute all the arguments of the Jew-scapegoaters, and I hope that more people use it in dealing with people who have such beliefs. But history being the guide it may take more than logic to correct their destructive effects in society.

Most RecentMost Recommended Comments (17)
at 03:08 on May 6th, 2011
I recommend the story just to say that I haven't heard a single word blaming Wall Street troubles on "Jews." There have been some bad actors on Wall Street and there is enough to spread among the American demographic without targeting a single group.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
matt stefanovich (not verified)at 07:13 on May 6th, 2011
then you do not listen carefully enough. when I am quiet I hear such whispering :) I am surprised, yankee jim, you are propably isolated. Me, myself I do not say, that Wall street is jewish territory, that would be simplification, but this particular minority plays an important role in this section of N.Y.C. If w watch the first movie Wall Street with very energetic {younger} M. Douglas as Gekko, we have to admit, that Gekko has some jewish specifics or better to say manners. Yet is is not underlined and what I say can b untrue. Gekko has a face and charakter of hungry, vicious, businessman who doesnt like value system of a cowboy or tradional puritan man. He hates conservative postures and traditional elites as well as aristocrats. On the other hand Gekko could be greek as well, not only jewish. Onassis was greek and he would understand pople like Gekko very well. same materialistic kind of person. I agree with Ilia, that people who brought crisis upon America did sometimes before, for. ex. in the 80ties a fortune for the same country. Greed can be good, but only sometimes. Americans have a hope, as well as european union. If Japan suffers some more damages, some more economical troubles due to different reasons, it can be a new start for US. economy. but its hard to predict. who knows?
at 07:34 on May 6th, 2011
YankeeJim is deaf you know. I only hear whispering when I am plugged in. Sometimes I hear it at the back of the church.
at 19:17 on May 7th, 2011
Matt, things going badly in Japan would hurt US and Europe more than it would help them. The way the global economy works is, the more money in one place the more money everywhere - as market for the products of the other countries; and the less money in that place the less the market for others' products.
I haven't seen the film you're talking about, but I know a number of successful stockbrokers and none of them are Jewish. One is even from Iran.
at 03:57 on May 6th, 2011
I have heard the "crash was engineered by Jews" theories on many occassion.
A load of drivel if you ask me, but people are always quick to put all the blame onto a single group.
On a lighter note....Where have you been ishy?
Been awhile since you posted.
at 04:57 on May 6th, 2011
I like Ishy and appreciate your comments FaithlessTemplar.
at 05:01 on May 6th, 2011
What would be the motive? Who would benefit and how?
at 16:37 on May 6th, 2011
Templar, I've had to go offline for a while because our computer was being hacked. I'm back online now, but I'm not posting as much as I used to because there are lots of things I have to do.
at 16:48 on May 6th, 2011
sorry to hear about that , ish.
But welcome back.
- Sign In or Join to post comments
matt stefanovich (not verified)at 15:16 on May 7th, 2011
hackers can be nasty, I bet.. ishambat, do you watch hockey championships ? I wish luck to Sweden, Russia and Czechs. unfortunately slovak hockey team lost everything. propably domestic environmnet harmed our players :)
at 15:19 on May 8th, 2011
I don't know much about what's going on in the hockey world. The only sports events I watch consistently are the Winter Olympics and the World Cup.
at 05:29 on May 6th, 2011
Well Said.
Be aware when some one does something against the law in the U.S. as well as other locations, if it was perpetrated by a Jew it is almost always mentioned. If a congressmen or businessman is arrested, no one mentions that they were catholic, protestant or even Buddhist. But if they happen to be born Jewish then it is mentioned. Hmmm.
If you pay careful attention it is amazing how often this form of anti-Semitism takes place in the national media.
Just one slight correction. I am pretty sure there are more Jews now living in Israel today then the U.S..
- Sign In or Join to post comments
"thirty-aught-six" (not verified)at 17:20 on May 6th, 2011
What Everyone Knows;
Jews are evil clannish connivers who secretly run the world
Muslims are all terrorists
Christian's, C.E.O's and businessmen in general are all right-wing extremists
The worker is exploited
Liberals are all closet socialist commies
White people are all racists
Black people are all crackhead gangbangers
Southerner's are all rednecks
Feminist are all dykes
Men are all rapist
Women are all social victims
Criminals are all innocent
etc., etc., etc,....
at 19:18 on May 7th, 2011
As they say, "artificial intelligence is no match for natural stupidity"
- Sign In or Join to post comments
"thirty-aught-six" (not verified)at 14:12 on May 8th, 2011
a pigeon-hole, -comfortable but tight fit suitable for surrendering individual thought. :-)
- Sign In or Join to post comments
matt er (not verified)at 16:54 on May 8th, 2011
Except for thirty-aught-six, a real gathering of disinfo specialists who create the canard and then discuss it.
at 13:32 on May 12th, 2011
Absolutely not, people have been writing crap about Jewish bankers being supposedly responsible for Wall Street crisis for ages.